Top 13 paella in Bushwick NYC
Welcome to the world of paella in Bushwick, NYC! This vibrant neighborhood is home to a fusion of cultures, including Spanish cuisine. One standout dish you must try is the traditional paella, a classic Spanish rice dish filled with saffron-infused flavors and an array of fresh seafood, meat, or vegetables. Savor the taste of Spain right in the heart of Bushwick.
1. La Isla
Family-owned restaurant with a warm and welcoming atmosphere

La Isla offers a delicious paella that is one of the best in Brooklyn, featuring perfectly cooked rice and a delightful mix of seafood. The paella dish I enjoyed was scrumptious, with a generous portion size and well-prepared ingredients.
Both meals showcase the restaurant's expertise in Spanish cuisine, with carefully selected and cooked seafood combined with high-quality rice. The portion sizes ensure that customers get value for their money while enjoying a satisfying and flavorful meal. The shared key point is the high quality and great taste of La Isla's paella, which makes it stand out in the Brooklyn food scene.
TOPICS
- Mexican Cuisine
- Cheap Eats
- Downtown Spots
Relate link
2. Mi Bella Dama
Wood-fired oven, homemade sauces, family-owned restaurant

Paella, a traditional Spanish dish, was tried and the experience was mixed. One opinion found the paella to be just average, lacking the authentic Spanish flavor that was anticipated. However, another viewpoint strongly praised the paella, highlighting the freshness of the seafood and the perfectly cooked rice.
In summary, opinions differed on the paella's quality, with one person expressing disappointment and the other expressing great satisfaction. The seafood and rice were mentioned as standout components, but only one reviewer found them to be exceptional. Further discussion could focus on what may have caused the discrepancy in the evaluations or examine what ingredients and cooking techniques contribute to an authentic Spanish taste in paella.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Mid-Range
- Downtown Spots
3. Aris Pollos A La Brasa
Authentic Spanish cuisine, family-owned and operated, friendly atmosphere

The paella in question had a generous portion size, satisfying the diner's appetite. However, its saltiness was a bit too strong for their personal preference. Despite this, the dish was still enjoyable.
In a separate instance, another person tried the paella and deemed it as one of the best they've had in Brooklyn. They highly recommended the dish to others, indicating its high quality and delightful taste. The saltiness of the paella did not seem to be an issue for this particular diner.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Budget-Friendly Eats
- Downtown Spots
- Vegetarian Options
Relate link
4. Sazon Nuñez
Family-owned restaurant with a focus on traditional recipes and warm hospitality

Sazon Nuñez offers a delicious paella that leaves a lasting impression. The portion size is generous, ensuring that customers get their fill of this traditional Spanish dish. The taste is authentic, delivering an enjoyable and memorable eating experience.
The paella at Sazon Nuñez is packed with flavor and features fresh, high-quality seafood. This authentic Spanish dish receives high praise from customers who appreciate its delicious taste. It's a highly recommended dish for anyone looking to treat their taste buds to something special.
TOPICS
- Mexican Cuisine
- Budget-Friendly Eats
- Downtown Spots
- Breakfast
5. Arepera Guacuco in Bushwick
Small, family-owned restaurant with warm atmosphere

The food from this establishment is known for its varying quality - when it's good, it's delicious and well-prepared, but when it's bad, it's disappointing. Both the in-house dining and delivery options have received high praise, with customers raving about the pabellon arepa and the mariscada seafood soup.
The pabellon arepa is a popular choice, and many recommend adding avocado to enhance the flavor. However, the mariscada seafood soup has been a surprise standout, with its unexpected deliciousness impressing many. While the quality of the food can be inconsistent, the flavors and dishes themselves have received much acclaim.
TOPICS
- Mexican Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Cheap Eats
Relate link
6. Alex's Luncheonette
Family-owned business with a cozy and welcoming atmosphere

Alex's Luncheonette is known for its exceptional paella, which is a must-try for anyone visiting the establishment. The seafood in the paella is always fresh, and the dish is packed with flavor. I had the opportunity to try the paella and can attest to its delicious taste. The generous portion size ensured that I left feeling satisfied and content.
The authentic taste of the paella at Alex's Luncheonette is one of its most impressive features. Each bite is filled with a medley of fresh seafood, create a burst of flavor that is both unique and satisfying. The recipe must be carefully crafted to achieve this level of authenticity, adding to the dish's overall appeal. Whether you are a seafood lover or simply looking to try something new, the paella at Alex's Luncheonette is not to be missed.
TOPICS
- Mexican Cuisine
- Budget-Friendly Eats
Relate link
7. Barchaa Latin Fusion Cuisine
Uses traditional Spanish cooking techniques with a Latin twist, located in Brooklyn, NY

The paella I tried was delicious, with a spot-on cooking and an abundance of flavor. The seafood in it was incredibly fresh, adding to the overall taste experience.
Despite the paella being slightly too salty for my personal preference, its quality was still evident. The freshness of the seafood and the care taken in cooking it resulted in a tasty dish.
TOPICS
- Fusion Cuisine
- Happy Hours
- Hidden Gems
8. D' Montazo rest
Family-owned restaurant with a cozy and welcoming atmosphere, using a traditional Spanish paella pan for cooking.

The paella dish was tasted by two different individuals, resulting in contrasting opinions. One reveled in the exquisite taste of the fresh seafood and the harmonious blend of flavors. Such a delightful experience has left them eager to return for another serving. On the other hand, the other individual found the paella to be merely passable. The rice was overcooked, and there was a noticeable absence of seasoning, making it far from the best paella they have ever tried.
Despite the differing evaluations, both parties were in agreement that the paella contained seafood and that the rice was a significant component. The first patron had a favorable impression of the dish, complimenting its fresh seafood and balanced flavors, whereas the second patron had a less positive experience, pointing out the overcooked rice and inadequate seasoning.
TOPICS
- Mexican Cuisine
- Budget-Friendly Eats
9. Empanada City in Bushwick
Holds weekly paella nights, Large portions, Cozy and trendy atmosphere

A wonderful experience was had today at Empanada City, known for its delicious and fresh empanadas. The food there is truly exceptional, with one standout being their tasty and fresh empanadas.
A popular choice among customers is the Nutella smoothie, which has gained a reputation for its deliciousness. However, the pizza burger didn't seem to be as well-received by visitors. Despite this, the overall food quality at Empanada City is highly recommendable.
TOPICS
- Mexican Cuisine
- Social Gatherings
- Cheap Eats
- Downtown Spots
10. Alegria Bar and Grill
Cozy and intimate atmosphere, live music performances, and a wide selection of wines and cocktails.

Alegria Bar and Grill serves a delicious paella that should not be missed. The portion size is generous, providing a satisfying meal for those who try it. One can expect the taste to be authentic, providing a genuine experience of this traditional Spanish dish.
The paella at Alegria Bar and Grill is a standout meal, boasting a perfect cook and a delicious blend of seafood and spices. Its quality makes it a must-try for anyone visiting the establishment. The dish is a testament to the restaurant's ability to serve excellent food that reflects its commitment to providing a memorable dining experience.
TOPICS
- Fusion Cuisine
- Breakfast
11. Sol Latino

TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Mid-Range
- Downtown Spots