Top 14 Tex Mex restaurants in Little Italy NYC
Tex Mex restaurants in Little Italy NYC are a surprising yet delightful culinary fusion. Amidst the traditional Italian eateries, a few establishments have introduced a unique blend of Mexican and American cuisine, creating a distinct and tasty experience. These Tex Mex restaurants in Little Italy offer a diverse menu, from sizzling fajitas to cheesy enchiladas, adding a exciting twist to this iconic Italian-American neighborhood.
1. Benito One
Offers a relaxed and festive atmosphere

Authentic Italian cuisine in the heart of Little Italy.
The food at this establishment is highly regarded as authentic Italian cuisine, with large portions that leave customers satisfied. Despite being a bit pricey, many reviewers believe that the quality of the food justifies the cost. The pasta served is freshly made, with some reviewers even describing it as artisanal, made with natural ingredients.
However, there are mixed reviews when it comes to the butteriness of certain dishes. While some customers find certain dishes to be too buttery, others rave about the same dishes, highlighting the delicious and rich flavors. Overall, the pasta dishes are a standout, with the freshness and natural ingredients providing a authentic and enjoyable dining experience.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Mid-Range
- Downtown Spots
Relate link
2. Da Gennaro
Family-owned and operated since 1987, fresh ingredients, homemade recipes

Family-owned and operated since 1984, serving traditional Italian dishes in the heart of Little Italy.
The food at the establishment is highly rated by customers, who rave about its delicious taste and high quality. Many customers have shared positive experiences with the staff, noting that they are attentive to special requests and provide helpful recommendations.
However, there seems to be some inconsistency when it comes to wait times. While some customers have mentioned being seated immediately, others have had to wait for service. This inconsistency may be a source of frustration for some customers and could potentially impact their overall experience and satisfaction with the establishment.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Dinner
- Downtown Spots
Relate link
3. Los Tacos No.1
Taqueria with communal seating, Handmade blue corn tortillas, Cotija cheese

Unique flavors and spices, family-owned business
For Tex Mex enthusiasts, Los Tacos No.1 is a top destination for tacos and quesadillas that deliver an authentic taste. The carne asada tacos are a standout, made with high-quality ingredients that make for a delicious meal.
If you're a fan of Tex Mex restaurants, Los Tacos No.1 is a must-visit location. Known for their exceptional tacos and quesadillas, the carne asada tacos are a customer favorite. With a commitment to using top-notch ingredients, Los Tacos No.1 provides an authentic dining experience for fans of the cuisine.
TOPICS
- Mexican Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Downtown Spots
4. Casa Bella
Live Mariachi music on weekends; family-owned and operated since 1977

Handmade pasta and mozzarella cheese, extensive wine list.
Mexican food is highly regarded for its delicious taste, with standout dishes such as breakfast tacos, rich and creamy white queso dip, and sizzling chicken fajitas. Complimentary chips and salsa often accompany meals, adding to the overall dining experience.
The manager, Michael, and the servers at this UES establishment are exceptional, providing top-notch service. The food is consistently excellent, and the frozen margaritas are a popular choice among patrons. This Mexican eatery is highly recommended for those seeking delicious food and exceptional service in the Upper East Side.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Downtown Spots
- Mid-Range
Relate link
5. IL Cortile in Little Italy
Family-owned for over 50 years, providing exceptional service and a wide range of dishes.

Offers a romantic and charming atmosphere in the heart of New York City
Yellow Rose is a great restaurant to consider if you're in the mood for Mexican food, particularly Tex-Mex. The restaurant is located in the East Village, making it a convenient choice for those living in or visiting the area. On a recent Saturday night, I had the pleasure of dining there with my boyfriend and was impressed by the quality of the food.
During our visit, I tried the steak tacos and chicken enchiladas, and both were delicious. The steak in the tacos was perfectly cooked and full of flavor, while the chicken enchiladas were creamy and satisfying. While I don't typically eat Mexican food in NYC, Yellow Rose has changed my mind and shown me that there are excellent options available outside of California. I would definitely recommend giving it a try if you're in the mood for some tasty Tex-Mex cuisine.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Corporate Events
- Celebrations
6. Oxomoco
Modern interior design, extensive mezcal selection, wood-fired cooking

Upscale Mexican restaurant with a lively atmosphere and unique dishes
Oxomoco is a must-visit restaurant in Brooklyn for anyone looking for exceptional Mexican cuisine. The authentic flavors and unique wood-fired cooking techniques set it apart from other Mexican restaurants in the area. Standout dishes include the lamb barbacoa tacos and chard Caesar salad, as well as the Smoked Mango appetizer, Hiramasa Aguachile, and tostadas.
Located in Brooklyn's Greenpoint neighborhood, Oxomoco has earned its Michelin star with its impressive selection of tequila, mescal, and Mexican wine. The service is top-notch, with friendly and efficient staff who contribute to a welcoming and inviting atmosphere. In addition to the delicious food, Oxomoco offers a range of tasty drinks that are the perfect complement to the flavorful dishes. Whether you're in the mood for tacos, tostadas, or something in between, Oxomoco is sure to deliver a memorable and satisfying dining experience.
TOPICS
- Mexican Cuisine
- Downtown Spots
- Mid-Range
7. Grotta Azzurra Restaurant in Little Italy
Family-owned and operated since 1981, using traditional recipes and cooking techniques.

Family-owned restaurant with a rich history and traditional recipes
Grotta Azzurra Restaurant, established in 1908 by the Davino family, is an iconic Italian eatery inspired by the blue grotto on the isle of Capri. Notable figures such as Enrico Caruso and Frank Sinatra have famously dined at this splendid restaurant. The design aims to evoke the beauty of one of the world's most famous caves, providing a unique and captivating dining experience.
The restaurant offers a beautiful atmosphere, delicious food, and lovely staff, ensuring a memorable visit. With a diverse menu that includes several vegetarian options and dishes marked with dietary restrictions, Grotta Azzurra Restaurant caters to various dietary needs, making it an inclusive and accommodating establishment. This renowned Italian eatery continues to provide exceptional service and an enchanting dining experience, carrying on its rich history and tradition.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Celebrations
- Mid-Range
- Downtown Spots
Relate link
8. Zia Maria Little Italy
Live mariachi music on weekends

Family-owned and operated since 1985, serving classic and innovative dishes
Zia Maria is a family-owned restaurant and pizzeria that provides authentic Italian cuisine, utilizing fresh ingredients to bring the authentic flavors of Italy to New York. In addition to their food offerings, they also have a fully-stocked top-shelf bar. The interior of the establishment boasts a contemporary design, creating a welcoming and comfortable atmosphere for patrons.
During a visit to Zia Maria, customers can expect to enjoy delicious Italian food, including a variety of pasta dishes and pizza. The seating is comfortable, and the atmosphere is pleasant, making it an ideal spot for a nice meal. The staff at Zia Maria are attentive, ensuring that guests are well taken care of throughout their dining experience.
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- Celebrations
- Italian Cuisine
- Downtown Spots
Relate link
9. La Mela
Offers a rooftop dining area with views of the city.

Family-owned and operated since 1970, using traditional Italian recipes
La Mela is a restaurant that offers high-quality food and a more relaxed atmosphere compared to more well-known spots. It is slightly less touristy and less expensive than other options, while still delivering excellent dishes that are sure to impress. The restaurant's service is a standout feature, with staff who are quick, friendly, and polite. They greet customers with a smile, creating a welcoming and pleasant dining experience.
The dining area at La Mela is modern and attractive, adding to the overall positive atmosphere. The wait staff are not only polite and friendly but also go above and beyond to ensure that guests have a great meal. From the moment you enter the restaurant to the moment you leave, the service is top-notch, making La Mela a great choice for anyone seeking a delicious and enjoyable dining experience that won't break the bank.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Vegan Options
- Downtown Spots
10. La Bella Vita restaurant in Little Italy
Family-owned and operated for over 20 years, using traditional recipes and techniques.

Family-run restaurant since 1992, using traditional Italian recipes and ingredients.
The reviewers rave about the amazing and fantastic atmosphere of the place, which is conveniently located near China Town. The location is great, and the restaurant offers both indoor and outdoor dining. The review also mentions a simple menu and fantastic sangria.
The food at this establishment was thoroughly enjoyed by the reviewers, with highlights including the Alfredo, ravioli, pizza, and caprese. The review concludes that they had a good time with good food, suggesting an overall positive dining experience.
(Note: The summary is limited to 800 characters as requested.)
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Downtown Spots
- Vegetarian Options
Relate link
11. Buona Notte
Friendly staff, cozy atmosphere, and live mariachi music on weekends.
Family-owned and operated since 1989, using traditional Italian recipes
The service at this establishment is generally regarded as friendly, efficient, and attentive. Guests often comment on the high level of service they receive. However, there have been some complaints during busy times when the service can be less than satisfactory.
The food is one of the highlights of this establishment, with guests describing it as good, authentic, and delicious. The pasta dishes in particular have received high praise from many guests. However, a few guests have expressed concern about the prices, finding some of the dishes to be a bit expensive. Overall, the food is a strength of this establishment, although they may want to consider affordability in their pricing strategy.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Downtown Spots
- Dinner
Relate link
12. Little Italy
Extensive tequila selection, Live mariachi music

Family-owned, handmade pasta, extensive wine list.
Gelso & Grand is a restaurant located at the distinctive corner of Mulberry and Grand Street, offering a unique dining experience that combines modern and classic New York styles. The seating plan is inviting and informal, with an indoor, outdoor, and private dining room. In contrast to other Italian restaurants in Little Italy that prioritize profits over quality, Gelso & Grand stands out for its dedication to providing excellent food and service.
The bartender at Gelso & Grand is particularly notable for their friendly and chill demeanor, making guests feel welcome and at ease. They are also knowledgeable about the menu and can recommend excellent dishes, including vegetarian options. One such recommendation is a delicious veggie dish that is sure to satisfy. Overall, Gelso & Grand is a great choice for those seeking a relaxed and enjoyable dining experience in Little Italy.
TOPICS
- Holiday Celebrations
- Italian Cuisine
- Mid-Range
- Downtown Spots
13. Factory Tamal
Authentic family recipes, cozy atmosphere

The egg sandwich at this establishment is a must-try, known for its great taste and affordability. It comes with various options to add bacon, sausage, or cheese, and is served on a soft, delicious brioche bun with a chipotle mayo spread. The sandwich left such a positive impression that it has created anticipation for a return visit to try their tamales.
The establishment's food has received positive reviews for its excellent quality and value for money. The egg sandwich, in particular, has gained popularity due to its delicious taste and the variety of add-ons available. The brioche bun, chipotle mayo, and the customer's choice of meat or cheese create a perfect combination of flavors. The overall positive experience has left the customer looking forward to trying the tamales on their next visit.
TOPICS
- Mexican Cuisine
- Cheap Eats
- Downtown Spots
14. Torrisi
Creative twists on classic dishes, excellent margaritas

Desserts are a standout feature at this establishment, with a variety of options to choose from. Popular choices include the almond cheesecake, chocolate & hazelnut napoleon, affogato, and date cake. For a refreshing treat, complimentary Italian ice is also offered.
When it comes to pasta, this place truly shines. The Tortellini Pomodoro and Rigatoni with Lamb are customer favorites, known for their delicious filling and rich sauces. These pasta dishes are praised for their unique flavors and satisfying portions.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Celebrations
Relate link