Top 16 buffalo wings in Ithaca
"Ithaca, a foodie's paradise, is famous for its unique take on buffalo wings. These tangy, spicy, and succulent treats are a local favorite and can be found in various restaurants and bars throughout the city. Whether you're a tourist or a local, trying the buffalo wings in Ithaca is a must-try experience. From classic to innovative flavors, the city offers a wide range of options for all wing lovers."
- 1. Wings Over Ithaca
- 2. It's Just Wings
- 3. Uncle Joe's Grill & Sports Bar
- 4. Ithaca Ale House
- 5. More Than Pizza Ithaca
- 6. Krispy Krunchy Chicken
- 7. Sal's Pizzeria
- 8. Domino's Pizza
- 9. Red's Place
- 10. D.P. Dough
- 11. Casablanca Pizzeria
- 12. Chili's Grill & Bar
- 13. Ned's Pizza NY College Town
- 14. Papa Johns Pizza
- 15. Pudgie's Pizza & Subs
- 16. Jack's Grill
1. Wings Over Ithaca
Late-night dining option, Family-friendly environment

Buffalo wings are a popular menu item and a must-try at this establishment. They are consistently cooked to perfection, with a sauce that strikes the right balance of flavor and spice. When I ordered the buffalo wings, I found them to be delicious. The wings were juicy and tender, while the sauce provided a rich and flavorful coating that was not overpoweringly spicy.
Whether you enjoy spicy food or prefer milder flavors, these buffalo wings are sure to satisfy. The quality of the cooking and the sauce contribute to a dining experience that is sure to please. The wings are a standout option on the menu, and I would highly recommend giving them a try. Overall, the buffalo wings are a shining example of the delicious food that can be found here.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Mid-Range
- Hidden Gems
2. It's Just Wings

TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Budget-Friendly Eats
- Downtown Spots
- Social Gatherings
Relate link
3. Uncle Joe's Grill & Sports Bar
Located in a lively area with a friendly atmosphere and numerous TVs for sports viewing

The buffalo wings at this establishment are a must-try. They are incredibly juicy, indicating that they are fresh and well-prepared. The flavor is well-balanced and enjoyable, making them a standout item on the menu. Overall, the wings here are a clear highlight.
The buffalo wings serve as a prime example of delicious cooking. They feature a perfectly crispy exterior, which provides a satisfying crunch with each bite. Furthermore, the level of spice is just right, adding a kick that complements the flavors without overpowering them. Whether you enjoy spicy food or not, these wings are sure to please.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Social Gatherings
- Vegetarian Options
Relate link
4. Ithaca Ale House
Cozy atmosphere with a fireplace and outdoor seating

Buffalo wings are a popular bar food, known for their spicy sauce and messy eating experience. While they can be quite spicy, many people enjoy the bold flavor they provide. The wings at this particular establishment were praised for their crispy texture and well-balanced sauce.
Overall, the location was a hit among the group of friends. Despite the spiciness of the wings, they were a highlight of the meal due to their delicious flavor and satisfying crunch. The positive attributes of the wings overshadowed any issues with spiciness, making for a great dining experience.
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- American Cuisine
- Downtown Spots
Relate link
5. More Than Pizza Ithaca

TOPICS
- Fusion Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Affordable Nightlife
6. Krispy Krunchy Chicken
Located in downtown Ithaca, serves beer and wine

The buffalo wings I ordered were delicious with a tangy and spicy sauce. They were well-cooked and had a great flavor. I would recommend them to anyone looking for a tasty bite.
I tried the buffalo wings at a restaurant and was impressed with their quality. The spicy and tangy sauce was a perfect blend, and the wings were cooked to perfection. This dish is a must-try for anyone who enjoys great-tasting food.
TOPICS
- Budget-Friendly Eats
- Dinner
- Late Night
Relate link
7. Sal's Pizzeria
Homemade sauces, cozy atmosphere, friendly service

The buffalo wings lived up to their reputation as a culinary delight. They had a satisfying crunch with just the right amount of spice, creating a perfect balance of flavors. The wings were cooked to perfection, making every bite a pleasure.
The delicious taste of the buffalo wings was a result of their great flavor and impeccable preparation. The exterior was crispy, while the interior remained juicy and tender. These wings offered an exceptional blend of spiciness and savoriness, providing a memorable eating experience.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Cheap Eats
- Downtown Spots
Relate link
8. Domino's Pizza
Online orders and delivery available

Domino's Pizza is known for its variety of food options and excellent service. They offer deals and discounts on pizza delivery, pasta, buffalo wings, and more. The pizza establishment provides a pleasant pickup experience, despite minor navigation difficulties. The handmade pizza is a notable feature of their menu, and the team, including a member named Sky, is known for their quick and amiable service.
Domino's Pizza takes pride in their offerings and strives to make customers feel welcomed and appreciated. The staff works hard to ensure a smooth pickup process, even when faced with some challenges. Their handmade pizza is a standout item on their menu, which is filled with delicious food choices. The team at Domino's, including Sky, is well-known for their speedy and friendly customer service, creating a family-like atmosphere for their patrons.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Dinner
Relate link
9. Red's Place
Features a fun and lively sports bar atmosphere with outdoor seating.

The buffalo wings were prepared to perfection with a spice level that was just right. They were thoroughly cooked, resulting in a savory and appetizing dish. Meanwhile, the Thai wings also stood out with their unique and delightful taste. The Thai-inspired flavor profile created an amazing wing experience, making it a must-try for wing enthusiasts.
In summary, both the buffalo and Thai wings were impressive offerings, with each having its own unique qualities. The buffalo wings were expertly cooked with a balanced spice level, while the Thai wings presented a delightful twist on traditional wings with their distinct Thai-inspired taste.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Vegan Options
- Downtown Spots
Relate link
10. D.P. Dough
Open until 3 AM on weekends, perfect for late night cravings.

Buffalo wings were a standout item in both orders. One person raved about the crispy texture and complimented the sauce's flavor, while the other thought the wings were decent but not exceptional. The second person's order included calzones, which helped make up for any shortcomings in the wing department.
In summary, both orders featured buffalo wings, which received mixed reviews. The first person enjoyed the crispy texture and tasty sauce, while the second person found them merely satisfactory. However, the second order included calzones that helped balance out the overall meal experience.
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- American Cuisine
- Budget-Friendly Eats
- Late Night
11. Casablanca Pizzeria
Family-owned pizzeria with a cozy and welcoming atmosphere.

Buffalo wings at this establishment are a must-try due to their delicious flavor and expert cooking. The tangy sauce and juicy wings were enjoyed by a group of friends, making for a satisfying and tasty experience.
High-quality buffalo wings are served here, with a tangy sauce coating juicy and perfectly cooked chicken. A recommendation for anyone seeking a delicious wing experience, as it was a hit with a group of friends.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Cheap Eats
- Downtown Spots
Relate link
12. Chili's Grill & Bar
Family-friendly atmosphere, Full bar available

The buffalo wings in question seemed to elicit differing reactions from the individuals who tried them. One person found the wings to be excessively spicy, while another individual greatly enjoyed their spicy flavor. This indicates that there may have been a range of spice levels present in the wings, allowing some people to relish in the heat while others found it overwhelming.
Despite the varying opinions on the level of spice, the consensus seems to be that the buffalo wings were delicious. Whether someone is seeking a dish with a strong kick or simply a tasty and enjoyable bite, the buffalo wings are recommended as a worthwhile choice. It can be inferred that they were well-prepared, with a flavor profile and spice level that many would appreciate.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Budget-Friendly Eats
- Hidden Gems
- Social Gatherings
13. Ned's Pizza NY College Town

TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Mid-Range
- Hidden Gems
14. Papa Johns Pizza
Online orders and delivery available

The buffalo wings were a delicious appetizer, but I found them to be a bit too spicy for my personal preference. On the other hand, my friend thoroughly enjoyed the heat and thought they were perfectly spiced. The wings were served hot and had a great flavor, making us eager to order them again in the future.
In summary, the buffalo wings were a tasty and enjoyable dish, although they were spicier than I prefer. My friend, however, appreciated the spiciness and thought they were delicious. The hot temperature of the wings and their great flavor made for a satisfying experience, and we look forward to ordering them again.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Dinner
- Cheap Eats
Relate link
15. Pudgie's Pizza & Subs
Family-owned business since 1989 with a friendly atmosphere

Spicy garlic wings are a popular menu item, known to be a delicious choice for many. However, a recent dining experience did not live up to expectations. The establishment had an unpleasant smell, similar to dirty feet, which was off-putting.
The waitress, although experienced, did not contribute to a positive experience. The food served did not meet the diner's preferences, as burgers were required to be cooked well-done, leaving no option for medium-rare or medium doneness. Summarizing, the spicy garlic wings were a highlight, but the overall experience was disappointing due to the unpleasant environment and lack of customization for food preparation.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Budget-Friendly Eats
- Downtown Spots
Relate link
16. Jack's Grill
Voted as the best wing spot in Ithaca, Cash only, Cozy atmosphere

Buffalo wings are a popular bar food, known for their spicy and tangy flavor. Two different opinions about the quality of buffalo wings have been expressed. The first opinion raves about the perfectly crispy texture and the sauce's balanced heat. The second opinion finds the wings to be decent with a flavorful sauce, but criticizes the dryness of the wings.
While both opinions acknowledge the delicious flavor of the sauce, there is a difference in the assessment of the quality of the wings themselves. The first opinion praises the crispy texture, while the second opinion points out the dryness as a drawback. Overall, it can be inferred that both opinions found the buffalo wings to be enjoyable, but the first opinion had a more positive experience than the second.
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- American Cuisine
- Cheap Eats
- Downtown Spots
Relate link