15 Best Gelato in New York City
"Gelato in NYC" is a delightful culinary experience, combining the Italian tradition of gelato-making with the cosmopolitan energy of New York City. From classic flavors to innovative creations, "Gelato in NYC" offers a diverse range of treats for locals and tourists alike. Indulge in this authentic dessert, crafted with passion and expertise, at any of the city's many renowned gelato shops.
- 1. Venchi Chocolate & Gelato Columbus Circle
- 2. Julietta Gelato Cafè
- 3. il laboratorio del gelato
- 4. FIGO il Gelato Italiano
- 5. Il Buco Alimentari & Vineria
- 6. Dolce Brooklyn - Artisanal Gelato & Ice Cream
- 7. Bambina Blue Gelato Wonder Room
- 8. Anita La Mamma del Gelato
- 9. Amorino
- 10. Gelateria Gentile - Williamsburg
- 11. Gelateria Gentile - West Village
- 12. Amorino Gelato and Cafe
- 13. Sant Ambroeus Gelateria
- 14. Noi Due Gelato
- 15. L'Arte del Gelato
1. Venchi Chocolate & Gelato Columbus Circle
Handmade chocolates from Italian recipes

Iratelli's Gelato, located in the United States, is unparalleled in its quality, particularly its rich and delicious dark chocolate gelato that is reminiscent of being in Italy. The line of customers waiting to indulge in these frozen treats moves quickly, making the wait time virtually negligible.
Moreover, Iratelli's Gelato offers an impressive array of vegan gelato options that are just as decadent and satisfying as their non-vegan counterparts. The vegan chocolates are clearly labeled, allowing customers with dietary restrictions to enjoy these treats with ease. The selection of vegan options is plentiful and every flavor tried was delightful.
2. Julietta Gelato Cafè
A popular spot for both gelato and coffee lovers

A clean and well-maintained gelato shop provides a wide range of options at affordable prices. The interior of the shop is inviting and comfortable, making it an ideal spot to enjoy a sweet treat.
During a recent visit, a delighted customer discovered an impressive selection of fifteen vegan gelato flavors. The valrhona (chocolate) and mixed berry options were chosen in a piccolo size and shared with a partner. The gelato received rave reviews for its delicious taste, while the prices were considered very reasonable.
3. il laboratorio del gelato
Artisanal gelato with a modern twist

Il Laboratorio del Gelato offers a wide variety of unique and interesting gelato flavors, with over 230 options listed on their website. The flavors are so unique and imaginative that it's impossible to think them up on your own. On multiple visits, the gelato has been consistently excellent, making it a standout experience each time.
With flavors ranging from the traditional to the exotic, Il Laboratorio del Gelato has something for everyone. From rich chocolate and creamy vanilla to more adventurous options like black sesame and gorgonzola dolce, each bite is a new and exciting experience. The high-quality ingredients and meticulous preparation methods ensure that every scoop is a delight, making this gelato shop a must-visit destination.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
4. FIGO il Gelato Italiano
Artisanal gelato made fresh daily

Figs and ricotta make up the unique and eponymous flavor known as Figo at this gelato shop. The shop, run by Italians, offers both dairy and non-dairy options for their gelato. The fruit gelato is made with high-quality fruits such as fig and pear, providing a delicious and refreshing option. The decor of the shop is modern and clean, adding to the overall pleasant experience.
In addition to the traditional gelato served in a cup or cone, customers can also opt to have their gelato served in a warm brioche bun. This unique presentation adds a warm and satisfying element to the cool and refreshing gelato. The Italian owners take pride in their gelato, using only the best ingredients and traditional techniques to create their delicious offerings. Whether you prefer dairy or non-dairy gelato, or like to try your gelato in a brioche bun, this shop has something for everyone.
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- Fusion Cuisine
- Downtown Spots
- Mid-Range
5. Il Buco Alimentari & Vineria
A popular Italian restaurant and marketplace in the heart of New York City

A popular gelato shop offers delicious and flavorful gelato. The salted caramel and caffe flavors were particularly rich and satisfying, although they were a bit harder than usual. Despite the hardness, the gelato still tasted great.
A recommended option for trying a variety of flavors is the gelato sampler. The vanilla and dairy-free chocolate flavors are a must-try for anyone visiting the shop. These flavors offer a unique and satisfying taste experience, elevating the overall gelato-eating journey.
TOPICS
- Mediterranean Cuisine
- Downtown Spots
6. Dolce Brooklyn - Artisanal Gelato & Ice Cream
Small-batch, artisanal gelato made with high-quality ingredients

Tasty and nice descriptions are often used to highlight the exceptional quality of the food at Dolce. The staff at this establishment is known for their great service, creating a welcoming and pleasant atmosphere for all guests. They are friendly and attentive, making sure that every visitor feels valued and satisfied.
Dolce is a restaurant that offers smoothness and fabulous flavors in every dish. It is a hidden gem, tucked away from the hustle and bustle of the city, providing a surprising Corsican dining experience. While Corsica is now a part of France, Dolce's cuisine carries a strong Italian influence, making it a unique and delightful dining destination for food lovers.
7. Bambina Blue Gelato Wonder Room
Handcrafted gelato using high-quality ingredients, focusing on natural and authentic flavors

The gelato offered in this location is truly exceptional, with a wide variety of unique flavors to choose from. Each flavor is rich, authentic, and more delicious than the last. It stands out as the best gelato in all of NYC, with a texture that is incredibly smooth and perfect.
This gelato is a must-try for anyone who loves frozen desserts. The unique flavors are what make it so special, and it's clear that a lot of care and attention goes into each one. The texture is a key factor in what makes this gelato so amazing, as it is incredibly rich and smooth. Overall, it's a must-visit destination for any gelato lover.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Celebrations
- Downtown Spots
8. Anita La Mamma del Gelato
An authentic Italian gelato experience in the heart of New York City

It can be difficult to choose from the wide variety of flavors at this ice cream shop, but luckily the staff is patient and offers samples by the spoon to assist those who are indecisive. My son tried the white chocolate cookie flavor and I opted for the chocolate coffee flavor, and both were excellent choices.
This ice cream and gelato shop is renowned as the best in NYC, featuring a large selection of flavors that all taste fresh and delicious. Due to its high quality, it has become a favorite summer spot for my children.
9. Amorino
Handmade gelato using traditional Italian methods

The rich pistachio gelato, when combined with whipped cream and a waffle, was an outstanding treat that left me fully satisfied. The gelato shop, which I have found to be the most consistently excellent option outside of Europe, offered a delicious dark chocolate flavor called "Amorino chocolate." This chocolate option went especially well with the caramel gelato and its crispy bits.
My experience with the pistachio gelato, complete with whipped cream and a waffle, was nothing short of amazing. This was all complemented by the exceptional dark chocolate gelato, named "Amorino chocolate," which I found to be a perfect match for the caramel gelato with its crispy additions. This gelato shop has proven itself to be the top choice in terms of consistency and quality outside of Europe.
10. Gelateria Gentile - Williamsburg
Family-owned business with a rich Italian heritage

Gianduja and nocciola gelato were enjoyed for their rich, authentic Italian taste. These flavors were noted for their deliciousness, and their lack of excessive sweetness compared to American ice cream. The portions served were generous, leading to a recommendation of ordering a small cup.
A visit to Williamsburg, specifically Bedford Ave, resulted in the discovery of an 'ARTISAN MALL' building. Inside, an industrial space housed several stores, including a small gelato shop called ANTICA GELATERIA GENTILE. This establishment was found to offer homemade Italian gelato made from high-quality ingredients imported directly from Italy. The gelato was served by two kind and friendly staff members. Flavors such as Cioccolato Fondente and Pistacchio were particularly enjoyed, as was their homemade Cialda.
11. Gelateria Gentile - West Village
Authentic Italian gelato made fresh daily

Gelateria Gentile's West Village location is small, with room for only three to four people. Despite its tiny storefront, it is known for making excellent gelato. The gelato is produced at their factory in Williamsburg and served on cones imported from Italy. A mini cone is placed on top of each serving.
The gelato at Gelateria Gentile is authentic Italian gelato, with well-curated ingredients and flavors. While I did not try the sorbetti or granita during my first visit, given the shop's Barese heritage, I assume they are also well-made. This is great gelato, consistent with the high standards of classic Italian gelato.
12. Amorino Gelato and Cafe
Artisanal gelato made with natural ingredients and unique flavors

The writer discovered a delicious gelato spot while walking back to their hotel after a show in NYC. They were impressed by the freshness and goodness of the gelato, having two big cups of multiple flavors during their trip. However, they found the ordering system to be a bit confusing and the portion expensive for the price.
The gelato at this spot was described as a deeply delicious cool treat, perfect for a hot and humid day. The flavors were enjoyable, but the ordering process was confusing. The staff was not described as rude, but they were not particularly friendly or welcoming. Despite this, the writer still encourages others not to skip this spot, suggesting that the delicious gelato may be worth the potential drawbacks.
13. Sant Ambroeus Gelateria

The pistachio gelato I tried was incredibly delicious, with a texture that was just right and a taste that was absolutely spot on. This gelato stands out for its rich and authentic flavors, making it a must-try for anyone visiting New York City.
In fact, the gelato here is so good that it can be considered divinely delicious. Whether you're a fan of pistachio or prefer other flavors, you're sure to find something to love at this NYC destination. With its high-quality ingredients and attention to detail, this gelato is a favorite among locals and tourists alike.
14. Noi Due Gelato

Gelatoville in the East Village and Noi Due Gelato are two exceptional gelato shops in NYC. Both shops offer creamy gelato with a smooth texture and no crystals. The flavors are amazing, with Stratacciella and pistachio being particularly noteworthy. Both shops allow sampling and offer a range of prices and portion sizes, making them a great choice for anyone looking to satisfy their gelato craving.
In addition to a wide selection of gelato flavors (including 8 vegan options), both shops offer other sweet treats like gelato cakes, baked goods, and affogato. The prices are reasonable, with $10 buying three scoops of gelato. At Gelatoville, the pistachio, strawberry sorbet, and halva (an Israeli/Middle Eastern dessert) are must-tries. The flavors are rich and intense, making for a truly delightful gelato experience.
15. L'Arte del Gelato
Authentic Italian gelato made fresh daily

The pistachio gelato stood out for its creamy texture and delightful toasty pistachio flavor. The rotating selection of flavors is a hit, although there's a request to bring back the orange chocolate option.
Meanwhile, the olive oil gelato offered an ethereal experience, reminiscent of tasting a small piece of heaven. Its smoothness was impressive, and when paired with something fruity, it created a perfect combination.
TOPICS
- Holiday Celebrations
- Italian Cuisine
- Vegan Options