Top 15 milkshakes in Upper West Side NYC
Discover our curated list of top-ranked milkshakes in Upper West Side NYC, compiled from extensive research across reputable websites and blogs. Explore outstanding options like Shake Shack Upper West Side, 5 Napkin Burger, Bareburger, 16 Handles, Big Gay Ice Cream. Let's explore together!
Toc
- 1. Shake Shack Upper West Side
- 2. 5 Napkin Burger
- 3. Bareburger
- 4. 16 Handles
- 5. Big Gay Ice Cream
- 6. Venchi Chocolate and Gelato Columbus Av
- 7. 7th Street Burger Upper West Side
- 8. Amorino Gelato - New York Amsterdam Avenue
- 9. Van Leeuwen Ice Cream
- 10. Van Leeuwen Ice Cream
- 11. Ample Hills Creamery Upper West Side
- 12. Milk Bar
- 13. Emack & Bolio's
- 14. Haagen-Dazs
- 15. Trudy's Ice Cream
1. Shake Shack Upper West Side
Modern take on classic fast food with a gourmet twist
Experience the deliciousness of Shake Shack on the Upper West Side. After our initial visit left us with some ordering regrets, we decided to give it another shot. And boy, are we glad we did! This time, we knew exactly what to order and indulged in their mouthwatering meals. From the first bite to the last, we were blown away by the flavors that danced on our taste buds. The convenient walk-up kiosks made the ordering process a breeze, especially during the bustling lunchtime rush. If you're looking for a truly satisfying meal, make your way to Shake Shack – you won't be disappointed!
Discover Shake Shack's tantalizing offerings on the Upper West Side, where every visit is like hitting the jackpot of taste. Our recent experience was a delightful contrast to our previous one, where we found ourselves ordering dishes that didn't quite tickle our fancy. Determined to right this culinary wrong, we returned for another go and were met with an explosion of flavors that simply blew us away. As we strolled through the American Museum of Natural History, our appetites grew, making Shake Shack the perfect lunchtime stop. Thanks to the efficient walk-up kiosks, we were able to swiftly place our order and dive into a meal that left us completely satisfied. Whether you're a first-time visitor or a Shake Shack enthusiast, this Upper West Side gem is guaranteed to leave you craving more.
Discover Shake Shack's tantalizing offerings on the Upper West Side, where every visit is like hitting the jackpot of taste. Our recent experience was a delightful contrast to our previous one, where we found ourselves ordering dishes that didn't quite tickle our fancy. Determined to right this culinary wrong, we returned for another go and were met with an explosion of flavors that simply blew us away. As we strolled through the American Museum of Natural History, our appetites grew, making Shake Shack the perfect lunchtime stop. Thanks to the efficient walk-up kiosks, we were able to swiftly place our order and dive into a meal that left us completely satisfied. Whether you're a first-time visitor or a Shake Shack enthusiast, this Upper West Side gem is guaranteed to leave you craving more.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Cheap Eats
- Dinner
- Late Night
2. 5 Napkin Burger
High-quality ingredients, handpicked meats, and freshly baked buns
5 Napkin Burger is not your average burger joint. Located in the heart of New York City, this American restaurant offers an experience that is hard to beat. From the moment you step through the doors, you are greeted with a lively atmosphere that exudes energy and excitement. The staff is friendly, helpful, and efficient, ensuring that your dining experience is nothing short of perfection. And let's not forget about the food. The burgers at 5 Napkin Burger are like none other. Juicy, flavorful, and cooked to perfection, they are a burger lover's dream come true. And if burgers aren't your thing, fear not. The restaurant also offers a variety of other options, including crispy fries and well-cooked salads. With decent portion sizes and great value for money, 5 Napkin Burger is a must-visit for food enthusiasts in New York City.
Step into 5 Napkin Burger and prepare to be blown away. This top-notch burger joint is not only known for its delicious food but also for its excellent service and family-friendly atmosphere. Whether you're in the mood for a quick bite or a leisurely meal with friends or family, this restaurant has got you covered. And let's not forget about the drinks. With a happy hour that offers great deals on beer and appetizers, 5 Napkin Burger is the perfect spot to unwind after a long day. The restaurant is beautifully decorated, creating a vibrant and welcoming environment that will leave you wanting to come back for more. So if you're a burger lover in New York City, do yourself a favor and pay a visit to 5 Napkin Burger. You won't be disappointed.
Step into 5 Napkin Burger and prepare to be blown away. This top-notch burger joint is not only known for its delicious food but also for its excellent service and family-friendly atmosphere. Whether you're in the mood for a quick bite or a leisurely meal with friends or family, this restaurant has got you covered. And let's not forget about the drinks. With a happy hour that offers great deals on beer and appetizers, 5 Napkin Burger is the perfect spot to unwind after a long day. The restaurant is beautifully decorated, creating a vibrant and welcoming environment that will leave you wanting to come back for more. So if you're a burger lover in New York City, do yourself a favor and pay a visit to 5 Napkin Burger. You won't be disappointed.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Mid-Range
Relate link
3. Bareburger
Emphasizes organic, sustainable, and locally-sourced ingredients.
Introducing Bareburger, the ultimate destination for mindful, feel-good food that is guaranteed to leave you satisfied. With a new location on the vibrant Upper West Side, Bareburger has perfected the art of delivering clean, comforting dishes that are not only delicious but also ethically sourced. Through an extensive network of partners and farmers, Bareburger ensures that every burger, salad, and sandwich is created within their tight-knit community. In fact, over a third of their menu is dedicated to vegetarian and plant-based options, proving that hearty and flavorful dishes can be enjoyed by all. But Bareburger’s commitment to sustainability goes beyond just their innovative menu. Step inside any Bareburger restaurant and you'll be greeted by a unique and vibrant atmosphere, crafted using reclaimed and recycled materials. With a menu fit for vegans, vegetarians, and meat-eaters alike, Bareburger promises a dining experience that is anything but simple.
Looking for a spot to enjoy some mouthwatering burgers? Look no further than Bareburger. We recently visited during happy hour for lunch, and it was nothing short of perfect. Indulging in their delectable burgers, accompanied by refreshing drinks, was an absolute delight. What truly stood out was the impeccable service we received. It was fast, efficient, and the staff went above and beyond to ensure our satisfaction. As an added bonus, we were given a bag of popcorn to enjoy while we eagerly awaited our meal. And let me tell you, it was worth the wait. I opted for the super burger, packed with onion rings and chopped fries, and while it was a hearty meal, the flavors were truly exceptional. So, whether you're craving a classic or looking to try something extraordinary, Bareburger is the place to be. Trust me, once you step foot in this establishment, you'll understand why their food is anything but simple.
Looking for a spot to enjoy some mouthwatering burgers? Look no further than Bareburger. We recently visited during happy hour for lunch, and it was nothing short of perfect. Indulging in their delectable burgers, accompanied by refreshing drinks, was an absolute delight. What truly stood out was the impeccable service we received. It was fast, efficient, and the staff went above and beyond to ensure our satisfaction. As an added bonus, we were given a bag of popcorn to enjoy while we eagerly awaited our meal. And let me tell you, it was worth the wait. I opted for the super burger, packed with onion rings and chopped fries, and while it was a hearty meal, the flavors were truly exceptional. So, whether you're craving a classic or looking to try something extraordinary, Bareburger is the place to be. Trust me, once you step foot in this establishment, you'll understand why their food is anything but simple.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Vegan Options
- Mid-Range
- Downtown Spots
4. 16 Handles
Create your own frozen yogurt masterpiece
16 Handles is the unrivaled champion of desserts in New York, taking the city by storm with its delectable soft serve and extravagant selection of flavors and toppings. Since its inception in 2008, starting with its East Village location, it has grown to encompass an impressive 29 locations. With their convenient online ordering system, you can now indulge in their mouthwatering treats wherever you desire. Not only do they excel in flavor and variety, but 16 Handles also thrives in creating a sense of community and providing unparalleled loyalty rewards for its cherished guests.
Although it may come with a slightly higher price tag, the experience is undoubtedly worth every penny. While the exact cost per ounce is not readily displayed, the accompanying image suggests a serving priced at $6.25. Rest assured, the taste is simply irresistible. However, it's important to note that their availability may be somewhat limited. Nonetheless, aptly named 16 Handles offers a staggering sixteen frozen yogurt flavors, allowing you to fill your cup to your heart's content. To add further delight, they provide an array of toppings to enhance your frozen treat. The amount you can enjoy is entirely up to you since they charge based on weight, meaning you can indulge to your heart's delight without any constraints.
Although it may come with a slightly higher price tag, the experience is undoubtedly worth every penny. While the exact cost per ounce is not readily displayed, the accompanying image suggests a serving priced at $6.25. Rest assured, the taste is simply irresistible. However, it's important to note that their availability may be somewhat limited. Nonetheless, aptly named 16 Handles offers a staggering sixteen frozen yogurt flavors, allowing you to fill your cup to your heart's content. To add further delight, they provide an array of toppings to enhance your frozen treat. The amount you can enjoy is entirely up to you since they charge based on weight, meaning you can indulge to your heart's delight without any constraints.
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- American Cuisine
- Cheap Eats
- Downtown Spots
Relate link
5. Big Gay Ice Cream
Small-batch, handcrafted ice cream with unique toppings and flavors
Big Gay Ice Cream, originally a food truck, has now developed a dedicated following in New York and Philadelphia. It's the go-to spot for delicious, dairy-based ice creams with chocolate, vanilla, and mixed flavors as the main focus, topped with a variety of amazing toppings. Weekly specials are always changing, and they also offer a selection of vegan and dairy-free fruit popsicles. Whether you prefer a classic cone like the Rocky Roadhouse, a decadent sundae like the Monday Sundae or Rufus, an ice cream float with Mexican Coca Cola, or a creamy Oreo milkshake, there's something for everyone. Don't forget to try the Trucker, an ice cream sandwich that pays homage to its food truck roots. With its vibrant and lively atmosphere, Big Gay Ice Cream is a must-visit spot that stays open late.
When you're in need of a sweet treat after a long stroll in Central Park, Big Gay Ice Cream is the perfect place for you. The ice cream is incredibly sweet, and the staff members are friendly and patient, even though there are so many flavor and topping options that it may take you a while to decide. The waffle cones are also top-notch, adding an extra touch of deliciousness to your frozen treat. The ice cream itself has a unique texture that's almost like frozen, dense whipped cream. I personally had a cup with strawberry topping, which I thoroughly enjoyed, but my friend didn't share my enthusiasm. However, I couldn't get enough of the delicious taste.
When you're in need of a sweet treat after a long stroll in Central Park, Big Gay Ice Cream is the perfect place for you. The ice cream is incredibly sweet, and the staff members are friendly and patient, even though there are so many flavor and topping options that it may take you a while to decide. The waffle cones are also top-notch, adding an extra touch of deliciousness to your frozen treat. The ice cream itself has a unique texture that's almost like frozen, dense whipped cream. I personally had a cup with strawberry topping, which I thoroughly enjoyed, but my friend didn't share my enthusiasm. However, I couldn't get enough of the delicious taste.
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- Cheap Eats
- Downtown Spots
- Vegetarian Options
6. Venchi Chocolate and Gelato Columbus Av
Authentic Italian chocolate and gelato made with high-quality ingredients
With its amazing ice cream and impeccable quality, Venchi Chocolate and Gelato on Columbus Ave is a must-visit for all dessert lovers. While it may be a bit on the pricey side, the portion sizes are generous and the flavors are simply phenomenal. Chocoivar, in particular, stands out as one of the best ice creams I have ever tasted, surpassing even the high standards set by Italian gelato. If you're a fan of ice cream, this place comes highly recommended.
In addition to their delectable treats, Venchi Chocolate and Gelato also excels in customer service. The friendly staff, led by the amazing Supervisor Jasmin, goes above and beyond to make every customer feel like family. They even stay open late, making it a perfect spot for late-night indulgence. The exceptional experience we had here has solidified Venchi as our go-to place for ice cream. We will definitely be returning soon.
In addition to their delectable treats, Venchi Chocolate and Gelato also excels in customer service. The friendly staff, led by the amazing Supervisor Jasmin, goes above and beyond to make every customer feel like family. They even stay open late, making it a perfect spot for late-night indulgence. The exceptional experience we had here has solidified Venchi as our go-to place for ice cream. We will definitely be returning soon.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Budget-Friendly Eats
7. 7th Street Burger Upper West Side
7th Street Burger on the Upper West Side is a true gem for burger lovers. With a quick service and a cooking time of around 5 to 8 minutes (though it can take a bit longer during peak times), you won't have to wait too long to indulge in their delicious offerings. The regular burger is reasonably priced and comes with a generous portion. I highly recommend it. The staff, especially Vidal, are friendly and efficient, adding to the overall positive dining experience. For those who love Smashed Burgers, 7th Street Burger is one of the best places to go. Despite their small menu, they excel at what they do. They serve the best burgers in New York, period! The burgers are delicious, made with fresh ingredients, and served quickly. What's even better is that they are also affordable. As someone from Poland, I'm already dreaming of when I can have these burgers again in the future. Best regards from across the ocean!
Located on the Upper West Side, 7th Street Burger is a fantastic burger joint that should not be missed. Their simple menu includes classic cheeseburgers, delicious fries, and even Mexican Coca-Cola. Vegetarians will be pleased to know that they also have the Impossible burger as a tasty alternative. The prices are affordable, the staff is friendly, and the service is fast. I only wish I had discovered this place sooner!
Located on the Upper West Side, 7th Street Burger is a fantastic burger joint that should not be missed. Their simple menu includes classic cheeseburgers, delicious fries, and even Mexican Coca-Cola. Vegetarians will be pleased to know that they also have the Impossible burger as a tasty alternative. The prices are affordable, the staff is friendly, and the service is fast. I only wish I had discovered this place sooner!
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Budget-Friendly Eats
- Vegetarian Options
Relate link
8. Amorino Gelato - New York Amsterdam Avenue
Handcrafted gelato made fresh daily with natural ingredients
Kyle provided the most presentable ice cream.She was great and very charming.I tried the Alphonso mango and it was good.It tasted more pulpy than creamy.There are definitely many others worth trying besides Mango.…
TOPICS
- Fusion Cuisine
- Downtown Spots
- Mid-Range
9. Van Leeuwen Ice Cream
Small-batch, artisanal ice cream made from scratch
Prospect Heights is ground zero for the ice cream empire builders behind Van Leeuwen Ice Cream, brothers Ben and Peter Van Leeuwen and their partner (and Ben's wife) Laura O'Neill. The first of many in New York City, this outpost still has its original magic touch by updating nostalgic flavors, like marionberry cheesecake, peppermint chips made with dark chocolate and peppermint extract, and brownie chips of peanut butter with real brownie pieces.
TOPICS
- Vegetarian Options
- Cheap Eats
- Downtown Spots
Relate link
10. Van Leeuwen Ice Cream
Small-batch, artisanal ice cream using high-quality, natural ingredients
Reviews: 4.5/5, 250+ Google Reviews Location: They have several locations in New York. Van Leeuwen honeycomb flavored ice cream. Van Leeuwen Ice Cream started in the spring of 2008 in a buttery yellow truck on the streets of New York, serving healthy ice cream made from milk, cream, eggs, and cane sugar; vegan balls are also available. The mission is to make good ice cream that makes you feel good. We see a long line every time we pass by their Upper West Side location. And we tried again a few days before Christmas, and, of course, there was a line, but much shorter. It only took us 5 minutes before our turn to walk up and ask what the signature flavor was. “It's a honeycomb! Many of our customers love it. And we also have a new flavor, matcha tea, which has a slight bitterness.”
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
Relate link
11. Ample Hills Creamery Upper West Side
I'm so happy it's back!This place has legendary ice cream and the flavors and concoctions are unique.Come enjoy a cold spoonful on a hot day.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Budget-Friendly Eats
- Downtown Spots
- Lunch
Relate link
12. Milk Bar
Known for their innovative and creative desserts
Milk Bar is the amazing dessert shop founded by chef Christina Tosi. Christian is the culinary brain behind Momofuku's dessert program. At Milk Bar you can relive your childhood enjoying Milk and Cereal Ice Cream. While you're here, don't miss out on their other delights. My personal favorites are the Chocolate Birthday Cake Truffles and the Cornflake Marshmallow Chocolate Chip Cookies. My pick: chocolate birthday cake truffles (not ice cream, but you have to try them)
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Cheap Eats
- Downtown Spots
Relate link
13. Emack & Bolio's
Hand-rolled ice cream made to order, homemade waffle cones, vegan options available
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Mid-Range
- Downtown Spots
Relate link
14. Haagen-Dazs
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Vegan Options
- Cheap Eats
- Downtown Spots
15. Trudy's Ice Cream
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- Gluten-Free
- Mid-Range
- Dinner