Top 18 school supply stores in Ithaca
Discover our curated list of top-ranked school supply stores in Ithaca, compiled from extensive research across reputable websites and blogs. Explore outstanding options like Kohl's, The Cornell Store, Barnes & Noble, Ollie's Bargain Outlet, Dollar Tree. Let's explore together!
Toc
- 1. Kohl's
- 2. The Cornell Store
- 3. Barnes & Noble
- 4. Ollie's Bargain Outlet
- 5. Dollar Tree
- 6. Friends of the Library Book Sale - Donations until April 16
- 7. Five Below
- 8. P&L Supply
- 9. Odyssey Bookstore
- 10. Alphabet Soup
- 11. Mockingbird Paperie
- 12. Staples
- 13. B & W Supply Co.
- 14. The UPS Store
- 15. The Cornell Store on the Ithaca Commons
- 16. SewGreen
- 17. Leonard’s Hobby and Cleaning Supplies
- 18. Walgreens
1. Kohl's
Kohl's Cash rewards program

Explore a shopping oasis at Kohl's, where every visit unveils new surprises. While the size may seem modest compared to other locations, the carefully curated selection of fashion and home decor never disappoints. The thrill of discovering hidden gems makes each trip a delight, especially with enticing deals like the irresistible Black Friday sales. Dive into a treasure trove of stylish clothing and festive Christmas sweaters, adding a touch of flair to your wardrobe. Plus, with party items that spark joy and elevate any celebration, Kohl's is a one-stop destination for affordable luxury.
2. The Cornell Store
Support for student organizations

Discover the ultimate destination for all things Cornell at The Cornell Store. From trendy apparel to exclusive merchandise, this store is a haven for Big Red enthusiasts. Unleash your inner fashionista with the latest collections that are constantly being unveiled. Whether you're a student, alumni, or just a Cornell fan, you'll find something that speaks to your unique style at this vibrant hub of campus spirit.
Indulge in a delightful shopping experience at the Cornell University store, where a diverse array of Cornell-branded products and curated items await. After browsing, treat yourself to a scrumptious meal at the cafeteria, offering a fusion of flavors to tantalize your taste buds. While the dining experience may lean towards the pricier side, the quality and satisfaction are well worth it. Experience the essence of Cornell University not just through the shopping, but also through the culinary delights that await you.
Indulge in a delightful shopping experience at the Cornell University store, where a diverse array of Cornell-branded products and curated items await. After browsing, treat yourself to a scrumptious meal at the cafeteria, offering a fusion of flavors to tantalize your taste buds. While the dining experience may lean towards the pricier side, the quality and satisfaction are well worth it. Experience the essence of Cornell University not just through the shopping, but also through the culinary delights that await you.
3. Barnes & Noble
In-store cafes with Starbucks drinks

Indulge in the enchanting world of Barnes & Noble, a haven where time stands still and curiosity thrives. With no shopping agenda in mind, I leisurely navigate through the aisles, marveling at the vast array of books that beckon me. While the prices are fair, the allure of online deals occasionally tugs at my attention. Nevertheless, the siren call of this store ensures that I will always find my way back, regardless of my location.
Immerse yourself in the serene ambience of Barnes & Noble, a sanctuary for book lovers to lose themselves in quiet contemplation. Although the preference for online book shopping is understandable, the charm of physically exploring literary realms is an experience that resonates deeply. Despite the evolving selection, the essence of Barnes & Noble endures, offering a timeless escape for those seeking solace in the written word.
Immerse yourself in the serene ambience of Barnes & Noble, a sanctuary for book lovers to lose themselves in quiet contemplation. Although the preference for online book shopping is understandable, the charm of physically exploring literary realms is an experience that resonates deeply. Despite the evolving selection, the essence of Barnes & Noble endures, offering a timeless escape for those seeking solace in the written word.
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- Downtown Spots
4. Ollie's Bargain Outlet
Unique treasure hunt shopping experience

Ollie's Bargain Outlet may not carry everything, but their selection comes at unbeatable prices. I discovered top brands at 50% cheaper than other stores. Their book section showcases captivating reads that appeal to all interests.
Aldi's is like the upscale version of Tops, just as Ollie's compares to Walmart. While you can snag fantastic bargains, it's important to be discerning as lower prices may sometimes compromise quality. Don't miss out on their fantastic rug selections for the best deals!
Aldi's is like the upscale version of Tops, just as Ollie's compares to Walmart. While you can snag fantastic bargains, it's important to be discerning as lower prices may sometimes compromise quality. Don't miss out on their fantastic rug selections for the best deals!
TOPICS
- Budget-Friendly Eats
- Happy Hours
- Downtown Spots
5. Dollar Tree
Everything in the store is $1 or less

Upon stepping into Dollar Tree, chaos reigns supreme with products strewn about haphazardly, creating an overwhelming and unkempt environment. The lack of cleanliness and organization is absolutely abysmal, leaving much to be desired in terms of upkeep.
However, amidst the disarray, the store does boast a silver lining with its helpful and amiable staff who are always ready to assist. Despite the occasional long lines, the efficiency at the checkout ensures minimal waiting time. It is evident that there has been some progress in terms of cleanliness and maintenance within the store over the past year.
However, amidst the disarray, the store does boast a silver lining with its helpful and amiable staff who are always ready to assist. Despite the occasional long lines, the efficiency at the checkout ensures minimal waiting time. It is evident that there has been some progress in terms of cleanliness and maintenance within the store over the past year.
6. Friends of the Library Book Sale - Donations until April 16
Proceeds benefit the public library

Discover a treasure trove at the Friends of the Library Book Sale with donations welcomed until April 16. Despite the initial rush, the organized chaos is managed efficiently with maps and limited entry ensuring a pleasant experience. The vast selection of over 10,000 visitors warrants the provided bag for your finds. Indulge in the adventure as you navigate the aisles, scoring 16 books for a steal at $8, and perhaps even catching an intriguing true crime session.
7. Five Below
Everything is $5 or less

With a wide array of budget-friendly products, Five Below presents itself as a treasure trove of affordable finds. Despite initial misconceptions, the store delights with its organized layout and amiable staff, offering a hassle-free shopping experience. It's become my go-to for gift shopping, boasting fantastic prices and an extensive selection to cater to diverse tastes. The only slight drawback is the limited options for gifts targeting the younger demographic of newborns to 4-year-olds.
8. P&L Supply

9. Odyssey Bookstore

10. Alphabet Soup

11. Mockingbird Paperie

12. Staples

13. B & W Supply Co.

14. The UPS Store

15. The Cornell Store on the Ithaca Commons

16. SewGreen

17. Leonard’s Hobby and Cleaning Supplies

18. Walgreens
