Best of 12 caprese sandwich in Madison
Craving a caprese sandwich in Madison? The city has a few hidden spots serving up this fresh, Italian-inspired classic. Whether you’re after gooey mozzarella, ripe tomatoes, and lush basil layered on crusty bread or a creative twist, exploring the caprese sandwich in Madison is a mouthwatering mini-adventure.
Toc
1. Merchant Madison
Modern American spot known for inventive comfort food, standout cocktails, and a lively downtown vibe.
__NEW TEXT__
A brunch visit brought a mixed but satisfying experience. While a request for over medium eggs resulted in scrambled ones, the rest of the meal impressed with a Cauliflower Cobb salad, mac and cheese, and a burger with fries—all delicious and well-prepared. Bacon arrived a bit chewier than expected, but overall, the service remained attentive and the setting offered a comfortable, welcoming vibe. Staff managed to be friendly without hovering.
A recent birthday celebration dinner highlighted the restaurant's strengths. Starters like chili crunch hummus and fried cheese curds paired nicely with a passion fruit pisco sour. The oyster mushroom shawarma stood out, and the server's attentiveness elevated the occasion. On a rainy evening, a thoughtful gesture of offering a towel left a positive impression, wrapping up a memorable evening with genuine hospitality and flavorful food.
A brunch visit brought a mixed but satisfying experience. While a request for over medium eggs resulted in scrambled ones, the rest of the meal impressed with a Cauliflower Cobb salad, mac and cheese, and a burger with fries—all delicious and well-prepared. Bacon arrived a bit chewier than expected, but overall, the service remained attentive and the setting offered a comfortable, welcoming vibe. Staff managed to be friendly without hovering.
A recent birthday celebration dinner highlighted the restaurant's strengths. Starters like chili crunch hummus and fried cheese curds paired nicely with a passion fruit pisco sour. The oyster mushroom shawarma stood out, and the server's attentiveness elevated the occasion. On a rainy evening, a thoughtful gesture of offering a towel left a positive impression, wrapping up a memorable evening with genuine hospitality and flavorful food.
TOPICS
- Downtown Spots
- American Cuisine
- Mid-Range
- Dinner
- Vegetarian Options
- Social Gatherings
Relate link
2. Pizza Brutta
Neapolitan pizzas and sandwiches made with wood-fired dough and ultra-fresh, quality ingredients.
__NEW TEXT__
The pizza Margherita proved popular with two at the table, showcasing a balance of flavors and a crisp yet chewy base. Meanwhile, the seasonal Caprese sandwich stood out for its remarkable freshness—house-made mozzarella, heirloom tomatoes, and basil nestled inside an airy, flavorful pizza roll created a memorable combination. Both dishes reflected care in preparation and an evident commitment to quality ingredients.
Sandwiches from this kitchen impress with generous portions and a focus on the bread. The bread, seemingly made from the same dough as the lauded pizzas, boasts a depth of flavor and appealing texture that lifts the entire experience. It's clear the star is not just the filling, but the exceptionally tasty bread itself, adding a satisfying, aromatic element to every bite.
The pizza Margherita proved popular with two at the table, showcasing a balance of flavors and a crisp yet chewy base. Meanwhile, the seasonal Caprese sandwich stood out for its remarkable freshness—house-made mozzarella, heirloom tomatoes, and basil nestled inside an airy, flavorful pizza roll created a memorable combination. Both dishes reflected care in preparation and an evident commitment to quality ingredients.
Sandwiches from this kitchen impress with generous portions and a focus on the bread. The bread, seemingly made from the same dough as the lauded pizzas, boasts a depth of flavor and appealing texture that lifts the entire experience. It's clear the star is not just the filling, but the exceptionally tasty bread itself, adding a satisfying, aromatic element to every bite.
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- Italian Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Mid-Range
- Downtown Spots
- Dinner
3. Stalzy's Deli
Neighborhood deli with artisan sandwiches, bakery classics, and friendly, welcoming vibes.
__NEW TEXT__
Stalzy’s delivers a memorable dining experience, blending a welcoming atmosphere with outstanding food and attentive service. The Reuben and Rachel sandwiches stand out for their perfectly toasted rye and generous fillings, elevating classic deli fare to something special. Hash browns are equally impressive, adding a satisfying touch to any lunch.
Whether dining solo or with company, guests leave satisfied by both the inviting space and the thoughtful execution of each dish. The burger, served well-done with crispy bacon, holds its own among seasoned burger enthusiasts. Stalzy’s is a true neighborhood gem, ideal for breakfast or lunch near the gardens.
Stalzy’s delivers a memorable dining experience, blending a welcoming atmosphere with outstanding food and attentive service. The Reuben and Rachel sandwiches stand out for their perfectly toasted rye and generous fillings, elevating classic deli fare to something special. Hash browns are equally impressive, adding a satisfying touch to any lunch.
Whether dining solo or with company, guests leave satisfied by both the inviting space and the thoughtful execution of each dish. The burger, served well-done with crispy bacon, holds its own among seasoned burger enthusiasts. Stalzy’s is a true neighborhood gem, ideal for breakfast or lunch near the gardens.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Mid-Range
- Hidden Gems
- Lunch
Relate link
4. Gino's Italian Deli
Locally beloved for hearty Italian subs and the freshest homemade bread in Madison.
__NEW TEXT__
The sub arrives generously packed with meat, and staff are happy to customize sandwiches beyond the listed ingredients upon request. The deli showcases a solid selection of meats and cheeses, making it a standout for those who appreciate variety and quality in their lunch options.
Gino’s Italian Deli consistently impresses as a must-visit spot for travelers in Madison. The sub sandwiches stand out for their flavor, with homemade bread setting a new standard for freshness. Combined with attentive service, this deli makes a reliable and satisfying stop.
The sub arrives generously packed with meat, and staff are happy to customize sandwiches beyond the listed ingredients upon request. The deli showcases a solid selection of meats and cheeses, making it a standout for those who appreciate variety and quality in their lunch options.
Gino’s Italian Deli consistently impresses as a must-visit spot for travelers in Madison. The sub sandwiches stand out for their flavor, with homemade bread setting a new standard for freshness. Combined with attentive service, this deli makes a reliable and satisfying stop.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Budget-Friendly Eats
- Suburban
- Lunch
5. Jason's Deli
Italian-inspired freshness: standout Caprese Panini bursting with flavor and quality ingredients.
__NEW TEXT__
Caprese Panini shines on the Jason’s Deli menu, blending fresh mozzarella, juicy Roma tomatoes, and flavorful pesto aioli in every mouthful. The soft herb panini bread provides an ideal backdrop, highlighting the uncomplicated yet vibrant taste profile that defines Italian fare.
This dish delivers a refreshing sandwich experience, inviting diners to enjoy familiar ingredients in perfect harmony. The thoughtfully crafted layering ensures the delicate creaminess of mozzarella and the bright, aromatic punch of pesto are enjoyed in every bite, making this panini a true highlight.
Caprese Panini shines on the Jason’s Deli menu, blending fresh mozzarella, juicy Roma tomatoes, and flavorful pesto aioli in every mouthful. The soft herb panini bread provides an ideal backdrop, highlighting the uncomplicated yet vibrant taste profile that defines Italian fare.
This dish delivers a refreshing sandwich experience, inviting diners to enjoy familiar ingredients in perfect harmony. The thoughtfully crafted layering ensures the delicate creaminess of mozzarella and the bright, aromatic punch of pesto are enjoyed in every bite, making this panini a true highlight.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Budget-Friendly Eats
- Suburban
- Lunch
6. Crostini Sandwiches
Local favorite for big, flavor-packed sandwiches and welcoming, laid-back vibes.
__NEW TEXT__
Crostini Sandwiches consistently impresses with generous, flavorful offerings. The meatball panini and Italian panini stand out for their rich taste, even if a bit messy. Specialty subs like the chipotle turkey deliver great texture, and the menu gives plenty of options for anyone seeking a classic deli fix. The Italian beef and gyro platter evoke the experience of bigger city delis, bringing a welcome authenticity. Fresh ingredients and attentive service make this spot a standout among sandwich shops.
Crostini Sandwiches consistently impresses with generous, flavorful offerings. The meatball panini and Italian panini stand out for their rich taste, even if a bit messy. Specialty subs like the chipotle turkey deliver great texture, and the menu gives plenty of options for anyone seeking a classic deli fix. The Italian beef and gyro platter evoke the experience of bigger city delis, bringing a welcome authenticity. Fresh ingredients and attentive service make this spot a standout among sandwich shops.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Cheap Eats
- Hidden Gems
- Lunch
7. Fabiola's Spaghetti House & Deli
Classic Italian eats in a cute setting, modern touches on comfort, and standout service every visit.
__NEW TEXT__
Exceptional attention to detail sets this restaurant apart. The salmon arrives with a flawless sear, and the staff creates a relaxed, welcoming environment—never rushing diners, always anticipating needs. Special thanks go to Jolie for her attentive service, which elevates the entire experience. Even small gestures, such as brewing fresh coffee, leave a lasting impression and invite repeat visits.
The opening of this red sauce Italian eatery fills a gap left by Josie’s, satisfying locals seeking nostalgia and newcomers craving quality. While classic dishes are present, the menu surprises with inventive interpretations of Italian staples, adding a modern twist. The atmosphere strikes a balance between cozy neighborhood charm and sophisticated dining, making every visit memorable.
Exceptional attention to detail sets this restaurant apart. The salmon arrives with a flawless sear, and the staff creates a relaxed, welcoming environment—never rushing diners, always anticipating needs. Special thanks go to Jolie for her attentive service, which elevates the entire experience. Even small gestures, such as brewing fresh coffee, leave a lasting impression and invite repeat visits.
The opening of this red sauce Italian eatery fills a gap left by Josie’s, satisfying locals seeking nostalgia and newcomers craving quality. While classic dishes are present, the menu surprises with inventive interpretations of Italian staples, adding a modern twist. The atmosphere strikes a balance between cozy neighborhood charm and sophisticated dining, making every visit memorable.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Mid-Range
- Downtown Spots
- Social Gatherings
- Vegetarian Options
- Dinner
Relate link
8. Hot Lunch
Retro vibes, inventive comfort sandwiches, cocktails and sodas—all served with nostalgic flair.
__NEW TEXT__
A stop at this sandwich shop during a rainy weekday lunch revealed a lively atmosphere and a menu with strong local buzz. The sandwiches, including a fairly good vegan banh mi, come in generous portions at reasonable prices. Staff remained friendly and attentive, adding to the enjoyable experience, while the house-made sodas and cocktails on draft provided extra appeal for anyone looking to linger.
Despite the relaxing vibe and inventive drinks, the high overall rating appears puzzling when factoring in value and wait time. Several diners have remarked that, though the setting proves memorable and the fare tastes good, the cost and lengthy service detract from the overall impression. While the spot remains popular among groups and casual diners, expectations may require adjustment.
A stop at this sandwich shop during a rainy weekday lunch revealed a lively atmosphere and a menu with strong local buzz. The sandwiches, including a fairly good vegan banh mi, come in generous portions at reasonable prices. Staff remained friendly and attentive, adding to the enjoyable experience, while the house-made sodas and cocktails on draft provided extra appeal for anyone looking to linger.
Despite the relaxing vibe and inventive drinks, the high overall rating appears puzzling when factoring in value and wait time. Several diners have remarked that, though the setting proves memorable and the fare tastes good, the cost and lengthy service detract from the overall impression. While the spot remains popular among groups and casual diners, expectations may require adjustment.
TOPICS
- Fusion Cuisine
- Mid-Range
- Downtown Spots
- Lunch
9. The Borough
Modern American comfort food with a focus on fresh, locally-sourced ingredients in a cozy space.
__NEW TEXT__
The Caprese Sandwich arrives on gently toasted bread, featuring a pleasantly flaky exterior and a soft, cool interior. Fresh mozzarella and ripe tomato create a well-balanced bite, though the overall experience stops short of being truly memorable. Execution is competent, but it lacks a spark to warrant a repeat visit.
Mushroom soup impresses with a creamy, comforting texture and a deep, earthy flavor profile. The seasoning feels just right, elevating the familiar favorite without overwhelming the palate. Both dishes are satisfying, yet neither crosses into must-try territory.
The Caprese Sandwich arrives on gently toasted bread, featuring a pleasantly flaky exterior and a soft, cool interior. Fresh mozzarella and ripe tomato create a well-balanced bite, though the overall experience stops short of being truly memorable. Execution is competent, but it lacks a spark to warrant a repeat visit.
Mushroom soup impresses with a creamy, comforting texture and a deep, earthy flavor profile. The seasoning feels just right, elevating the familiar favorite without overwhelming the palate. Both dishes are satisfying, yet neither crosses into must-try territory.
TOPICS
- Downtown Spots
- Fusion Cuisine
- Mid-Range
- Dinner
- Social Gatherings
Relate link
10. Yola's Cafe and Coffee Shop of Madison
Homestyle breakfast classics and standout sandwiches in a cozy, community-focused setting.
__NEW TEXT__
Yola’s breakfast menu offers a standout Belgian waffle, made with a cherished family recipe and an undisclosed twist, served with strawberries and a generous cloud of whipped cream. The supporting lineup includes classic egg dishes, hearty oatmeal, yogurt, and a tempting bakery selection, ensuring broad appeal for a variety of breakfast preferences.
The breakfast sandwich earns particular praise for its layered flavors and satisfying composition, quickly becoming a go-to favorite among guests. Friendly, accommodating staff enhance the cozy atmosphere and make every visit feel welcoming. Yola’s manages to combine comforting classics with signature options for a memorable morning meal.
Yola’s breakfast menu offers a standout Belgian waffle, made with a cherished family recipe and an undisclosed twist, served with strawberries and a generous cloud of whipped cream. The supporting lineup includes classic egg dishes, hearty oatmeal, yogurt, and a tempting bakery selection, ensuring broad appeal for a variety of breakfast preferences.
The breakfast sandwich earns particular praise for its layered flavors and satisfying composition, quickly becoming a go-to favorite among guests. Friendly, accommodating staff enhance the cozy atmosphere and make every visit feel welcoming. Yola’s manages to combine comforting classics with signature options for a memorable morning meal.
TOPICS
- Suburban
- American Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Breakfast
- Mid-Range
Relate link
11. Teddywedgers
Legendary home of hearty hand pies and unbelievably good, crave-worthy sandwiches in Madison.
__NEW TEXT__
Teddywedgers consistently delivers an inviting atmosphere, elevated by staff who treat customers like regulars. Unprompted generosity, like a deal on pasties that looked flawless, speaks volumes about a high standard—perhaps even perfectionism—among the crew. The aroma alone is enough to draw people in, but it’s the small interactions that set this place apart.
Each visit brings a new twist, sometimes with a quirky song recommendation request, other times bolstered by friendly conversation and the promise of the daily special. Even when the timing isn’t perfect and some pasties are sold out, loyal locals still consider it a fixture in the Madison food scene. One bite of the corned beef hash pasty and it’s easy to see why people keep coming back decade after decade.
Teddywedgers consistently delivers an inviting atmosphere, elevated by staff who treat customers like regulars. Unprompted generosity, like a deal on pasties that looked flawless, speaks volumes about a high standard—perhaps even perfectionism—among the crew. The aroma alone is enough to draw people in, but it’s the small interactions that set this place apart.
Each visit brings a new twist, sometimes with a quirky song recommendation request, other times bolstered by friendly conversation and the promise of the daily special. Even when the timing isn’t perfect and some pasties are sold out, loyal locals still consider it a fixture in the Madison food scene. One bite of the corned beef hash pasty and it’s easy to see why people keep coming back decade after decade.
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- American Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Cheap Eats
- Downtown Spots
- Lunch
Relate link
12. Bar Corallini
A modern Italian eatery serving inventive classics, with vibrant ambiance and standout vegan options.
__NEW TEXT__
Bar Corallini consistently impresses with its inventive menu and polished atmosphere, making it a top choice for special occasions. The range of unique dishes, such as the Zucca pizza with butternut squash, demonstrates both creativity and skill in the kitchen. Service exudes a thoughtful touch, as staff go above and beyond to elevate celebrations and ensure every guest feels welcome. Desserts also stand out as a highlight, rounding out the dining experience.
Beyond the menu, Bar Corallini’s ambiance adds to its appeal. The interior blends modern elegance with warmth, creating a setting ideal for both intimate dinners and lively gatherings. Even during busy times, the staff remains accommodating and unhurried. Visitors frequently mention how memorable their experiences are, whether traveling from out of town or simply enjoying a night out in Madison.
Bar Corallini consistently impresses with its inventive menu and polished atmosphere, making it a top choice for special occasions. The range of unique dishes, such as the Zucca pizza with butternut squash, demonstrates both creativity and skill in the kitchen. Service exudes a thoughtful touch, as staff go above and beyond to elevate celebrations and ensure every guest feels welcome. Desserts also stand out as a highlight, rounding out the dining experience.
Beyond the menu, Bar Corallini’s ambiance adds to its appeal. The interior blends modern elegance with warmth, creating a setting ideal for both intimate dinners and lively gatherings. Even during busy times, the staff remains accommodating and unhurried. Visitors frequently mention how memorable their experiences are, whether traveling from out of town or simply enjoying a night out in Madison.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Mid-Range
- Downtown Spots
- Dinner
Relate link