14 best Italian restaurants in Upper East Side New York City
Italian restaurants in Upper East Side NYC offer a wide variety of delicious and authentic Italian cuisine. From classic pasta dishes to savory pizzas, these restaurants cater to all tastes and preferences. With a cozy and inviting atmosphere, they provide the perfect setting to enjoy a meal with family and friends. Dive into the rich flavors and traditions of Italy right in the heart of NYC's Upper East Side.
Toc
1. Tony's Di Napoli
Family-style Italian dining with a warm, lively atmosphere.
__NEW TEXT__
Tony's Di Napoli is consistently one of the best restaurants in New York City, offering a top-notch Italian dining experience. The food is always exceptional, with a wide selection of pizzas, pastas, and other classic Italian dishes. The atmosphere is cozy and inviting, making it the perfect place for a family dinner or a night out with friends.
The hospitality at Tony's Di Napoli is unmatched, with friendly and attentive staff who go above and beyond to make sure every guest feels welcome. The restaurant's commitment to quality and customer satisfaction is evident in every aspect of the dining experience. From the delicious food to the warm and welcoming ambiance, Tony's Di Napoli is truly a standout among New York City's many Italian restaurants.
Tony's Di Napoli is consistently one of the best restaurants in New York City, offering a top-notch Italian dining experience. The food is always exceptional, with a wide selection of pizzas, pastas, and other classic Italian dishes. The atmosphere is cozy and inviting, making it the perfect place for a family dinner or a night out with friends.
The hospitality at Tony's Di Napoli is unmatched, with friendly and attentive staff who go above and beyond to make sure every guest feels welcome. The restaurant's commitment to quality and customer satisfaction is evident in every aspect of the dining experience. From the delicious food to the warm and welcoming ambiance, Tony's Di Napoli is truly a standout among New York City's many Italian restaurants.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Downtown Spots
2. L'Osteria
Homemade pasta and seasonal ingredients.
__NEW TEXT__
The pasta presented at this establishment is a culinary delight, showcasing a rich and satisfying dining experience. The dishes are made in-house using fresh, seasonal ingredients, resulting in an unforgettable and delicious pasta affair.
As a beloved neighborhood establishment, this restaurant offers a charming and intimate atmosphere, making it a perfect spot for special occasions. Here, you can savor homemade pasta dishes that stand out from the usual, leaving a lasting impression on even the most discerning palate.
The pasta presented at this establishment is a culinary delight, showcasing a rich and satisfying dining experience. The dishes are made in-house using fresh, seasonal ingredients, resulting in an unforgettable and delicious pasta affair.
As a beloved neighborhood establishment, this restaurant offers a charming and intimate atmosphere, making it a perfect spot for special occasions. Here, you can savor homemade pasta dishes that stand out from the usual, leaving a lasting impression on even the most discerning palate.
3. Antonucci Cafe
Elevated Italian fare with a touch of home
__NEW TEXT__
A memorable dining experience was had at Antonucci Cafe. Of particular note was the bronzino, which was expertly prepared with a perfectly crisp exterior and delicate, well-cooked fish within.
The eggplant ravioli and cavatelli were also outstanding choices, offering traditional Italian flavors with a regional twist from Venice. Each dish showcased the careful attention to detail and commitment to quality that is the hallmark of Antonucci Cafe.
A memorable dining experience was had at Antonucci Cafe. Of particular note was the bronzino, which was expertly prepared with a perfectly crisp exterior and delicate, well-cooked fish within.
The eggplant ravioli and cavatelli were also outstanding choices, offering traditional Italian flavors with a regional twist from Venice. Each dish showcased the careful attention to detail and commitment to quality that is the hallmark of Antonucci Cafe.
4. Elio's
Classic Italian dining on the Upper East Side.
__NEW TEXT__
Elio's, a classic New York establishment located in the Upper East Side, is a must-visit for anyone seeking a traditional and upscale dining experience. The restaurant's charm lies in its ability to consistently deliver excellent food, drink, and service, making it a popular destination for both locals and tourists alike. Although it may be on the pricier side, the experience at Elio's is worth every penny.
The bar at Elio's is an intimate and warm setting, perfect for a drink or a meal. The experienced bartenders are skilled at crafting classic cocktails, as well as offering expert recommendations for wine pairings. The menu features a range of Italian dishes made with fresh, high-quality ingredients. Whether you're in the mood for a hearty pasta dish or a delicate fish entreé, Elio's has something to satisfy every craving. The warm and inviting atmosphere, combined with the knowledgeable and friendly service, make Elio's a standout dining experience.
Elio's, a classic New York establishment located in the Upper East Side, is a must-visit for anyone seeking a traditional and upscale dining experience. The restaurant's charm lies in its ability to consistently deliver excellent food, drink, and service, making it a popular destination for both locals and tourists alike. Although it may be on the pricier side, the experience at Elio's is worth every penny.
The bar at Elio's is an intimate and warm setting, perfect for a drink or a meal. The experienced bartenders are skilled at crafting classic cocktails, as well as offering expert recommendations for wine pairings. The menu features a range of Italian dishes made with fresh, high-quality ingredients. Whether you're in the mood for a hearty pasta dish or a delicate fish entreé, Elio's has something to satisfy every craving. The warm and inviting atmosphere, combined with the knowledgeable and friendly service, make Elio's a standout dining experience.
5. Sfoglia
Rustic Italian charm with a seasonal, creative menu.
__NEW TEXT__
The dishes offered by this establishment are characterized by their savory and delightfully crispy-yet-chewy texture, with an emphasis on freshness. Breads, pastas, pastries, pappardelle, and gnocchi are all made with great care and attention to detail. The menu features a prosciutto sandwich on a signature ciabatta-focaccia hybrid bread, as well as chicken cooked under a brick for a succulent, crispy skin. Small plates such as crostini with housemade labne and blueberry compote, sprinkled with pistachios and finished with a hint of mint, are also available.
The service at this restaurant has been described as a bit of a mixed bag. Some reviewers have praised it for its elegance and amazing level of care, giving it a perfect score. Others, however, have found it to be slow, distracted, or even rushed. This discrepancy may be due to variations in staffing or simply differences in individual expectations and experiences. Overall, while there are some reports of subpar service, many customers have had positive experiences with the restaurant's staff.
The dishes offered by this establishment are characterized by their savory and delightfully crispy-yet-chewy texture, with an emphasis on freshness. Breads, pastas, pastries, pappardelle, and gnocchi are all made with great care and attention to detail. The menu features a prosciutto sandwich on a signature ciabatta-focaccia hybrid bread, as well as chicken cooked under a brick for a succulent, crispy skin. Small plates such as crostini with housemade labne and blueberry compote, sprinkled with pistachios and finished with a hint of mint, are also available.
The service at this restaurant has been described as a bit of a mixed bag. Some reviewers have praised it for its elegance and amazing level of care, giving it a perfect score. Others, however, have found it to be slow, distracted, or even rushed. This discrepancy may be due to variations in staffing or simply differences in individual expectations and experiences. Overall, while there are some reports of subpar service, many customers have had positive experiences with the restaurant's staff.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Mid-Range
- Downtown Spots
6. Lusardi's
Sophisticated yet casual dining with a neighborhood charm
__NEW TEXT__
The level of service provided at this establishment is consistently praised by patrons. Staff are attentive and go out of their way to accommodate customers, creating a welcoming and friendly atmosphere. Reviewers have described their experiences with the service as nothing short of excellent.
The seafood served at this restaurant is a standout feature. Fresh and perfectly cooked, it consistently receives high praise from diners. However, some reviewers have noted that the pasta dishes could be improved, finding them lacking in flavor compared to the seafood options. Despite this, the overall consensus is that the seafood is not to be missed.
The level of service provided at this establishment is consistently praised by patrons. Staff are attentive and go out of their way to accommodate customers, creating a welcoming and friendly atmosphere. Reviewers have described their experiences with the service as nothing short of excellent.
The seafood served at this restaurant is a standout feature. Fresh and perfectly cooked, it consistently receives high praise from diners. However, some reviewers have noted that the pasta dishes could be improved, finding them lacking in flavor compared to the seafood options. Despite this, the overall consensus is that the seafood is not to be missed.
7. Due
Prime Upper East Side living with luxury features
__NEW TEXT__
This establishment is an excellent choice for various occasions, providing a warm and inviting atmosphere that is perfect for a romantic date night or a relaxed gathering with friends. The extensive wine list caters to a range of preferences, ensuring a satisfactory selection for all guests. The menu features an array of dishes, each one skillfully prepared and presented, making it difficult to choose a favorite.
The service team is highly trained, demonstrating both professionalism and friendliness. With attentive service, they cater to guests' needs without being intrusive. Although a small number of guests occasionally report instances of inattentiveness, the overall consensus is one of praise and appreciation for the respectful and efficient treatment they receive. This commitment to providing top-quality service elevates the dining experience to new heights, leaving a lasting, positive impression on those who visit.
This establishment is an excellent choice for various occasions, providing a warm and inviting atmosphere that is perfect for a romantic date night or a relaxed gathering with friends. The extensive wine list caters to a range of preferences, ensuring a satisfactory selection for all guests. The menu features an array of dishes, each one skillfully prepared and presented, making it difficult to choose a favorite.
The service team is highly trained, demonstrating both professionalism and friendliness. With attentive service, they cater to guests' needs without being intrusive. Although a small number of guests occasionally report instances of inattentiveness, the overall consensus is one of praise and appreciation for the respectful and efficient treatment they receive. This commitment to providing top-quality service elevates the dining experience to new heights, leaving a lasting, positive impression on those who visit.
8. 83 1/2
A warm, welcoming place where friends and families share their passion for food.
__NEW TEXT__
This establishment prides itself on fast and reliable delivery services. They understand the importance of punctuality when it comes to delivering food to their customers, particularly those who are hosting guests. The quality of their cuisine is frequently commended, and guests often express their satisfaction with the service.
As a frequent diner, one can attest to the consistently good service and delicious food served at this establishment. The staff is friendly and attentive, providing a delightful dining experience. The menu offers a wide variety of options, catering to diverse palates and preferences, making it an excellent choice for a meal out.
This establishment prides itself on fast and reliable delivery services. They understand the importance of punctuality when it comes to delivering food to their customers, particularly those who are hosting guests. The quality of their cuisine is frequently commended, and guests often express their satisfaction with the service.
As a frequent diner, one can attest to the consistently good service and delicious food served at this establishment. The staff is friendly and attentive, providing a delightful dining experience. The menu offers a wide variety of options, catering to diverse palates and preferences, making it an excellent choice for a meal out.
9. Nica Trattoria
Feels like dining with family in a cozy Italian home.
__NEW TEXT__
A great neighborhood restaurant, the food at this establishment is both delicious and made-to-order. The chef, Nica, takes great pride in his culinary creations, which becomes apparent with each bite. A date night at this cozy spot proved to be both enjoyable and satisfying, with Nica's warm and welcoming demeanor adding to the overall positive experience. This intimate eatery evokes the feeling of dining at a close friend's home, further enhancing its appeal.
This charming Italian restaurant is small in size but big on flavor. Giuseppe, the owner, chef, and server, provides diners with a personalized and attentive dining experience. The 'famous' lamb chops, as recommended by Giuseppe, are a must-try, boasting a perfect balance of seasoning and an unforgettable taste. The clean plates that result from such a dish are a testament to the quality of food offered at this hidden gem.
A great neighborhood restaurant, the food at this establishment is both delicious and made-to-order. The chef, Nica, takes great pride in his culinary creations, which becomes apparent with each bite. A date night at this cozy spot proved to be both enjoyable and satisfying, with Nica's warm and welcoming demeanor adding to the overall positive experience. This intimate eatery evokes the feeling of dining at a close friend's home, further enhancing its appeal.
This charming Italian restaurant is small in size but big on flavor. Giuseppe, the owner, chef, and server, provides diners with a personalized and attentive dining experience. The 'famous' lamb chops, as recommended by Giuseppe, are a must-try, boasting a perfect balance of seasoning and an unforgettable taste. The clean plates that result from such a dish are a testament to the quality of food offered at this hidden gem.
10. Paola's
Authentic Italian cuisine in the heart of Carnegie Hill.
__NEW TEXT__
Some customers have reported negative experiences with the service at this establishment, citing slow response times and a lack of attentiveness from staff. Others have gone so far as to describe the service as rude and unaccommodating, which is certainly disappointing to hear. It's worth noting, however, that not all customers have had this experience, with some praising the friendliness and attentiveness of the staff.
Despite the issues with service, there is widespread agreement among reviewers that the food at this establishment is of high quality. The pasta dishes in particular have received rave reviews, with many customers praising the freshness and consistency of the ingredients. Whether you're in the mood for a hearty plate of spaghetti or a lighter pasta salad, you can expect to enjoy a delicious and satisfying meal. It's just a shame that the service doesn't always live up to the same high standards.
Some customers have reported negative experiences with the service at this establishment, citing slow response times and a lack of attentiveness from staff. Others have gone so far as to describe the service as rude and unaccommodating, which is certainly disappointing to hear. It's worth noting, however, that not all customers have had this experience, with some praising the friendliness and attentiveness of the staff.
Despite the issues with service, there is widespread agreement among reviewers that the food at this establishment is of high quality. The pasta dishes in particular have received rave reviews, with many customers praising the freshness and consistency of the ingredients. Whether you're in the mood for a hearty plate of spaghetti or a lighter pasta salad, you can expect to enjoy a delicious and satisfying meal. It's just a shame that the service doesn't always live up to the same high standards.
11. Uva
Rustic charm with a touch of Italian elegance.
__NEW TEXT__
The portions at the restaurant are on the smaller side and the prices are somewhat steep, but many diners still find the food to be worth the cost. Some dishes may come across as bland, while others feature bold and robust flavors. Despite this, the overall consensus about the food leans towards the positive, with many customers rating their meals as great or excellent.
A recent visitor raved about their meal, which started with cacciatorino, air-dried salami, followed by pappardelle al ragu di Vitello, pasta ribbons with veal. Both dishes were met with enthusiasm, as they provided an explosion of mouthwatering flavors. The staff at the establishment were also commended for their attentiveness and willingness to accommodate a customer's request for a cocktail swap, which led to a positive dining experience overall.
The portions at the restaurant are on the smaller side and the prices are somewhat steep, but many diners still find the food to be worth the cost. Some dishes may come across as bland, while others feature bold and robust flavors. Despite this, the overall consensus about the food leans towards the positive, with many customers rating their meals as great or excellent.
A recent visitor raved about their meal, which started with cacciatorino, air-dried salami, followed by pappardelle al ragu di Vitello, pasta ribbons with veal. Both dishes were met with enthusiasm, as they provided an explosion of mouthwatering flavors. The staff at the establishment were also commended for their attentiveness and willingness to accommodate a customer's request for a cocktail swap, which led to a positive dining experience overall.
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- American Cuisine
- Cheap Eats
- Downtown Spots
12. Maruzzella
Cooking with love for decades in the Upper East Side
__NEW TEXT__
The pasta dishes served at this establishment are a delight, with each bite offering a taste of classic, home-made flavors. The care and attention given to cooking the pasta results in a perfect texture that is neither overcooked nor underdone. Additionally, the seafood options are a popular choice, boasting a freshness that elevates the overall dining experience.
The service at this restaurant is top-notch, with friendly and efficient servers who go above and beyond to ensure a pleasant meal. They provide attentive service, constantly checking in on customers while still giving them space to enjoy their meals. The servers' use of humor and their diligence in keeping water glasses full adds an extra layer of hospitality to the dining experience. Overall, the service is a perfect complement to the delicious food.
The pasta dishes served at this establishment are a delight, with each bite offering a taste of classic, home-made flavors. The care and attention given to cooking the pasta results in a perfect texture that is neither overcooked nor underdone. Additionally, the seafood options are a popular choice, boasting a freshness that elevates the overall dining experience.
The service at this restaurant is top-notch, with friendly and efficient servers who go above and beyond to ensure a pleasant meal. They provide attentive service, constantly checking in on customers while still giving them space to enjoy their meals. The servers' use of humor and their diligence in keeping water glasses full adds an extra layer of hospitality to the dining experience. Overall, the service is a perfect complement to the delicious food.
13. Felice 83
Experience the taste of Italy in every bite.
__NEW TEXT__
Felice 83 is a restaurant that beautifully captures the essence of Italy, with its design inspired by the refined elegance of Florence and the cozy comfort of the Tuscan countryside. The atmosphere is welcoming and inviting, making it an ideal spot for a romantic dinner or a special occasion.
The service at Felice 83 is consistently rated as excellent. Servers are friendly, prompt, and attentive, ensuring that guests feel well taken care of throughout their meal. They are also knowledgeable about the menu and wine list, providing helpful recommendations and insights to enhance the dining experience. The level of service adds to the overall enjoyment of the meal, making Felice 83 a standout destination for those seeking a top-notch Italian dining experience.
Felice 83 is a restaurant that beautifully captures the essence of Italy, with its design inspired by the refined elegance of Florence and the cozy comfort of the Tuscan countryside. The atmosphere is welcoming and inviting, making it an ideal spot for a romantic dinner or a special occasion.
The service at Felice 83 is consistently rated as excellent. Servers are friendly, prompt, and attentive, ensuring that guests feel well taken care of throughout their meal. They are also knowledgeable about the menu and wine list, providing helpful recommendations and insights to enhance the dining experience. The level of service adds to the overall enjoyment of the meal, making Felice 83 a standout destination for those seeking a top-notch Italian dining experience.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Lunch
- Dinner
- Downtown Spots
14. Sant Ambroeus Madison
A blend of Milanese tradition and New York elegance.
__NEW TEXT__
Sant Ambroeus Madison, an upscale Italian restaurant on Manhattan's Upper East Side, draws a fashionable crowd of New Yorkers who appreciate its sophisticated atmosphere and exquisite cuisine. The restaurant's location on Madison Avenue only adds to its appeal, making it a popular destination for those seeking a chic dining experience.
Despite the occasional snooty demeanor of some waitstaff members, Sant Ambroeus Madison is recognized for its remarkable culinary offerings. The menu boasts a selection of authentic Italian dishes, all prepared with fresh, high-quality ingredients, which results in a truly satisfying dining experience. The establishment's commitment to providing exceptional dishes, even in the face of a sometimes pretentious ambiance, makes it a must-visit location for food connoisseurs in New York City.
Sant Ambroeus Madison, an upscale Italian restaurant on Manhattan's Upper East Side, draws a fashionable crowd of New Yorkers who appreciate its sophisticated atmosphere and exquisite cuisine. The restaurant's location on Madison Avenue only adds to its appeal, making it a popular destination for those seeking a chic dining experience.
Despite the occasional snooty demeanor of some waitstaff members, Sant Ambroeus Madison is recognized for its remarkable culinary offerings. The menu boasts a selection of authentic Italian dishes, all prepared with fresh, high-quality ingredients, which results in a truly satisfying dining experience. The establishment's commitment to providing exceptional dishes, even in the face of a sometimes pretentious ambiance, makes it a must-visit location for food connoisseurs in New York City.