14 Best ice cream shops in Yonkers New York
Ice cream shops in Yonkers, NY, offer a delightful treat for both locals and visitors. These establishments provide a wide range of flavors and textures, from classic vanilla and chocolate to innovative concoctions like lavender honey and vegan options. Whether you're looking for a refreshing dessert or a fun family outing, ice cream shops in Yonkers NY have got you covered!
- 1. Lost Borough Ice Cream
- 2. Paleteria La Michoacana
- 3. La Imperial Mexican Ice's
- 4. Ralph's Famous Italian Ices
- 5. Carvel
- 6. Häagen-Dazs Ice Cream
- 7. Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard
- 8. CookiesNcream
- 9. Baskin-Robbins
- 10. Paleteria y Jugos Pueblo
- 11. Swirlnjoy
- 12. Haagen-Dazs
- 13. Penny Lick Ice Cream
- 14. Uncle Louie G's
1. Lost Borough Ice Cream
Handcrafted ice cream with endless flavor possibilities
Lost Borough Ice Cream is a small but outstanding ice cream shop located in Yonkers. Known for its fun and welcoming atmosphere, the shop offers a wide variety of unique and delicious flavors all made in-house. Some customer favorites include Sakura, key lime pie, and Dominican Vanilla + Coconut, with some flavors rotating seasonally.
The extensive menu at Lost Borough Ice Cream holds its own when compared to even the biggest players in the NYC ice cream scene. From regional favorites like Grape Nut to more adventurous options like lemon blueberry cake, there's truly something for everyone. The shop's commitment to creating high-quality, creative flavors using only the freshest ingredients is evident in every scoop. Overall, Lost Borough Ice Cream stands out as a must-visit destination for any true ice cream lover.
2. Paleteria La Michoacana
A taste of Mexico in every bite!
Paleteria La Michoacana is an ideal spot for a rejuvenating break, offering a delightful menu that includes expertly prepared nacho chips, laing, and chili. The establishment is well-known for its delicious gelato, which is a must-try for any visitor. A majority of patrons have consistently praised the staff for their professionalism, and the speedy service is also commonly appreciated.
As a long-time customer of Paleteria La Michoacana, I can attest to the exceptional quality of their ice cream. The ice cream served here is simply unmatched and is the best I have ever tasted. One of the standout features of the ice cream is the extensive array of flavors available, which provides a unique and enjoyable experience with every visit.
3. La Imperial Mexican Ice's
4. Ralph's Famous Italian Ices
Refreshing treats for every taste and preference.
Ralph's Famous Italian Ices is a popular destination for those with a sweet tooth. The establishment is renowned for its delicious ice cream, particularly the rich and creamy chocolate flavor topped with chocolate sprinkles. In addition to their traditional ice cream, they offer a wide range of Italian ices, including sugar-free options.
The staff at Ralph's are known for their friendliness and efficiency, even during the busy summer months. Customers can enjoy their treats at picnic tables set up outside the strip mall location. The variety of flavors is impressive, with pistachio creme and cotton candy being among the most popular choices. However, there have been occasional reports of order mix-ups, but this does not seem to deter the loyal customer base.
5. Carvel
Handmade ice cream cakes with famous chocolate crunchies
Carvel, a well-established business in Yonkers, has evolved from its humble beginnings as a small ice cream shop with only two flavors to a full-fledged dessert destination. The menu now includes an assortment of sweet treats such as ice cream cakes and Flying Saucers, a type of ice cream sandwich.
A recent visit to Carvel with family members resulted in a delightful experience. The classic charm of the establishment was still present, but with modern updates. A sundae was enjoyed, providing a heavenly and satisfying dessert experience. For those living abroad, Carvel is a must-visit for a taste of nostalgia and a high-quality treat.
6. Häagen-Dazs Ice Cream
Indulge in luxury with every scoop
A visitor had a highly distressing experience at a business establishment on a Wednesday afternoon. The individual went in at 12:15 PM and placed an order for a cone. However, the encounter took a turn for the worse when the server, who was allegedly new and had just opened for business, announced that she could not provide change for a 50 dollar bill. To make matters worse, the server then demanded the customer to return the cone and made the situation uncomfortable.
The customer was left feeling disrespected and unhappy with the encounter, having been served rudely and unprofessionally. The lack of basic customer service and change-giving skills displayed by the server marred an otherwise simple transaction, raising questions about the establishment's commitment to providing excellent customer service. The customer was left with a bad taste in their mouth, not due to the cone they had ordered, but due to the unprofessional behavior they had experienced.
7. Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard
Refreshing treats made fresh daily with real fruit flavors
A visitor's first experience with Rita's Italian Ice at the Bellefonte, DE location left a lasting impression. The cake batter custard and watermelon gelati stood out as particularly delicious, although the latter resulted in a brain freeze. The blend of custard and gelati, as suggested by Yousef, brought back memories of a McFlurry, but with a more refined and satisfying result.
Another customer's frequent visits to Rita's were sparked by a friend's initial introduction. Their go-to order is the blue raspberry and lemon frozen drink, a refreshing and flavorful combination. The establishment's welcoming atmosphere and personalized service are also noteworthy. The server remembered the customer's previous orders and even the selective girlfriend approved, leading to the nickname "our place". Such experiences have quickly made Rita's a go-to spot for this reviewer.
8. CookiesNcream
9. Baskin-Robbins
10. Paleteria y Jugos Pueblo
Best place in Yonkers for Mexican treats
Paleteria y Jugos Pueblo is a popular destination among visitors, boasting an impressive average rating of 4.47 out of 5, based on 34 reviews. Many guests have expressed their satisfaction with the food, praising it for its authentic Mexican flavors and exceptional taste. One satisfied customer described it as the "best place in Yonkers to enjoy Mexican food."
Aside from the delicious food, the staff at Paleteria y Jugos Pulo have also received high praise for their friendliness and attentive service. Although the establishment does not accept credit cards, customers have emphasized that it is worth making a trip to this establishment. With such glowing reviews, it's no wonder that this establishment is a favorite among visitors seeking delicious Mexican cuisine and excellent customer service.
11. Swirlnjoy
Ultimate self-serve frozen yogurt experience
Upon visiting a local yogurt shop, the staff's welcoming and helpful demeanor stood out from the moment I stepped inside. The shop offered a vast array of yogurt flavors and toppings, satisfying my sweet tooth. Among the many options, I discovered they carried my favorite frozen dessert - dipping dots, which I haven't seen in other shops. I'm excited to return for this rare treat.
This yogurt shop boasts a wide selection of frozen yogurt flavors, along with ice cream and sorbet, catering to all preferences. There is a plethora of toppings available to customize your dessert to your liking. Moreover, there are special treats for kids, making this a perfect family-friendly destination. The outdoor seating area is clean and inviting, offering a pleasant atmosphere. The friendly and helpful staff further elevate the shop's appeal.
12. Haagen-Dazs
Indulge in luxurious, handcrafted ice cream.
The Dazzler Sundae is a must-try for anyone who can't decide between ice cream flavors. By taking the server's suggestion and combining mint chip and Belgian chocolate ice cream, the customer experienced a delightful surprise. The smooth texture of the ice cream paired perfectly with the rich hot fudge, making for a more satisfying dessert than expected.
The ice cream selection is always top-notch, featuring unique flavors like vegan chocolate fudge. While the brownies seemed like a good idea to complement the ice cream, they fell short of expectations. Therefore, to truly enjoy the delicious ice cream, it is recommended to stick with ice cream-based desserts. Overall, the Dazzler Sundae is a standout option for those seeking a memorable ice cream experience.
13. Penny Lick Ice Cream
Old-fashioned ice cream with local ingredients
The company takes great pride in being tree nut, peanut, and sesame free. This commitment to allergen-free products is commendable and demonstrates a consideration for the well-being of their customers. By avoiding these common allergens, they are able to create a safer and more inclusive ice cream experience for all to enjoy.
The pricing of the ice cream is set at a fair and reasonable rate. The cost matches the quality and quantity of the product, providing customers with a generous portion of delicious ice cream. It's clear that the company values its customers and strives to provide them with a high-quality product at a reasonable price. This balance of quality and affordability makes the ice cream a great value for anyone looking to indulge in a tasty treat.
14. Uncle Louie G's
A taste of New York in every scoop
This ice cream shop provides a tasty and enjoyable experience, but there is room for improvement in the service department. The individual operating the counter during one's visit may have appeared disinterested and lacking in politeness, potentially contributing to the less-than-ideal service experience. It is possible that this is the same individual mentioned in other reviews.