23 most favorite Caribbean restaurants in New York City
In the vibrant and multicultural city of New York, Caribbean restaurants in NYC offer a delicious taste of the islands. These restaurants bring the vibrant flavors and spices of the Caribbean to life, transporting diners to sunny beaches and warm breezes with every bite. Whether you're craving spicy jerk chicken, savory stews, or fresh seafood, Caribbean restaurants in NYC have got you covered. Come and explore the rich culinary heritage of the Caribbean without leaving the bustling streets of NYC.
- 1. The Islands
- 2. Caribbean Starr
- 3. BK9
- 4. Freda's Cuisine
- 5. Sisters
- 6. Negril BK
- 7. Caribbean Soul
- 8. Karibbean
- 9. Golden Krust Caribbean Restaurant
- 10. Tings
- 11. Jasmine's Caribbean Cuisine
- 12. Omar's Kitchen and Rum Bar
- 13. Kokomo Caribbean Restaurant
- 14. Negril Village
- 15. Imani
- 16. Mangoville
- 17. FyahBun Creative
- 18. Miss Lily's 7A Cafe
- 19. Little Ochie
- 20. Cream Ridgewood
- 21. Caribbean Fiesta
- 22. Bamboo Walk Caribbean Restaurant
- 23. Veronica's Kitchen
1. The Islands
Offers a unique blend of urban living and natural beauty with stunning skyline views of Manhattan.

The atmosphere at the establishment is described as wonderful and family-friendly. The service is friendly and adds to the pleasant dining experience. Although the prices are on the expensive side, the quality of the food is said to be worth it.
The individual ordered rice and peas with jerk chicken and a side of plantains. The rice was noted to be very flavorful, with a discernible coconut taste that added to the delightfulness of the dish. The jerk chicken and plantains were also likely enjoyable, but the rice was specifically highlighted in the description.
2. Caribbean Starr
Live music on weekends

In one dining experience, the food received had issues with temperature and doneness. The rice was cold and burnt in certain areas, which was not enjoyable. However, it was decided to give the restaurant another chance, as this problem may have been an isolated incident.
In a separate instance, the food from the same restaurant was delicious. Both dishes were satisfying, despite the roti skin being a bit greasy. The curry goat was so flavorful that the greasiness of the roti was easily overlooked. Due to the positive experience, it was decided to order from this restaurant again.
3. BK9
Known for its extensive beer selection and lively atmosphere

The food at this establishment is consistently praised by reviewers for its delicious and flavorful qualities. Generous portions are served, ensuring that customers leave satisfied. Among the menu items, the rum raisin cake and fish tacos are standout favorites.
The drinks offered also receive positive feedback, with reviewers highlighting their strength and variety. Additionally, some customers have noted a happy hour promotion, indicating a value-added experience for patrons. Overall, the combination of delicious food and strong drinks makes for a positive dining experience.
4. Freda's Cuisine
Family-owned Italian restaurant with a homey feel

The restaurant ran out of the desired dish, but was unable to notify the customer through their system. As a result, an alternate order of baked chicken was provided. However, upon closer inspection, the chicken still had some feather stalks attached to the skin.
Regarding the side dish, the mac and cheese served was not enjoyable. The dish had a curdled appearance, indicating that it may not have been prepared correctly or served at the appropriate temperature.
5. Sisters
Celebrates and promotes African culture through fashion and beauty products

The oxtails dish, served with coconut rice, peas, and sweet potatoes, is a customer favorite at the restaurant. The customer was impressed with not only the delicious food but also the attentive service they received.
Another customer had the opportunity to try the roti chicken and goat. They highlighted the significance of a well-made filling and a flavorful crust, both of which Sisters' restaurant successfully delivered. The customer was clearly satisfied with their meal.
6. Negril BK
Reggae-themed decor and atmosphere inspired by the Negril resort in Jamaica

Caribbean cuisine is celebrated at Negril BK, offering a modern and contemporary dining experience. The restaurant serves authentic Caribbean dishes with a unique twist, accompanied by a wide selection of the finest rums from around the world. Negril BK provides a vibrant and lively atmosphere for patrons to enjoy their meals, making it a popular dining destination.
Spanning across three rooms, Negril BK accommodates over 200 seats and offers several dining options. The tropical-themed dining room is adorned with splashy decor, providing a colorful and festive atmosphere. The lounge area is perfect for socializing and enjoying cocktails, while the private rum speakeasy offers an exclusive and intimate setting for guests to savor their favorite spirits.
TOPICS
- Asian Cuisine
- Budget-Friendly Eats
- Vegetarian Options
7. Caribbean Soul
Offers a taste of the Caribbean in a homey setting

Caribbean Soul is an excellent choice for a surprise birthday dinner or a quick supper to go. The dishes are well-seasoned and expertly cooked, offering a variety of options for any palate. For appetizers, try their perfectly cooked salmon or treat yourself to their succulent crab legs. Their crab pasta is also a popular choice among guests. For dessert, indulge in their tasty waffles, and don't forget to try one of their famous rum-based cocktails, like their strawberry margarita or liqueur.
The staff at Caribbean Soul is known for their friendly service and helpful recommendations. If you're in a hurry, this place is perfect for takeout. Visitors especially love their salmon appetizers, crab legs, and crab pasta, which are all cooked to perfection. Whether you're looking for a romantic dinner spot or a casual place to grab a bite with colleagues, Caribbean Soul offers delicious food and great drinks in a welcoming atmosphere.
8. Karibbean

9. Golden Krust Caribbean Restaurant
Family-owned business serving the New York area since 1989

The food at the establishment is generally described as good and authentic Jamaican cuisine. Many reviewers have praised the taste of the food, highlighting its authenticity. However, there are some guests who have found the food not to be fresh and the portions to be small. Additionally, some reviewers have mentioned a surprise element in their food, but it is not clear if this is a positive or negative experience.
Most guests consider the price to be reasonable for the quality of food and the portion sizes. However, it is important to note that there are differing opinions on the freshness and portion sizes of the food, which could affect the perceived value of the price. Overall, while the food is generally well-liked, there is some variation in the experiences of guests.
10. Tings

The drinks at this establishment are unique and certainly worth trying. However, the food, particularly the ox-tail, was just average. The ox-tail was a bit tougher than expected and had more bone attached to it than desired. That being said, the taste was still enjoyable and the staff, including the friendly guy at the counter, added to the positive experience.
In contrast, the jerk chicken sandwich stands out as one of the best in NYC. It comes highly recommended and is served with delicious coleslaw on a soft, appetizing roll. The jerk seasoning is excellent, providing just the right amount of flavor without being overly spicy. The owner takes a personal interest in customers' satisfaction, checking in to ensure they are happy and clearly delighted when patrons enjoy his food. The service is fast, and the establishment is clean and enjoyable.
TOPICS
- Mexican Cuisine
- Fusion Cuisine
- Downtown Spots
- Dinner
11. Jasmine's Caribbean Cuisine
Offers a taste of the Caribbean in the heart of New York City

The food at this establishment is a highlight, with a variety of options that are well-seasoned and delicious. Some of the popular dishes include jerk wings, shrimp empanadas, oxtail stew, curry shrimp, and sweet potato pudding. However, some guests felt that the service was rushed, which may have detracted from their dining experience.
In terms of the atmosphere, the music is described as excellent, featuring Afro beats and reggae tunes that add to the overall ambiance. Some guests even enjoyed the live music that was performed. However, the space was found to be small and noise levels were high, which may have been a drawback for some guests.
12. Omar's Kitchen and Rum Bar
A unique dining experience combining food, rum, and live music in a relaxed environment

The food at the event was well-received, with many guests praising its authenticity. Popular dishes included jerk chicken, oxtails, and plantain gnocchi. The quality of the food was consistently good, providing guests with a satisfying dining experience.
In addition to the excellent food, the music was a highlight of the event. Guests described it as great and fun, creating a fantastic atmosphere. The Caribbean-themed music, featuring reggae tunes and island vibes, contributed to the event's upbeat and lively atmosphere.
13. Kokomo Caribbean Restaurant
A taste of the Caribbean in the heart of Brooklyn

Kokomo Caribbean Restaurant delivers high-quality dishes on both dinner and brunch services. Standout menu items include their oxtail rasta pasta, wings, mac and cheese, sweet plantain pancakes, shrimp flatbread, ackee stuffed plantains, oxtail flatbread, and lamb chops. Their rum punch is also a popular choice, offering a subtle hint of nutmeg.
The service at Kokomo is consistently top-notch, with attentive staff providing excellent recommendations. Notable team members include Cinquie and Abraham, who contribute to the overall positive dining experience. The extensive menu offers a variety of dishes that have all received high praise, making Kokomo a must-visit Caribbean restaurant.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Waterfront
- Social Gatherings
14. Negril Village
Authentic Jamaican food and vibe in the heart of New York City

Negril Village is a restaurant located in Greenwich Village that offers a unique dining experience with its Nu Caribbean, or 'New York Savvy Caribbean', cuisine. As the latest addition to the Negril chain, the restaurant is known for its entertaining and hip atmosphere, making it a popular destination for those who wish to enjoy delicious Caribbean food in a classy environment.
The food at Negril Village is a highlight, with a wide selection of dishes that are sure to please anyone who loves Caribbean cuisine. In addition to the great food, the restaurant also features a mini club downstairs, providing guests with an enjoyable and mellow atmosphere that is perfect for a date night. With its central location in Greenwich Village, Negril Village is a must-visit destination for anyone looking to experience the best of Caribbean food and culture.
15. Imani
Pet-friendly building with a rooftop terrace

The food served is fresh and hot, with a spicy dipping sauce provided to complement the dishes. Some customers perceive the waiting time between the appetizers and entrees to be reasonable, while others believe it takes an excessively long time for the main course to be prepared. Two highly recommended dishes are the curry chicken and oxtail stew, which are known to be flavorful and delicious. Additionally, the guacamole and plantain are also popular choices among patrons. The staff members are commended for their excellent service, and the atmosphere is described as lively with reggae music playing in the background, setting a pleasant ambiance for dining.
In summary, the food offered is fresh and has a good balance of flavors with a spicy dipping sauce provided. However, there are mixed reviews regarding the waiting time between appetizers and entrees. The curry chicken and oxtail stew are must-try dishes, and the guacamole and plantain are also worth trying. The service is excellent, contributing to a great dining experience. The upbeat atmosphere, created by the reggae music playing in the background, enhances the overall positive experience of the restaurant.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Vegan Options
- Cheap Eats
16. Mangoville
Outdoor dining with a lively street vibe

The individual went to the location after hearing it was open, but unfortunately, they found it closed upon arrival. On a previous visit, the food and staff stood out, making for a positive experience.
Despite the disappointment of the recent closed doors, the individual had enjoyed great food and exceptional service from the staff during a previous visit. The positive qualities of the establishment remain in the individual's memory, with the enjoyable food and commendable staff being key highlights.
17. FyahBun Creative

The service at this establishment is exceptional. The ladies who work there are friendly and create a positive atmosphere. The overall experience is highly pleasant.
The jerk chicken is a must-try dish. It features delicious, spicy, and flavorful meat that is so tender, it falls off the bone. The hot sauce is particularly noteworthy, leaving a lasting impression that will have you eagerly licking your fingers.
18. Miss Lily's 7A Cafe
Popular spot for brunch in the East Village

The food at this establishment is a standout, featuring delicious, homemade, and warm dishes that showcase Puerto Rican flavors. The menu includes popular options such as sancocho, alcapurrias, chicken pastelillos, and sorullos de guava con queso. For a hearty meal, guests can enjoy larger dishes like fried chuleta with rice and beans or mofongo with pernil.
The prices at this establishment are very reasonable, offering great value for the large portions of delicious menu items. The restaurant provides an affordable opportunity to sample authentic Puerto Rican cuisine and enjoy a satisfying meal. Whether you're in the mood for something light and flavorful or a hearty and filling dish, this restaurant has something for everyone at a price that can't be beat.
TOPICS
- Fusion Cuisine
- Dinner
- Late Night
- Downtown Spots
19. Little Ochie
A taste of Jamaica in the heart of Harlem

This establishment is one of the few authentic Jamaican spots left in the neighborhood. The owner, a lady who runs the place, is always a joy to talk to. The menu features a variety of delicious Jamaican dishes, such as curry goat, jerk chicken, chicken soup, cow foot soup, and stew peas. For dessert, they offer potato pudding, sweet potato pie, and carrot cake.
The establishment has recently updated their payment options and now accepts all forms of payments, including credit cards, mobile payment, and cash. This is a big improvement, as cash used to be the only payment form. The food is homemade, making it a great option for those missing home-cooked Jamaican meals. Whether you're a fan of Jamaican cuisine or looking to try something new, this place is definitely worth a visit.
20. Cream Ridgewood
Surrounded by lush greenery and tree-lined streets

Cream Ridgewood is known for its impressive selection of seasonal cocktails and dishes, which are sure to delight even the most discerning of palates. The menu is inspired by the Caribbean background of the restaurant's Executive Chef and master mixologist, offering a unique fusion of flavors from the Caribbean, Latin, and Asian culinary traditions. With a rotating menu that changes with the seasons, Cream Ridgewood provides a delicious and exciting dining experience that keeps diners coming back for more.
The food at Cream Ridgewood is simply delicious, offering a nice selection of fusion dishes that combine flavors from the Caribbean, Latin, and Asian culinary traditions. However, the restaurant can be quite small and fills up quickly, so it's a good idea to make a reservation in advance. One downside to the dining experience at Cream Ridgewood is the loud music, which can make it difficult to have a conversation with your dining companions. Despite this, the delicious food and unique flavor combinations make Cream Ridgewood a dining destination worth visiting.
21. Caribbean Fiesta

Due to the closure of Central Park cafés during Covid-19, my wife and I visited a cafeteria in the Upper East Side, which primarily catered to hospital staff in the area. The cafeteria offered a variety of dishes, and I enjoyed an exquisite goat stew, sweet potatoes, and brown rice, while my wife had fish, rice, and mixed vegetables. The dishes are priced by weight, and our meal cost $16, including soft drinks. We decided to eat by the Harlem Meer.
The food served at this cafeteria was delightful, authentic, and fresh, offering a mix of Caribbean and Soul Food cuisine. There was an extensive selection of meat, seafood, and salads that diners could choose from, ensuring a satisfying meal for all tastes and preferences.
22. Bamboo Walk Caribbean Restaurant
Offers an authentic Caribbean dining experience in Brooklyn

The service at this business is highly regarded by customers, who comment frequently on the attentiveness and hospitality of the staff. The restaurant's atmosphere also receives much praise, with many customers noting its Caribbean-inspired theme.
The ambiance of the establishment is often described as great, beautiful, inviting, cozy, and romantic, with pleasant music contributing to the atmosphere. However, some customers found the music to be too loud.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Downtown Spots
- Gluten-Free
- Mid-Range
23. Veronica's Kitchen
