The best 15 Italian restaurants in Staten Island New York City
Italian cuisine is a beloved staple in New York City, and Staten Island is home to some of the best Italian restaurants in the area. From traditional pasta dishes to hand-crafted pizzas, these establishments showcase the rich flavors and techniques of Italian cooking. Whether you're in the mood for a classic red sauce joint or a modern take on Italian fare, you're sure to find it at one of the many Italian restaurants in Staten Island, NYC.
Toc
1. Patrizia's of Brooklyn
Where guests become family with authentic Italian cuisine.
__NEW TEXT__
A recent visit to a restaurant for a friend's 50th birthday celebration proved to be a delightful dining experience. The menu offered an array of dishes that were all skillfully prepared and bursting with flavor. From the pizza and seafood options to the pasta and steak, every dish was delicious and satisfying. The restaurant's staff went above and beyond to ensure that the birthday celebrant felt special, playing the birthday song no less than fifty times throughout the night.
The quality of the food and the exceptional service from the hostess and waitstaff made for a truly enjoyable evening. This restaurant is a standout on Staten Island, with its abundant and delicious offerings and attentive staff. It's no wonder that it ranks as one of the top establishments in the area. Those seeking a memorable dining experience are sure to be impressed by this restaurant's offerings. It's clear that a return visit is in order to savor even more of what this establishment has to offer.
A recent visit to a restaurant for a friend's 50th birthday celebration proved to be a delightful dining experience. The menu offered an array of dishes that were all skillfully prepared and bursting with flavor. From the pizza and seafood options to the pasta and steak, every dish was delicious and satisfying. The restaurant's staff went above and beyond to ensure that the birthday celebrant felt special, playing the birthday song no less than fifty times throughout the night.
The quality of the food and the exceptional service from the hostess and waitstaff made for a truly enjoyable evening. This restaurant is a standout on Staten Island, with its abundant and delicious offerings and attentive staff. It's no wonder that it ranks as one of the top establishments in the area. Those seeking a memorable dining experience are sure to be impressed by this restaurant's offerings. It's clear that a return visit is in order to savor even more of what this establishment has to offer.
TOPICS
- Budget-Friendly Eats
- Downtown Spots
- Social Gatherings
- American Cuisine
2. Nino's Restaurant
Family-friendly Italian dining since 1994.
__NEW TEXT__
The prices at this establishment are quite reasonable, considering the high quality of the food and the generous portions they serve. The restaurant offers a wide range of delicious dishes, all made with fresh and flavorful ingredients. The service is also top-notch, with friendly and attentive staff who make sure every guest feels welcome.
If you're looking for a delicious Italian meal, this is the place to go. The pollo sorrentino is a must-try, with tender chicken and flavorful sauce that will leave you wanting more. The spinach raviolis are also a standout dish, with fresh pasta and rich, creamy filling. Whether you're celebrating a special occasion or just looking for a satisfying meal, this restaurant is sure to impress.
The prices at this establishment are quite reasonable, considering the high quality of the food and the generous portions they serve. The restaurant offers a wide range of delicious dishes, all made with fresh and flavorful ingredients. The service is also top-notch, with friendly and attentive staff who make sure every guest feels welcome.
If you're looking for a delicious Italian meal, this is the place to go. The pollo sorrentino is a must-try, with tender chicken and flavorful sauce that will leave you wanting more. The spinach raviolis are also a standout dish, with fresh pasta and rich, creamy filling. Whether you're celebrating a special occasion or just looking for a satisfying meal, this restaurant is sure to impress.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Gluten-Free
- Cheap Eats
- Personal Celebrations
3. Trattoria Toscana
Taste of Tuscany in every dish.
__NEW TEXT__
This restaurant is renowned for its excellent food and service. A group of ten people dined there, ordering from both the prix fixe and regular dinner menus. The entrees, including lobster, chicken, and shrimp dishes, were all well-prepared and full of flavor. The appetizers were equally delightful, with offerings like eggplant rollatini, salads, mozzarella dishes, and calamari. The dessert selection was plentiful, with highlights such as Nutella pie, chocolate mousse, cheesecake, and lava cake. The staff and owners were attentive and even provided complimentary after-dinner drinks, adding a personal touch to the dining experience.
The food and service at this establishment are truly exceptional. A party of diners sampled a variety of dishes, including appetizers like grilled octopus and burrata. For the main course, they opted for pasta dishes with parmesan and black pepper, as well as squid ink pasta with half a lobster. The evening concluded with a shared dessert trio. The restaurant's commitment to quality and attention to detail is evident in every dish, providing a memorable dining experience for all who visit. The staff's attentiveness and the owners' involvement only add to the overall positive impression. Diners are sure to leave satisfied and eager to return.
This restaurant is renowned for its excellent food and service. A group of ten people dined there, ordering from both the prix fixe and regular dinner menus. The entrees, including lobster, chicken, and shrimp dishes, were all well-prepared and full of flavor. The appetizers were equally delightful, with offerings like eggplant rollatini, salads, mozzarella dishes, and calamari. The dessert selection was plentiful, with highlights such as Nutella pie, chocolate mousse, cheesecake, and lava cake. The staff and owners were attentive and even provided complimentary after-dinner drinks, adding a personal touch to the dining experience.
The food and service at this establishment are truly exceptional. A party of diners sampled a variety of dishes, including appetizers like grilled octopus and burrata. For the main course, they opted for pasta dishes with parmesan and black pepper, as well as squid ink pasta with half a lobster. The evening concluded with a shared dessert trio. The restaurant's commitment to quality and attention to detail is evident in every dish, providing a memorable dining experience for all who visit. The staff's attentiveness and the owners' involvement only add to the overall positive impression. Diners are sure to leave satisfied and eager to return.
4. Angelina's Restaurant
Raising the standard for fine dining in Staten Island.
__NEW TEXT__
Angelina's Ristorante, located in Staten Island, is a fine dining establishment that has been setting the standard for excellence in the industry for over 20 years. The restaurant's atmosphere is unparalleled, providing a sophisticated and elegant ambiance that is perfect for special occasions or a night out.
The service at Angelina's is exceptional, with staff going above and beyond to ensure every guest has a memorable dining experience. Attentive and professional, the team takes care of every detail with precision and care. The food is equally impressive, with each dish bursting with flavor and freshness. From appetizers to entrees, each dish is crafted with the highest quality ingredients and attention to detail. Overall, Angelina's Ristorante is a top-notch dining destination that is sure to impress.
Angelina's Ristorante, located in Staten Island, is a fine dining establishment that has been setting the standard for excellence in the industry for over 20 years. The restaurant's atmosphere is unparalleled, providing a sophisticated and elegant ambiance that is perfect for special occasions or a night out.
The service at Angelina's is exceptional, with staff going above and beyond to ensure every guest has a memorable dining experience. Attentive and professional, the team takes care of every detail with precision and care. The food is equally impressive, with each dish bursting with flavor and freshness. From appetizers to entrees, each dish is crafted with the highest quality ingredients and attention to detail. Overall, Angelina's Ristorante is a top-notch dining destination that is sure to impress.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- High-End
- Downtown Spots
- Dinner
5. Deluca's Italian Restaurant
Experience the ultimate dining with family-like hospitality
__NEW TEXT__
Delicious and delightful, a dining experience at DeLuca's is not one to be missed. The menu offers a wide variety of options, from classic favorites to off-menu specials, ensuring something for everyone. The food arrives at the table hot and perfectly prepared, a testament to the kitchen's skill and attention to detail.
In addition to the excellent menu, DeLuca's also boasts impressive service. The staff is friendly and attentive, ensuring that every guest's needs are met. The restaurant also offers adequate parking with a private lot in the rear, making it a convenient option for those looking for a worry-free dining experience. The front porch is a charming spot to enjoy a meal, offering a unique and enjoyable atmosphere. Overall, DeLuca's is a top-notch dining destination that is sure to impress.
In conclusion, food enthusiasts will be delightfully satisfied with DeLuca's, a must-try restaurant that offers delicious and excellently prepared dishes. With a varied menu and good service, it is a top choice for dining in. The restaurant's private parking lot makes it an easily accessible destination, and the front porch adds to its charm and appeal. Whether it's your first visit or you're a returning customer, DeLuca's is sure to provide a memorable and enjoyable dining experience.
Delicious and delightful, a dining experience at DeLuca's is not one to be missed. The menu offers a wide variety of options, from classic favorites to off-menu specials, ensuring something for everyone. The food arrives at the table hot and perfectly prepared, a testament to the kitchen's skill and attention to detail.
In addition to the excellent menu, DeLuca's also boasts impressive service. The staff is friendly and attentive, ensuring that every guest's needs are met. The restaurant also offers adequate parking with a private lot in the rear, making it a convenient option for those looking for a worry-free dining experience. The front porch is a charming spot to enjoy a meal, offering a unique and enjoyable atmosphere. Overall, DeLuca's is a top-notch dining destination that is sure to impress.
In conclusion, food enthusiasts will be delightfully satisfied with DeLuca's, a must-try restaurant that offers delicious and excellently prepared dishes. With a varied menu and good service, it is a top choice for dining in. The restaurant's private parking lot makes it an easily accessible destination, and the front porch adds to its charm and appeal. Whether it's your first visit or you're a returning customer, DeLuca's is sure to provide a memorable and enjoyable dining experience.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Downtown Spots
- Lunch
- Dinner
6. Bocelli
Staten Island’s premier Italian dining experience
__NEW TEXT__
Appetizers at Bocelli are a must-try, with options such as creamy burrata, a vibrant seafood salad, and the daily special of octopus carpaccio. Sweet and sour shrimp or calamari are also available for those who prefer something tangy. For a taste of a variety of flavors, the dish for two featuring calamari, baked clams, shrimp, stuffed mushrooms, and mozzarella en carozza is a great choice.
Bocelli's exceptional service and delicious food make it a standout restaurant. The attentive staff caters to diners' every need, creating an impressive and welcoming ambiance. The food is no less impressive, with pristine presentation and thoughtful preparation, making Bocelli a must-visit dining destination.
Appetizers at Bocelli are a must-try, with options such as creamy burrata, a vibrant seafood salad, and the daily special of octopus carpaccio. Sweet and sour shrimp or calamari are also available for those who prefer something tangy. For a taste of a variety of flavors, the dish for two featuring calamari, baked clams, shrimp, stuffed mushrooms, and mozzarella en carozza is a great choice.
Bocelli's exceptional service and delicious food make it a standout restaurant. The attentive staff caters to diners' every need, creating an impressive and welcoming ambiance. The food is no less impressive, with pristine presentation and thoughtful preparation, making Bocelli a must-visit dining destination.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Celebrations
- Downtown Spots
- Mid-Range
7. Da Noi
A taste of Italy in the heart of Staten Island
__NEW TEXT__
The ambiance at this establishment is warm and inviting, making it an ideal spot for a romantic date night. The cocktails are a standout feature, with an impressive selection of both classic and innovative options that are sure to impress.
The food offerings are equally impressive, with a menu that boasts delicious and expertly prepared dishes. The pasta selections, in particular, are not to be missed. The service is top-notch, with attentive and friendly staff who go above and beyond to ensure a memorable dining experience. Overall, it's a fantastic spot for those seeking a cozy and romantic evening with exceptional food and drinks.
The ambiance at this establishment is warm and inviting, making it an ideal spot for a romantic date night. The cocktails are a standout feature, with an impressive selection of both classic and innovative options that are sure to impress.
The food offerings are equally impressive, with a menu that boasts delicious and expertly prepared dishes. The pasta selections, in particular, are not to be missed. The service is top-notch, with attentive and friendly staff who go above and beyond to ensure a memorable dining experience. Overall, it's a fantastic spot for those seeking a cozy and romantic evening with exceptional food and drinks.
8. Cielo
Heavenly dining experience with Central Italian cuisine
__NEW TEXT__
Service at this establishment is often lauded for its friendliness, speed, and efficiency. Guests frequently comment on the excellent service they receive, highlighting the staff's attentiveness and ability to cater to their needs promptly. The service experience is consistently positive, creating a welcoming atmosphere for all who visit.
The food offerings at this location are highly regarded for their quality, taste, and variety. Guests often rave about the excellent food, praising the kitchen for consistently meeting and exceeding their expectations. The menu is diverse, catering to a wide range of dietary preferences and restrictions, while never sacrificing flavor or quality. Overall, the dining experience is a standout aspect of this establishment, leaving guests satisfied and eager to return.
Service at this establishment is often lauded for its friendliness, speed, and efficiency. Guests frequently comment on the excellent service they receive, highlighting the staff's attentiveness and ability to cater to their needs promptly. The service experience is consistently positive, creating a welcoming atmosphere for all who visit.
The food offerings at this location are highly regarded for their quality, taste, and variety. Guests often rave about the excellent food, praising the kitchen for consistently meeting and exceeding their expectations. The menu is diverse, catering to a wide range of dietary preferences and restrictions, while never sacrificing flavor or quality. Overall, the dining experience is a standout aspect of this establishment, leaving guests satisfied and eager to return.
9. La Fontana
Serving fine Italian food with a family touch since 1983.
__NEW TEXT__
The cost of dining at La Fontana is perceived as fair and reasonable by its guests. Patrons often express satisfaction with the pricing, making it a desirable option for those looking for a quality meal without breaking the bank.
The service at La Fontana is highly regarded, with guests praising the staff for their promptness, friendliness, and willingness to accommodate special requests. Waitstaff exhibit patience and kindness, contributing to a positive dining experience. Additionally, the food offerings, including Italian noodles, are well-received and appreciated for their delicious taste and authenticity.
The cost of dining at La Fontana is perceived as fair and reasonable by its guests. Patrons often express satisfaction with the pricing, making it a desirable option for those looking for a quality meal without breaking the bank.
The service at La Fontana is highly regarded, with guests praising the staff for their promptness, friendliness, and willingness to accommodate special requests. Waitstaff exhibit patience and kindness, contributing to a positive dining experience. Additionally, the food offerings, including Italian noodles, are well-received and appreciated for their delicious taste and authenticity.
10. Basilio Inn
Oldest restaurant on Staten Island, established in 1921
__NEW TEXT__
Basilio's is a beloved dining establishment that has been serving the community for over a century. Its longevity alone is enough to pique the interest of any food lover. Upon visiting, guests are greeted with a warm and inviting atmosphere that has been perfected over decades of operation.
The menu at Basilio's features fresh and flavorful dishes that are sure to satisfy. Owner Maurice takes great pride in using only the freshest ingredients, including homegrown tomatoes for his signature red sauce. The homemade pasta is also a standout, with a texture and taste that rivals even the most highly-regarded Italian restaurants. While the interior decor may not be the height of modern design, it more than makes up for it with the high-quality food and exceptional service. Reservations are highly recommended to ensure a table at this popular local spot.
Basilio's is a beloved dining establishment that has been serving the community for over a century. Its longevity alone is enough to pique the interest of any food lover. Upon visiting, guests are greeted with a warm and inviting atmosphere that has been perfected over decades of operation.
The menu at Basilio's features fresh and flavorful dishes that are sure to satisfy. Owner Maurice takes great pride in using only the freshest ingredients, including homegrown tomatoes for his signature red sauce. The homemade pasta is also a standout, with a texture and taste that rivals even the most highly-regarded Italian restaurants. While the interior decor may not be the height of modern design, it more than makes up for it with the high-quality food and exceptional service. Reservations are highly recommended to ensure a table at this popular local spot.
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- Italian Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Downtown Spots
11. Brioso
Authentic Italian dining experience since 1995.
__NEW TEXT__
Brioso Ristorante is a fantastic dining destination for anyone seeking delicious food and excellent service. During a recent family lunch, the restaurant's owner and waitstaff provided attentive and accommodating service, ensuring that everyone in the party was comfortable and able to enjoy their meal and company without feeling rushed.
The value at Brioso is hard to beat, with pre-fixe specials featuring a range of beautifully prepared dishes such as spicy mussels, eggplant, pasta, and pork chop. One standout dish is the pear fiocchetti parmesan. The food is consistently excellent, and the restaurant's elegant decor only adds to the overall dining experience. Whether you're celebrating a special occasion or just looking for a great meal, Brioso Ristorante is an excellent choice.
Brioso Ristorante is a fantastic dining destination for anyone seeking delicious food and excellent service. During a recent family lunch, the restaurant's owner and waitstaff provided attentive and accommodating service, ensuring that everyone in the party was comfortable and able to enjoy their meal and company without feeling rushed.
The value at Brioso is hard to beat, with pre-fixe specials featuring a range of beautifully prepared dishes such as spicy mussels, eggplant, pasta, and pork chop. One standout dish is the pear fiocchetti parmesan. The food is consistently excellent, and the restaurant's elegant decor only adds to the overall dining experience. Whether you're celebrating a special occasion or just looking for a great meal, Brioso Ristorante is an excellent choice.
TOPICS
- Mediterranean Cuisine
- Italian Cuisine
- Lunch
- Dinner
12. La Strada
Authentic Italian dining with a cozy fireplace.
__NEW TEXT__
La Strada is a renowned restaurant on Staten Island, known for its high-quality food and outstanding service. Although the interior may appear slightly outdated, its culinary offerings continue to impress. Popular dishes such as supa de pece, a traditional Romanian fish soup, and the hot antipasto for two, are just a few examples of the establishment's commitment to providing delicious and authentic meals.
The staff at La Strada is frequently commended for their expertise and attentiveness. They manage to juggle multiple parties effortlessly, ensuring that each guest feels valued and well taken care of. The team's professionalism is evident in their ability to maintain a welcoming and comfortable atmosphere, making La Strada a go-to dining destination for both regulars and newcomers.
La Strada is a renowned restaurant on Staten Island, known for its high-quality food and outstanding service. Although the interior may appear slightly outdated, its culinary offerings continue to impress. Popular dishes such as supa de pece, a traditional Romanian fish soup, and the hot antipasto for two, are just a few examples of the establishment's commitment to providing delicious and authentic meals.
The staff at La Strada is frequently commended for their expertise and attentiveness. They manage to juggle multiple parties effortlessly, ensuring that each guest feels valued and well taken care of. The team's professionalism is evident in their ability to maintain a welcoming and comfortable atmosphere, making La Strada a go-to dining destination for both regulars and newcomers.
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- Gluten-Free
- Downtown Spots
13. Enoteca Maria
Nonnas of the World: A unique culinary experience.
__NEW TEXT__
The restaurant in question has consistently provided excellent meals during multiple visits, with a diverse range of cuisines to choose from. On a recent trip, the lunch selection included dishes from Trinidad/Tobago, Turkey, and Italy, all of which were delicious.
The establishment's customer service is also noteworthy. When the original reservation had to be canceled, the restaurant management handled the situation with grace and understanding. This positive experience left a lasting impression and reinforced the desire to support the business. During the visit, the gluten-free options were explored, with the bronzini being a standout choice. Meanwhile, the rabbit dish, which the reviewer is familiar with preparing at home, was also impressive.
The restaurant in question has consistently provided excellent meals during multiple visits, with a diverse range of cuisines to choose from. On a recent trip, the lunch selection included dishes from Trinidad/Tobago, Turkey, and Italy, all of which were delicious.
The establishment's customer service is also noteworthy. When the original reservation had to be canceled, the restaurant management handled the situation with grace and understanding. This positive experience left a lasting impression and reinforced the desire to support the business. During the visit, the gluten-free options were explored, with the bronzini being a standout choice. Meanwhile, the rabbit dish, which the reviewer is familiar with preparing at home, was also impressive.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Gluten-Free
- Mid-Range
- Dinner
14. Cucina Fresca
Feels like dining with family in a cozy, intimate setting.
__NEW TEXT__
Cucina Fresca is a restaurant that consistently delivers an exceptional dining experience. The atmosphere is inviting and sophisticated, perfect for special occasions or an intimate dinner. The restaurant's staff are highly trained, providing attentive and personalized service that makes guests feel welcome and well taken care of.
The menu at Cucina Fresca is a highlight, featuring fresh and flavorful dishes that are sure to impress. Complimentary starters such as fried mozzarella cheese and pork shoulder, along with pizza squares and bread, set the stage for a meal that is both indulgent and satisfying. The restaurant's pizza, in particular, has received rave reviews, with a perfectly cooked crust and a delicious combination of toppings. Overall, Cucina Fresca is a restaurant that truly delivers on every level.
Cucina Fresca is a restaurant that consistently delivers an exceptional dining experience. The atmosphere is inviting and sophisticated, perfect for special occasions or an intimate dinner. The restaurant's staff are highly trained, providing attentive and personalized service that makes guests feel welcome and well taken care of.
The menu at Cucina Fresca is a highlight, featuring fresh and flavorful dishes that are sure to impress. Complimentary starters such as fried mozzarella cheese and pork shoulder, along with pizza squares and bread, set the stage for a meal that is both indulgent and satisfying. The restaurant's pizza, in particular, has received rave reviews, with a perfectly cooked crust and a delicious combination of toppings. Overall, Cucina Fresca is a restaurant that truly delivers on every level.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Gluten-Free
- Mid-Range
- Hidden Gems
15. Fiore Di Mare
A hidden gem blending classic and contemporary Italian cuisine.
__NEW TEXT__
Fiore Di Mare, located on 227 Mansion Ave in Staten Island, is a delightful Italian restaurant that offers a tasteful blend of classic and contemporary dishes in a cozy atmosphere. The menu features a range of dishes from pasta and risotto to seafood and meats, all made with fresh and high-quality ingredients. The restaurant's elegant yet inviting ambiance, with its soft lighting and comfortable seating, makes it an ideal spot for both intimate gatherings and larger groups.
The latest reviews for Fiore Di Mare rave about the restaurant's exceptional service, friendly staff, and delicious food. The picturesque plates and impressive presentation of the dishes are also worth noting. With its warm and welcoming environment, Fiore Di Mare provides a dining experience that is both satisfying and memorable. The restaurant's location on the edge of Staten Island adds to its charm, providing a unique and off-the-beaten-path dining experience. The next time you're in the area, be sure to check out Fiore Di Mare for a taste of authentic Italian cuisine in a cozy and inviting atmosphere.
Fiore Di Mare, located on 227 Mansion Ave in Staten Island, is a delightful Italian restaurant that offers a tasteful blend of classic and contemporary dishes in a cozy atmosphere. The menu features a range of dishes from pasta and risotto to seafood and meats, all made with fresh and high-quality ingredients. The restaurant's elegant yet inviting ambiance, with its soft lighting and comfortable seating, makes it an ideal spot for both intimate gatherings and larger groups.
The latest reviews for Fiore Di Mare rave about the restaurant's exceptional service, friendly staff, and delicious food. The picturesque plates and impressive presentation of the dishes are also worth noting. With its warm and welcoming environment, Fiore Di Mare provides a dining experience that is both satisfying and memorable. The restaurant's location on the edge of Staten Island adds to its charm, providing a unique and off-the-beaten-path dining experience. The next time you're in the area, be sure to check out Fiore Di Mare for a taste of authentic Italian cuisine in a cozy and inviting atmosphere.
TOPICS
- Mediterranean Cuisine
- Budget-Friendly Eats
- Suburban