30 Best Places for Bloody Marys in New York City
Discover the ultimate brunch experience in New York City with Bloody Marys. This cherished cocktail, made with vodka and tomato juice, is served with a twist in the city's top restaurants and bars. From classic to innovative recipes, Bloody Marys in New York City are a must-try for cocktail enthusiasts and foodies alike. Join us as we explore the vibrant Bloody Mary scene in the heart of the Big Apple.
- 1. The Dutch
- 2. The Wren
- 3. Mother's Ruin
- 4. Tiny's & The Bar Upstairs
- 5. White Horse Tavern - Financial District
- 6. The Dead Rabbit
- 7. Dudley's
- 8. Hole In The Wall
- 9. Mom's Kitchen and Bar
- 10. Motel Morris
- 11. Essex
- 12. Boulton & Watt
- 13. Prune
- 14. Cookshop
- 15. Sunday In Brooklyn / Williamsburg
- 16. Russ & Daughters Cafe
- 17. King Cole Bar
- 18. Local NYC
- 19. The Winslow
- 20. Penelope
- 21. North Fork Restaurant
- 22. Underdog
- 23. The Crooked Knife
- 24. The Smith
- 25. Stone Street Tavern
- 26. Sadelle's
- 27. Banter NYC
- 28. The Malt House
- 29. Jacob's Pickles
- 30. Buttermilk Channel
1. The Dutch
Specialize in Dutch and imported cheeses

Sitting outside, we enjoyed a wonderful experience. The food served was of excellent quality, and the bloody marys were particularly noteworthy. Made perfectly with the right amount of spice and a satisfying kick, the bloody marys were a definite highlight of our visit. We look forward to returning again.
If you visit this place, don't miss out on trying their bloody marys. These drinks are expertly spiced and have just the right amount of heat to make them enjoyable. Their bloody marys are a standout feature that deserves appreciation and should not be missed.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Mid-Range
- Lunch
- Dinner
2. The Wren
A trendy date spot with a speakeasy vibe

The Wren is a great spot to visit for a delicious, stiff drink. It's a place that I frequent, especially for their Bloody Marys. During my visits, I've come to appreciate their brunch service. Of all the items on the menu, two stand out to me.
First, their Bloody Marys are exceptional. I keep coming back for this drink, and it's one of the main reasons I choose The Wren for my brunch outings. Second, their black/blood pudding is fantastic. This dish is the other factor that makes me return to The Wren. The quality of these two items is so high that they keep me coming back, even though I could easily go elsewhere.
3. Mother's Ruin
Award-winning gin palace with a speakeasy vibe

The Bloody Marys served at this establishment are truly exceptional. They are skillfully prepared, with just the right amount of spice, providing a delightful start to any brunch. The drink's quality is such that it can be considered among the best I have ever tasted.
If you're a fan of Bloody Marys, you're in for a treat at this place. The cocktails offer a perfect balance of flavors, making them a must-try. I highly recommend giving them a sip next time you're here for brunch.
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- American Cuisine
- Downtown Spots
4. Tiny's & The Bar Upstairs
A hidden gem for craft cocktail and beer lovers

Tiny's serves Bloody Marys that are a popular choice among patrons, known for their distinctive twist that sets them apart. The restaurant's Bloody Marys have gained a reputation for being exceptional, with a spice level that is perfectly balanced to suit most tastes. They make for an excellent start to any brunch.
In summary, Tiny's is known for its unique and delicious Bloody Marys that are a hit with customers. These drinks are expertly spiced, making them a great way to kick off brunch.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Downtown Spots
- Affordable Nightlife
5. White Horse Tavern - Financial District
The White Horse Tavern is known for its literary history and was a favorite spot for famous writers such as Dylan Thomas and Norman Mailer

The White Horse Tavern serves an exceptional Bloody Mary in New York City. The drink is highly recommended for its great flavor and impressive presentation. A recent visitor stopped by the tavern for a quick drink and was delighted with the Bloody Mary's taste and appearance.
In summary, the White Horse Tavern stands out for its top-notch Bloody Mary in NYC. The visitor, who stopped by for a brief drink, was thoroughly satisfied with the cocktail's flavor and presentation. Without a doubt, this establishment should be on anyone's list looking for an excellent Bloody Mary.
6. The Dead Rabbit
One of the world's best bars with a unique and lively atmosphere

If you have a fondness for Bloody Marys, The Dead Rabbit in NYC offers an exceptional version of this classic drink. The establishment's Bloody Mary is widely regarded as one of the best in the city, and it's not hard to see why. With its expertly balanced blend of spices and kick, this cocktail is a standout.
The Dead Rabbit's Bloody Mary is a must-try for any cocktail enthusiast. The spice level is skillfully calibrated, and there's just the right amount of heat to give the drink some punch. From the first sip, it's clear that this is no ordinary Bloody Mary. The carefully chosen ingredients and meticulous preparation result in a truly memorable drinking experience.
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- Happy Hours
- Downtown Spots
- Late Night
7. Dudley's
Popular spot for craft cocktails and live music

Dudley's offers a wonderful brunch experience, with a highlight being their exceptional Bloody Marys. These cocktails are crafted with care and skill, resulting in a perfectly balanced and flavorful drink. The Bloody Marys are expertly spiced, providing just the right amount of heat to enhance the other ingredients.
In summary, Dudley's serves outstanding Bloody Marys at their brunch. The cocktails are well-made, with a well-balanced blend of spices and a satisfying kick. If you're a fan of Bloody Marys, or even if you're just looking to try something new and delicious, Dudley's is definitely worth a visit.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Vegan Options
- Kosher Options
8. Hole In The Wall
Offers unique Filipino-American fusion dishes

For Bloody Mary enthusiasts, the Bloody Mary served at this NYC location is a must-try. Its reputation for being one of the best in the city is well-deserved, as it features a perfect balance of spices and a satisfying kick.
This Bloody Mary stands out from the rest with its carefully crafted blend of spices and well-measured heat. If you're looking to try one of the top Bloody Marys in NYC, this is an excellent choice.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Downtown Spots
- Celebrations
9. Mom's Kitchen and Bar
Popular spot for a modern take on American comfort food

For bloody Mary enthusiasts, Mom's Kitchen and Bar in NYC is a must-visit destination. The establishment is renowned for serving some of the best bloody Marys in the city. The drinks are packed with a strong alcohol taste and an abundance of flavor, making them a favorite among patrons.
Mom's Kitchen and Bar's bloody Marys are a standout feature. Their robust and delicious flavor profile makes them a top choice for anyone looking to indulge in this classic cocktail. The drinks are crafted with care, ensuring a satisfying and enjoyable experience for customers.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Happy Hours
- Downtown Spots
10. Motel Morris
Retro-chic boutique hotel with a vibrant atmosphere

The breakfast fried rice with kimchi that husband ordered was also delicious. The restaurant proved to be a reliable choice for a satisfying brunch, providing a chance to reconnect with friends while enjoying the pleasant fall scenery.
The Bloody Mary served was nice, though not exceptional. It was still an enjoyable drink that added to the overall positive dining experience. I would recommend this place for a decent brunch and hope to have the opportunity to dine there again in the future.
11. Essex
Celebrity chef owned restaurant with a focus on seasonal and locally sourced ingredients

A variety of drinks are available, including mimosas, beer, Bloody Marys, and screwdrivers. However, these drinks are pre-made and may not be served cold. Despite this, the brunch experience is mostly positive. The host, Francesca, is described as being great, and the Bloody Marys are specifically called out for being very good.
One of the standout dishes is the manchego Mac and cheese, which is said to be delicious, and it is recommended to add chorizo to it. Overall, the brunch experience is a good one, with the excellent host and tasty food and drinks being the highlights. However, the lukewarm temperature of the pre-made drinks may be a drawback for some.
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- Mexican Cuisine
- Happy Hours
- Downtown Spots
12. Boulton & Watt
Original site of the first commercial steam engine in America

The bartender at the bar was very welcoming and attentive, contributing to an overall pleasant atmosphere. Accompanying the upbeat environment was a good selection of food, including a Full English Breakfast that, despite being shared, proved too much for us to finish. Bright and airy, the bar was filled with content patrons sipping on drinks and engaging in lively conversation.
During our visit, we tried both a mimosa and a Bloody Mary, taking advantage of the weekend Happy Hour specials. This promotion featured discounted prices for mimosas, Bloody Mary's, and sangrias, all priced at $6. This offer added to the value and enjoyment of our experience at the bar.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Vegan Options
- Dinner
13. Prune
A cozy, charming coffee shop in the heart of New York City with a rich history

The East Village establishment with glass doors opening to the street in summer has been a local favorite for 18 years. It attracts regulars who enjoy sipping Bloody Marys over brunch in a carelessly chic setting. The bar keeps things simple with a concise menu, but their Bloody Mary selection is anything but.
This local favorite has maintained its popularity due to its simplistic menu and high-quality Bloody Marys. For 18 years, it has been a staple in the East Village, with glass doors that open to allow for summertime enjoyment. Its chic atmosphere and regular clientele enjoying brunch and Bloody Marys are just a few of the reasons for its enduring success.
14. Cookshop
Only physical store specialized in professional-grade cookware

Cookshop is known for its exceptional Bloody Marys. What sets them apart is their unique twist on this classic drink. A sip of their Bloody Mary reveals a well-balanced and flavorful experience, with just the right amount of spice. It's the perfect way to kick off your brunch.
If you're a fan of Bloody Marys, you must try Cookshop's version. Their take on this brunch staple is sure to impress. With a flawless blend of spices and a kick that wakes up your taste buds, Cookshop's Bloody Marys are a standout. They're an essential part of any brunch experience at this popular eatery.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Mid-Range
- Dinner
15. Sunday In Brooklyn / Williamsburg
Popular spot for brunch and outdoor dining in Williamsburg

The first establishment offers the best Bloody Mary in the area, providing a drink that is guaranteed to satisfy. The drink's delicious taste has earned high praise from visitors, who continue to return for more. The Bloody Mary is made with high-quality ingredients, which give it a unique and delightful flavor.
Visitors to the area looking for a great Bloody Mary won't be disappointed. The drink's exceptional taste has earned it a reputation as the best in the region. This acclaim is well-deserved, as the Bloody Mary is made with care and attention to detail, resulting in a drink that is both delicious and unforgettable. Whether you're a fan of this classic cocktail or looking to try something new, this Bloody Mary is not to be missed.
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- Italian Cuisine
- Budget-Friendly Eats
- Dinner
16. Russ & Daughters Cafe
A centenarian family-owned appetizing store offering traditional Jewish comfort food

Russ & Daughters Cafe is known for its delicious Bloody Marys. The cocktail is the perfect combination of spices, making it a must-try for visitors. It pairs especially well with the cafe's smoked fish platters, making for a well-rounded and enjoyable dining experience.
The Bloody Marys served at Russ & Daughters Cafe have a unique twist to them. The hint of horseradish adds an extra layer of flavor that sets them apart from other versions of the drink. This unique touch makes the Bloody Marys at Russ & Daughters Cafe a standout choice for those looking to try something new and exciting.
TOPICS
- Downtown Spots
- Vegetarian Options
- Cheap Eats
- Italian Cuisine
17. King Cole Bar
Experience the rich history and charm of this classic New York City piano bar.

The King Cole Bar, located inside the St. Regis, boasts a classic wooden decor, soft lighting, and comfortable seating, creating a relaxing atmosphere for guests. The ambiance is highly valued by patrons, despite some finding the prices to be on the higher side.
Among the top recommendations for visitors of the King Cole Bar is trying their signature drink, the Red Snapper, also known as a Bloody Mary. The bar's version of this classic cocktail is renowned and has earned a well-deserved spot on many must-try lists.
TOPICS
- Holiday Celebrations
- High-End
- Downtown Spots
18. Local NYC
Historic area with modern amenities

If you're in NYC and looking for a great Bloody Mary to start your day, Local is the place to go. Their Bloody Marys have a solid reputation and are a popular choice for brunch-goers. The bar takes pride in their ability to kickstart your day with a delicious and kicky cocktail.
For those who love a good Bloody Mary, Local NYC is a must-visit spot. With amazing cocktails that are perfect for brunch, you can't go wrong. Whether you're looking to cure a hangover or just want to enjoy a tasty drink, their Bloody Marys are sure to hit the spot. So if you find yourself in the city, make sure to check out Local's awesome Bloody Marys.
19. The Winslow
Offers a unique blend of historical charm and modern amenities

The Winslow in NYC is a must-visit destination for Bloody Mary enthusiasts. The bar is renowned for serving some of the city's best Bloody Marys, which have been highly praised for their exceptional balance of flavors and spice.
I was thoroughly impressed with the Bloody Marys at The Winslow. They were perfectly spiced and offered just the right amount of kick. The balanced flavors made each sip a true delight, making it easy to understand why these drinks have gained such a stellar reputation.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Downtown Spots
- Social Gatherings
20. Penelope
Popular spot for brunch with a lively and energetic vibe

The Bloody Marys served at Penelope are highly regarded for their excellent taste and flavor. They strike a perfect balance between spiciness and savoriness, making them a popular choice among patrons. The restaurant's Bloody Marys are known to be a fantastic way to start off brunch, providing a flavorful and enjoyable experience for diners.
Penelope is known for its wonderful Bloody Marys, which are seasoned to perfection. These cocktails offer a great start to any brunch, delighting customers with their perfect blend of spice and savory taste. The reputation of Penelope's Bloody Marys is well-deserved, as they continue to be a standout menu item at the restaurant.
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- Fusion Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
21. North Fork Restaurant
Uses locally sourced and sustainable ingredients

The Bloody Marys served at North Fork are a must-try for any brunch-goers. They are widely recognized for their strong and robust flavor profile, which is sure to impress even the most discerning of drinkers. The cocktails are a standout element of the dining experience, and guests are highly recommended to give them a try.
North Fork's Bloody Marys have gained a positive reputation for their exceptional taste and potency. The cocktails are a delicious and satisfying addition to any brunch meal, providing a burst of flavor that is both strong and delicious. Whether you're a fan of Bloody Marys or looking to try something new, North Fork's version of this classic drink is not to be missed.
22. Underdog
Offers a unique underground speakeasy experience

This review highlights a wonderful cocktail bar located on Stone Street, known for its excellent drink selections. One drink that particularly stands out is their Bloody Mary, which is prepared to perfection. The spice level is expertly balanced, and each glass delivers just the right amount of spiciness.
If you're a fan of Bloody Marys, this bar is a must-visit location. Its hidden charm, coupled with the exceptional Bloody Marys, makes for a memorable drinking experience. It's a highly recommended spot for both locals and tourists alike, especially if you're looking to try an outstanding version of this classic cocktail.
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- American Cuisine
- Budget-Friendly Eats
- Downtown Spots
23. The Crooked Knife
Authentic Swedish cuisine in the heart of New York City

The brunch spot is located in a midtown area, making it a convenient location for city dwellers and visitors alike. The establishment excels in creating well-crafted brunch cocktails that go beyond the typical mimosa or bloody mary. This variety offers patrons a chance to try something new and exciting with their meal.
Apart from the impressive brunch cocktails, the restaurant has a range of non-alcoholic beverages and food items to choose from. Whether you're looking for a savory or sweet dish, the menu has something to satisfy every craving. With its central location and diverse offerings, this brunch spot is a great place to relax and enjoy a meal with friends or family.
24. The Smith
Within walking distance to many popular attractions

The Bloody Marys served at The Smith are a standout option for those who enjoy a well-crafted cocktail. The drink is known for its strong flavor and generous alcohol content, making it a popular choice for many patrons. The Bloody Marys at The Smith are expertly spiced, providing a burst of flavor with each sip. There is a perfect amount of kick to these cocktails, adding an exciting element to the drinking experience.
In summary, if you are a fan of Bloody Marys, The Smith is the place to go. The cocktails are prepared with attention to detail, resulting in a perfectly balanced and flavorful drink. Whether you prefer your Bloody Marys with a little extra spice or a more subtle kick, The Smith has got you covered. The cocktails are sure to impress even the most discerning of drinkers, making it a must-visit destination for fans of this classic drink.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Mid-Range
- Downtown Spots
25. Stone Street Tavern
Historic location with a lively and welcoming environment

Stone Street Tavern is a great spot for a drink, especially if you're in the mood for a Bloody Mary. The bar is known for its flavorful and well-made Bloody Marys, which are a popular choice among patrons. In fact, Stone Street Tavern is widely considered one of the best places for Bloody Marys in the Financial District.
If you're looking for a great Bloody Mary, Stone Street Tavern is definitely worth a visit. The bar's Bloody Marys are a highlight of its menu, and are sure to satisfy anyone looking for a flavorful and well-crafted cocktail. Whether you're a local or a tourist, Stone Street Tavern is a great choice for a drink in the Financial District. Highly recommended!
TOPICS
- Downtown Spots
- Dinner
- Late Night
- Cheap Eats
26. Sadelle's
Popular celebrity spot, high tea service

The hostess at the restaurant can be cautious and unresponsive, so it's important to follow up during the expected wait time or risk being ignored. However, once seated, customers can enjoy excellent food and service. The Tower and French Toast are highly recommended for groups of 4-5 people, and the establishment is known for having the best Bloody Mary drinks.
27. Banter NYC
Known for its extensive rotating tap list

The Bloody Marys at Banter NYC have received rave reviews for their delicious and well-balanced flavor. They strike a perfect balance between spicy, tangy, and savory, making them a must-try for any brunch-goer. The restaurant's Bloody Marys have even been noted as a standout feature of their brunch offering, setting them apart from other establishments in the area.
28. The Malt House
Features a cozy and lively atmosphere with live music on select nights.

The Bloody Marys served at this establishment are highly regarded, especially during brunch. They are skillfully spiced and provide just the right amount of heat. This drink is a standout, offering a perfect balance of flavors and a refreshing quality that is not to be missed.
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- Vegetarian Options
- Happy Hours
- Downtown Spots
29. Jacob's Pickles

The first set of drinks we tried were the Jam Jar and Bloody Mary's. We were impressed with the quality of these cocktails, as they were not only delicious but also had a generous size. The Jam Jar was a fruity and refreshing option, while the Bloody Mary had a spicy kick that added an exciting twist.
Moving on to the food, the service was prompt, and the staff was friendly and attentive. We ordered a variety of dishes, including the burger, fish and chips, and salad. The burger was juicy and flavorful, cooked to perfection with a soft bun that complemented the meat. The fish and chips had a crispy exterior and tender interior, while the salad was fresh and crisp, dressed with a tangy vinaigrette. Overall, we were pleased with the meal's presentation and taste.
30. Buttermilk Channel
