Top 20 restaurants in Theater District NYC
Experience the thrill of the Theater District in NYC and elevate your night out with delectable dining options. Restaurants in Theater District NYC offer diverse cuisines, from classic Italian to modern Asian fusion, ensuring a perfect match for every palate. Immerse yourself in the vibrant atmosphere and indulge in sumptuous meals, making your evening unforgettable as you explore the restaurants in Theater District NYC.
- 1. Carmine's
- 2. Trattoria Trecolori
- 3. Havana Central Times Square
- 4. Glass House Tavern in Theater District
- 5. La Masseria NY in Theater District
- 6. Dos Caminos
- 7. Osteria al Doge
- 8. The Lambs Club in Theater District
- 9. Bond 45 NY
- 10. Cafe Un Deux Trois
- 11. O'Casey's Times Square
- 12. Serafina Italian Restaurant Time Hotel
- 13. Ellen's Stardust Diner
- 14. Victor's Cafe
- 15. Sardi's
- 16. Yard House
- 17. Bar Centrale
- 18. Broadway Lounge
- 19. Sugar Factory New York - Time Square
- 20. Broadway 49
1. Carmine's
Feels like an Italian American wedding feast

Known for its classic Italian-American fare in a bustling setting
The service at this establishment is often described as friendly and prompt, with a few reports of staff being rude or tactless. Despite this, the overall consensus is that the service is pleasant and attentive, making for an enjoyable dining experience.
The food served at this location receives mixed reviews, with some customers praising the quality and taste, while others find it average. The portion sizes, in particular, have been criticized for being overly large. Additionally, there have been some complaints about extra charges for additional condiments such as marinara sauce, which some customers feel is unnecessary and petty.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Corporate Events
- Celebrations
- Downtown Spots
2. Trattoria Trecolori
Authentic Italian dining in the Theatre District.

Family-owned trattoria with a traditional wood-burning oven
The restaurant offers a wide selection of delicious and flavorful dishes, with generous portions that are sure to satisfy. The service is commendable, with staff who are attentive, efficient, and prompt in their assistance. The ambiance, while on the noisy side, is made pleasant by the exceptional service and delectable food.
For those with dietary restrictions, this restaurant is a great option. A vegan diner was able to enjoy a delicious pasta dish during their anniversary dinner, showcasing the establishment's ability to cater to various preferences and needs. Overall, the restaurant excels in offering both excellent food and efficient service, making for a satisfying dining experience.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Mid-Range
- Dinner
Relate link
3. Havana Central Times Square
Best Cuban restaurant and rum bar in NYC.

Energetic atmosphere with live music and dancing.
Reviewers consistently highlight the speed and attentiveness of the service they received. They describe the staff as efficient, always ready to assist and quick to respond to any requests or issues. Certain servers are specifically named as providing exceptional service, contributing to a positive dining experience.
The food offerings are highly praised, with a diverse range of options available to accommodate different dietary preferences. Vegetarian, meat, and seafood dishes are all featured on the menu, ensuring that there is something to please every diner. Additionally, the prices for the meals are considered reasonable, adding to the overall value and satisfaction expressed in the reviews.
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- Mexican Cuisine
- Affordable Nightlife
4. Glass House Tavern in Theater District
Perfect spot for pre-theatre dining in Times Square

Elegant dining in a glass-enclosed atrium with a sophisticated ambiance and diverse menu options.
The Glass House Tavern offers a dining experience that is sure to please. With a menu that features delicious dishes such as branzino and duck, there is something for everyone to enjoy. The wine list is also quite impressive, offering a range of options at reasonable prices. The service at the Glass House Tavern is top-notch, with staff who are attentive and attuned to guests' needs.
Upon entering the Glass House Tavern, one is immediately struck by the warm and inviting atmosphere. The decor is soothing, creating a comfortable environment that makes guests feel right at home. The service is prompt and friendly, with staff who go out of their way to make sure each guest feels welcome and well taken care of. The food is the star of the show, with dishes that are expertly prepared and full of flavor. Overall, the Glass House Tavern is a standout dining destination that is sure to leave a lasting impression.
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- Italian Cuisine
- Mid-Range
- Downtown Spots
Relate link
5. La Masseria NY in Theater District
Bringing the Italian countryside to NYC

Rustic atmosphere with a lively open kitchen
La Masseria is a delightful restaurant that brings the charm of old-world Italy to its diners. With a rustic and relaxed interior design, the restaurant successfully transports its guests to a simpler time. The authenticity of the food is a constant source of praise, as it accurately reflects the flavors and traditions of Italian cuisine.
The wine list at La Masseria is equally impressive, showcasing a collection of 250 bottles that span all regions of Italy. In addition to the Italian offerings, the list also includes a selection of some of the best American and international wines. The thoughtful selection of wines complements the menu and elevates the dining experience for all guests.
TOPICS
- Mediterranean Cuisine
- Downtown Spots
6. Dos Caminos
Authentic Mexican flavors in the heart of Times Square.

Upscale Mexican dining experience with a vibrant ambiance.
Dos Caminos offers delicious, fresh Mexican food with outstanding service. The menu features beautifully seasoned dishes, including the steak tacos and taco salad, both highly recommended. William, a server at the restaurant, is exceptionally knowledgeable and has a delightful personality. He provides excellent recommendations based on personal preferences.
The Baja tacos are a must-try at Dos Caminos, and the atmosphere is both chill and entertaining. The staff, including Ela, are attentive and helpful, ensuring a pleasant dining experience. The service is never intrusive, and guests are allowed to enjoy their meals at their own pace. Dos Caminos is highly recommended for any occasion, including pre-theatre dinners.
TOPICS
- Mexican Cuisine
- Happy Hours
- Downtown Spots
7. Osteria al Doge
Authentic Venetian dining in the heart of Times Square.

The restaurant offers a unique dining experience with its Venetian-inspired decor, providing a touch of Italy in the heart of New York City.
The culinary offerings at this establishment have been highly praised by reviewers for their delicious and expertly prepared dishes. A particular standout among the menu items are the pasta dishes, which have been singled out for their exceptional quality and taste. The balance of quality and quantity in the food servings has been well-received, with diners expressing satisfaction with the ample portions that do not compromise on flavor or presentation.
The service at this restaurant has also earned high marks from customers, who have commented on the attentiveness and efficiency of the staff. Many reviewers have noted that the team goes above and beyond to ensure that patrons are able to make their shows on time, providing not only excellent service but also a high level of convenience. The combination of delicious food and top-notch service has earned this establishment a glowing reputation among diners in the area.
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- Italian Cuisine
- Downtown Spots
Relate link
8. The Lambs Club in Theater District
Upscale American cuisine in a historic setting.

Located in the heart of Times Square, designed by renowned architect Thierry Despont.
Dining at Lambs Club is an experience that can be described as nothing short of fantastic. The fine dining establishment offers exceptional food and service that is sure to leave a lasting impression. Ava, the server, was particularly impressive with her attentive and knowledgeable service, going above and beyond to ensure a memorable dining experience.
The upscale ambiance of the restaurant is charming and intimate, with a huge fireplace that adds to the cozy atmosphere. A drink by the fireplace is the perfect way to warm up and relax before a delicious meal. While the prices may be on the higher end, the quality of food and service makes it well worth the investment. Overall, Lambs Club is a fine dining experience that is not to be missed.
TOPICS
- Corporate Events
- Celebrations
- American Cuisine
- Italian Cuisine
9. Bond 45 NY
Authentic Italian cuisine in the heart of Broadway.

Authentic Italian cuisine with a lively atmosphere and entertainment
Bond 45 NY is located in the heart of the theater district, making it a very convenient option for pre-show dining. The restaurant's interior is tastefully decorated, creating an inviting atmosphere for guests. One standout feature of Bond 4
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Downtown Spots
- High-End
10. Cafe Un Deux Trois
Authentic French brasserie since 1977

Quintessential French bistro experience in the heart of NYC
A beautiful atmosphere and ample seating greet customers at this establishment, accompanied by tasteful and striking decor. The coffee served is of a high standard, boasting a rich and robust flavor profile that is sure to satisfy coffee connoisseurs. Unfortunately, there were some issues with the temperature of the food, as some plates arrived cold at the table. However, the taste of the dishes was largely enjoyable and made up for the slight discrepancies in temperature.
A group of eight ladies dined here before attending a theater performance and found the experience to be a positive one. Each member of the party was satisfied with their meal, with a few standout dishes that truly shone. The mussels were a hit, arriving in a large bowl filled to the brim with savory broth and crispy fries that served as the perfect accompaniment. Additionally, the chicken cordon bleu was a popular choice, complete with a unique and appetizing mustard sauce that added an unexpected twist to the classic dish.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Downtown Spots
11. O'Casey's Times Square
Perfect spot for a quick bite before a show.

During a recent weekend, a visit was made to the popular establishment, O'Casey's, known for its delicious brunch offerings. The experience started off on a positive note with an impressive chicken club and chicken Marsala, both of which stood out for their high-quality ingredients and impeccable preparation.
The flavors were rich and satisfying, with the chicken perfectly cooked to retain its juiciness while delivering a delightful crunch. The accompanying sauces were well-balanced and elevated the dishes to a new level. The presentation was also noteworthy, with each plate arranged with care and attention to detail, making for a visually appealing dining experience. Overall, O'Casey's did not disappoint and is a must-visit for anyone seeking a memorable brunch in the area.
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- Happy Hours
- Lunch
12. Serafina Italian Restaurant Time Hotel
Authentic Italian cuisine in the heart of NYC

Features a wood-fired brick oven, extensive wine list, and gluten-free options.
Serafina Time Hotel in New York was the chosen destination for a celebratory birthday dinner over the MLK weekend. The restaurant proved to be an excellent choice, providing a delightful and satisfying dining experience for all. The appetizers were attractively presented and tasted delicious, setting a high standard for the meals to come. Each dish that followed was met with equal enthusiasm, as the quality of the food and flavor combinations were exceptional.
Serafina never fails to impress, and it's a frequent dining spot while in New York. The extraordinary service and delicious food have consistently made it a reliable restaurant of choice. Its location in the heart of Times Square makes it a convenient option, particularly for those with pre-theatre plans. Due to its popularity, making a reservation in advance is highly recommended to ensure a smooth and enjoyable dining experience.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Downtown Spots
- Mid-Range
Relate link
13. Ellen's Stardust Diner
Home of the world-famous singing waitstaff!

Experience talented singing waitstaff while enjoying American diner fare
The menu offered an extensive selection, catering to a wide range of tastes and preferences. The milkshakes, in particular, were a standout, with rich and creamy textures that were downright decadent. Each sip was a delight, and it was clear that a great deal of care went into crafting these frozen treats.
As for the venue itself, it exuded an air of sophistication and charm. The food was nothing short of amazing, with generous portions and flavors that were expertly balanced and full of depth. And when it came to the entertainment, the singing and performances were top-notch, providing a lively and engaging atmosphere that was impossible to ignore. From start to finish, this was a dining experience that was truly memorable.
TOPICS
- Celebrations
- Downtown Spots
- American Cuisine
14. Victor's Cafe
A culinary voyage to Cuba since 1963

A New York City staple for Cuban food and live music since 1963.
Victor’s Café offers a memorable dining experience, serving exquisite Cuban cuisine that delight the senses. The menu features an array of authentic dishes, such as empanadas, croquetas, tostones, and lechón, which are sure to transport you to the vibrant streets of Cuba. However, it’s their signature oxtail stew that truly sets them apart, along with their flavorful black beans and irresistible fried mature plantains.
At Victor’s Café, the ambiance is as captivating as the food. The café exudes a warm and inviting atmosphere, making it the perfect spot to enjoy a family dinner or a night out with friends. The owners’ passion for their Cuban heritage is evident in every aspect of the café, from the lively décor to the exceptional service. The result is a truly unforgettable dining experience that will leave you craving more.
TOPICS
- Mediterranean Cuisine
- High-End
- Downtown Spots
15. Sardi's
The toast of Broadway since 1921

Iconic pizza place in the heart of Times Square
The food at this establishment has received mixed reviews, with some praising its delightful, perfect, and outstanding quality, while others find it mediocre, terrible, and average. The dishes presented showcase a range of flavors and textures, but opinions on their success vary greatly among patrons.
Service is an area where the establishment generally shines, with many reviewers noting its excellence, attentiveness, friendliness, and accommodating nature. However, some have mentioned slow service during their visit, which may detract from an otherwise positive dining experience. Despite these occasional lapses, the staff's commitment to providing quality hospitality is commendable and appreciated by most guests.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Downtown Spots
- Personal Celebrations
- Mid-Range
16. Yard House
Modern American gathering place with 100+ beers on tap.

Modern decor, rock music playing, great place to watch sports
Vegan options at Yard House are exceptional and worth trying. The lobster garlic noodles, artichoke dip, tacos, onion rings, and dragonfruit lemonade are highly recommended dishes that cater to plant-based diners. These dishes showcase the creativity and attention to detail put into each menu item, ensuring that all guests have satisfying dining experiences.
Yard House is famous for its delicious and expertly prepared chicken wings. The chicken wings are crispy, moist, and full of flavor, making them a popular choice among customers. Moreover, the exceptional service provided by the waitstaff, such as Maya, adds to the overall positive dining experience. Maya's kindness, helpfulness, and attentiveness to customers' needs demonstrate Yard House's commitment to providing excellent service, making it a standout establishment in the restaurant industry. Overall, Yard House is a restaurant worth visiting for its food and service offerings.
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- American Cuisine
- Asian Cuisine
- Downtown Spots
17. Bar Centrale
Hidden gem in the theater district with a speakeasy charm.

Bar Centrale, situated in the theater district's "Restaurant Row," is a well-concealed jewel that exudes an intimate and cool ambiance, reminiscent of a speakeasy. The establishment is known for its fun and unpretentious vibe, making it a popular spot among patrons. With its limited seating, securing a reservation is crucial to guarantee a comfortable dining experience.
The dimly lit and inviting ambiance of Bar Centrale is perfect for those looking to enjoy a drink or two. The atmosphere is both intimate and cozy, providing a welcome escape from the hustle and bustle of the city. The bar's speakeasy-style decor adds to its allure, creating a unique and memorable experience for guests. Whether you're looking to unwind after a long day or enjoy a night out with friends, Bar Centrale is an excellent choice.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Downtown Spots
- Dinner
- Corporate Events
18. Broadway Lounge
Perfect spot for cocktails with Times Square views

The staff at this establishment go above and beyond to ensure a pleasant dining experience. They are accommodating and understanding, making adjustments to meet the needs of their patrons. The menu features a diverse selection of dishes, catering to a range of tastes and preferences. The drinks served are generously poured and packed with flavor, enhancing the overall meal.
This venue is an excellent choice for those seeking a memorable dining experience. The outdoor terrace provides a stunning view of Times Square, making it an ideal location for special occasions. Whether it's a romantic dinner or a celebration with friends, the ambiance and scenery are sure to impress. The staff's attentive service and the menu's delicious offerings further contribute to a truly enjoyable experience.
TOPICS
- Corporate Events
- American Cuisine
- Downtown Spots
- Dinner
19. Sugar Factory New York - Time Square
The Most Instagrammable Restaurant in America

Instagrammable food and decor, family-friendly
The Sugar Factory is a must-visit dining destination, known for its high-energy atmosphere and delicious sweet treats. Guests from across New York flock to this restaurant for its unique and vibrant dishes, as well as its outrageous desserts. One standout offering is the insane milkshakes, which are a favorite among visitors of all ages.
Whether you're celebrating a special occasion or just looking for a fun and delicious dining experience, the Sugar Factory is sure to impress. The restaurant's over-the-top desserts and colorful dishes make for an extremely memorable and Instagrammable experience. From start to finish, every moment at the Sugar Factory is sure to be a delight for the senses.
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- Mexican Cuisine
- Dinner
20. Broadway 49

TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- Mediterranean Cuisine
- Downtown Spots