The 14 best consignment shops in New York City
Consignment shops in New York City are a popular destination for savvy shoppers and trendsetters. These stores offer a unique shopping experience, featuring gently-used, high-quality items at a fraction of the retail price. By selling items on behalf of individuals, consignment shops in New York City provide a sustainable and affordable way to update your wardrobe or home decor. Whether you're looking to score a designer deal or clear out some clutter, these shops are a must-visit.
- 1. Margoth Consignment Shop
- 2. Buffalo Exchange
- 3. Consignment Brooklyn
- 4. Designer Revival
- 5. INA
- 6. Cure Thrift Shop
- 7. Gentlemen's Resale
- 8. What Goes Around Comes Around
- 9. Michael's, The Consignment Shop for Women
- 10. Beacon's Closet
- 11. New York Vintage Inc
- 12. Tokio 7
- 13. Beacon's Closet
- 14. tth Vintage Boutique
1. Margoth Consignment Shop

2. Buffalo Exchange
Buy, sell, and trade fashion on the spot

Buffalo Exchange, a popular clothing store, has received varying reviews from customers. Many commend the store for its friendly and professional staff, like Tayla, who make the shopping experience enjoyable. The store is consistently well-organized and clean, contributing to a positive atmosphere. However, not all reviews are entirely favorable.
Some customers have expressed disappointment with the high prices of items and the limited size diversity available in-store. Additionally, accounts of poor experiences selling items have led some to view Buffalo Exchange less favorably. Despite these criticisms, the store still has its fair share of loyal customers who appreciate the wide selection of clothes and continue to shop there regularly.
3. Consignment Brooklyn
Smart. Sustainable. Style.

The store offers an impressive selection of high-quality, stylish clothing. The brands they carry, such as Ann Demeulemeester, Dries Van Noten, Margiela, Helmut Lang, and Mister Marc Jacobs, are well-known for their exceptional craftsmanship and unique designs. The clothes they sell are both fashionable and durable, making them a great investment for any wardrobe.
The prices reflect the high quality of the clothing, with each item being a worthwhile investment. The store's commitment to offering only the best brands and pieces ensures that customers will be satisfied with their purchases. Whether you're looking for a statement piece or a wardrobe staple, this store has something to offer for every fashion-conscious individual. Overall, the store is a great destination for those who value quality and style in their clothing choices.
4. Designer Revival

The level of care and attention given to customers at this establishment is truly commendable. From the moment one enters, they are made to feel welcome and valued. The owner and staff go above and beyond to ensure each customer has a personalized and positive experience.
The pricing of the merchandise is another standout feature. High-end items such as Chanel boots and Louboutin shoes are available at prices that are surprisingly affordable. These deals offer customers the opportunity to purchase luxury goods at a fraction of the typical retail cost. Overall, the combination of exceptional service and fair pricing make this establishment a standout choice for those seeking a top-notch shopping experience.
5. INA

6. Cure Thrift Shop
Non-profit supporting Type 1 diabetes research

Cure Thrift Shop is a true treasure trove for those who love to hunt for unique and valuable items. This consignment shop is known for its diverse collection of goods, which include vintage clothing, accessories, furniture, and housewares. Whether you're a seasoned thrifter or new to the scene, you'll find something to love at Cure Thrift Shop.
What sets Cure Thrift Shop apart is not only its impressive selection but also its charitable mission. All profits from the shop go towards supporting HIV/AIDS services and research, making every purchase a meaningful one. The staff is knowledgeable and passionate about the cause, and they're always happy to help you find what you're looking for. With its great selection, affordable prices, and commitment to giving back, Cure Thrift Shop is a must-visit for anyone in NYC looking for a rewarding shopping experience.
7. Gentlemen's Resale
New York City's best men's luxury consignment

Gentlemen's Resale provides a unique opportunity for men to elevate their style with high-end fashion items at accessible prices. The store offers a wide selection of brands such as Brunello Cucinelli, Loro Piana, and Gucci, allowing shoppers to find distinctive pieces that suit their taste and budget. By regularly checking for new arrivals and acting quickly, fashion-conscious individuals can make significant improvements to their wardrobe without breaking the bank.
However, there have been instances where the shopping experience at Gentlemen's Resale has fallen short of expectations. Recently, a customer brought several new, labeled garments to the store for consignment, including an expensive Robert Graham leather sport jacket. Unfortunately, when the customer returned to retrieve their unsold clothing, they discovered that the jacket had been damaged while in the store's possession. Despite the staff's acknowledgment of the issue and apologies, the store has yet to offer a satisfactory resolution or reimbursement to the customer, who is now seeking legal action. As a result, potential consignors should exercise caution and carefully review consignment policies before entrusting their items to Gentlemen's Resale.
8. What Goes Around Comes Around
Discover rare luxury pieces from top designers

The vintage denim selection is remarkable, offering a unique range of authentic and stylish pieces. Fans of Chloe's designs from Karl Lagerfeld's era will be thrilled to discover a carefully curated assortment of clothes that reflect the designer's distinct style. The vintage Chanel offerings are simply astounding, featuring a diverse collection of classic and on-trend items that are sure to catch the eye of any fashion enthusiast.
While the price range may be out of reach for some shoppers, the opportunity to own a piece of fashion history is priceless. The store's commitment to sourcing high-quality vintage pieces is evident in the carefully chosen collection of both Chanel and denim items. Anyone looking to add some standout pieces to their wardrobe will appreciate the rarity and authenticity of the items on offer.
9. Michael's, The Consignment Shop for Women
Look like a million without spending a million

Michael's, The Consignment Shop for Women, is a highly-regarded consignment store located on New York's fashionable Madison Avenue. The store has built a reputation for providing a wide selection of high-quality, gently-used designer items from some of the most prestigious brands in the world. Michael's clientele includes many of New York's most prominent and fashionable residents, who trust the store to provide them with access to the latest trends and hard-to-find pieces.
The store's selection is unmatched, featuring an extensive range of designer shoes, handbags, clothing, and accessories from brands such as Christian Louboutin, Chanel, Louis Vuitton, Prada, and Manolo Blahnik. With a keen eye for detail and a commitment to quality, Michael's carefully curates their inventory to ensure that every item meets their high standards. From classic pieces to the latest trends, shoppers are sure to find something that suits their style and complements their wardrobe. Whether you're a seasoned fashionista or simply looking to add a touch of luxury to your everyday look, Michael's has something for everyone.
10. Beacon's Closet
Sustainable fashion with a unique, curated selection

Entering Beacon's Closet in Manhattan is a delightful and luxurious experience. The spacious and stylish interior, enhanced by elegant chandeliers and chic wallpaper, exudes an air of sophistication. This location, unlike its Brooklyn counterparts in Park Slope and the Burg, offers a trendier and more upscale selection of clothing and accessories. With a wide range of prices, shoppers can find both designer items, such as a Marc Jacobs shirt for $35 or Michael Kors shoes, and more affordable options. The store is an inviting space for consignors to sell their gently-used garments and accessories, making it a unique and exciting venue for both buyers and sellers.
Upon visiting Beacon's Closet, one is immediately struck by the vibrant atmosphere and diverse range of offerings. The trendy, fashion-forward music and lively clientele, primarily composed of students, create an energetic and welcoming ambiance. With racks upon racks of clothing and accessories waiting to be explored, shoppers can spend hours searching for the perfect additions to their wardrobes. Delivering a fresh and youthful take on consignment shopping, Beacon's Closet successfully blends a cool and fashionable aesthetic with a fun and engaging in-store experience.
11. New York Vintage Inc

New York Vintage is a gem for those who enjoy shopping for consignment items. The store is meticulously arranged, making it easy for shoppers to browse through the diverse selection of consigned goods. The condition of these items is exceptional, with many appearing to be virtually new. This establishment's commitment to quality is evident in every piece they sell, making it an ideal destination for vintage shoppers.
The store's offerings include an impressive array of rare and hard-to-find vintage pieces. Whether you're looking for designer labels or unique one-of-a-kind items, New York Vintage is sure to have something that catches your eye. The store's selection is constantly changing, so there's always something new to discover. Overall, New York Vintage is a must-visit destination for anyone who loves high-quality vintage clothing and accessories.
12. Tokio 7
Luxury consignment with unique designer finds

Tokio 7 on East 7th Street is an ideal consignment store for luxury designer clothing. While the prices can be on the higher side for second-hand items, the store also offers more affordably priced pieces that don't carry a designer label. All the clothing and accessories available in the store are stylish and high-quality, making it a great place to find unique pieces to add to your wardrobe. The store also offers a selection of Japanese knick-knacks, adding to its charm. The staff at Tokio 7 are known to be friendly and helpful, making the shopping experience even more enjoyable.
Tokio 7 has been a go-to destination during our visits to New York City. We have had great success at this store, having consigned clothing from designers such as Prada, Vivienne Westwood, and Armani. Many of the garments still have their original price tags and have never been worn, making them quite the steal. The store is always organized, clean, and easy to navigate, with garments displayed in a way that makes it easy to browse. Tokio 7's focus on high-end designer clothing sets it apart from other consignment stores, making it a must-visit destination for anyone looking to consign or purchase luxury fashion.
13. Beacon's Closet
Female-owned, locally operated since 1997

The recently opened location of this establishment offers a roomy and airy atmosphere, thanks to its high ceilings and spacious layout. However, the shop's racks are somewhat overstocked, making it challenging to browse through the extensive inventory. It's worth noting that the pricing of their clothing is on the higher end, which might not be ideal for budget-conscious shoppers.
Despite the vast selection of apparel, the quality of some items leaves something to be desired. Many of the blouses, for instance, appear to be worn-out and lackluster, with frilly trims, and faded colors. Moreover, these blouses are being sold for $15 - $20, which is expensive for the quality provided. With such a wide variety of options available, it's crucial to ensure that each item meets shoppers' expectations of quality and value for money.
14. tth Vintage Boutique
Empowering homeless moms through job training and support

TTH Vintage Boutique is an upscale clothing store offering an elegant collection of vintage and designer items. The boutique's thoughtfully curated selection is artfully displayed, making it a pleasure to browse through the racks. The high-quality clothing includes a range of styles and sizes, appealing to various tastes and preferences. The boutique's chic ambiance and top-notch customer service make it a worthwhile shopping destination.
TTH Vintage Boutique is not just a store, but a social enterprise with a mission to empower homeless mothers. Founded and led by Deborah Koenigsberger, the boutique provides job training and employment opportunities to these women, helping them regain their independence and dignity. Visitors to the boutique can feel good about their purchases, knowing they are supporting a worthy cause. Shopping at TTH Vintage Boutique is not just a retail experience but a chance to make a positive impact on the lives of others.