Top 28 gift shops in Ithaca
Discover our curated list of top-ranked gift shops in Ithaca, compiled from extensive research across reputable websites and blogs. Explore outstanding options like The Cornell Store, Angry Mom Records, Five Below, The Brain Shoppe, Buffalo Street Books. Let's explore together!
Toc
- 1. The Cornell Store
- 2. Angry Mom Records
- 3. Five Below
- 4. The Brain Shoppe
- 5. Buffalo Street Books
- 6. Found In Ithaca
- 7. Mama Goose
- 8. The Cornell Store on the Ithaca Commons
- 9. One World Market
- 10. The Sunshines Creative Designs
- 11. 3-D Light-Loose Threads
- 12. Home Green Home
- 13. Bool's Flower Shop
- 14. Ithaca Flower Shop
- 15. Ithacamade
- 16. Pastimes
- 17. Handwork, Ithaca's Artisan Cooperative
- 18. American Crafts by Robbie Dein
- 19. Mockingbird Paperie
- 20. Comics for Collectors
- 21. 15 STEPS
- 22. Marmalade Mercantile
- 23. P&L Supply
- 24. Sunny Days Of Ithaca
- 25. Urban Outfitters
- 26. T-Shirt Express (now Muckles Ink)
- 27. Sparks and Embers
- 28. IthacaN Flea Market by Sunny Days of Ithaca
1. The Cornell Store
Strong connection to Cornell University.

Experience the ultimate Cornell pride at The Cornell Store - your one-stop-shop for all things Big Red. Explore an array of exclusive Cornell swag and trendy merchandise that cater to every fan. Whether you're a student, alumni, or visitor, immerse yourself in the latest collections that hit the shelves monthly. And while you're there, don't miss out on the unique Apple store and a diverse dining selection that promises a delightful culinary journey.
Step into the welcoming ambiance of the Cornell University store, where sophistication meets school spirit. Discover a well-curated range of branded products alongside offerings from top manufacturers. Indulge in a delectable dining experience at the on-site cafeteria, where every bite is a flavorful celebration - despite the slightly upscale price point. Upgrade your shopping and dining outings at the Cornell Store and relish a truly immersive and satisfying visit.
Step into the welcoming ambiance of the Cornell University store, where sophistication meets school spirit. Discover a well-curated range of branded products alongside offerings from top manufacturers. Indulge in a delectable dining experience at the on-site cafeteria, where every bite is a flavorful celebration - despite the slightly upscale price point. Upgrade your shopping and dining outings at the Cornell Store and relish a truly immersive and satisfying visit.
2. Angry Mom Records

Angry Mom Records is a treasure trove for nostalgia seekers and music enthusiasts alike. From vintage tunes to rare finds, this store is a haven for those seeking the magic of vinyl records. With a vast selection at surprisingly affordable prices, this is where music lovers can truly indulge in their passion for quality music.
Nestled on the ground floor of the Autumn Leaves bookstore building, Angry Mom Records exudes an authentic charm that beckons both regulars and newcomers alike. The friendly service and well-organized displays create a welcoming ambiance for customers to explore and discover hidden gems. Step into this musical haven and let the soothing melodies of the past transport you to simpler times.
Nestled on the ground floor of the Autumn Leaves bookstore building, Angry Mom Records exudes an authentic charm that beckons both regulars and newcomers alike. The friendly service and well-organized displays create a welcoming ambiance for customers to explore and discover hidden gems. Step into this musical haven and let the soothing melodies of the past transport you to simpler times.
3. Five Below
Exciting treasure hunt experience

Immerse yourself in the wonderland of savings at Five Below! Don't let the name fool you - this treasure trove is not just for chilly weather gear. Step inside to discover a world where friendly faces and pristine aisles invite you to explore endless possibilities. It's a paradise for gift shopping, boasting unbeatable prices and an eclectic selection that caters to every taste. From trendy teens to picky pals, there's something for everyone - except perhaps the tiniest tots, aged from newborns up to four.
Fuel your gifting genius at Five Below, where every visit is a delightful adventure in value. Let the welcoming ambiance and well-stocked shelves guide you to the perfect present for any occasion. Your go-to destination for budget-friendly shopping, this haven is a surefire way to spread joy without breaking the bank. So why settle for ordinary gifts when you can unearth extraordinary finds at Five Below?
Fuel your gifting genius at Five Below, where every visit is a delightful adventure in value. Let the welcoming ambiance and well-stocked shelves guide you to the perfect present for any occasion. Your go-to destination for budget-friendly shopping, this haven is a surefire way to spread joy without breaking the bank. So why settle for ordinary gifts when you can unearth extraordinary finds at Five Below?
4. The Brain Shoppe

The Brain Shoppe is a charming store filled with captivating puzzles and mystery games on display. Even if you don't make a purchase, trying out the puzzles is a must-do experience. With a variety of brain-related products catering to all ages, from toddlers to seniors, it's a treasure trove of entertainment. From intriguing books to brain-teasers, this store is a haven for anyone looking to sharpen their mind or find a unique gift. Immerse yourself in the store's selection and uncover hidden gems that will keep you engaged for hours.
5. Buffalo Street Books

Buffalo Street Books is a gem in the community, known for its vibrant events and unique book selections. Supporting this independent bookstore is crucial as it has faced challenges in the past. Let's keep this literary haven thriving by investing in our reading pleasures here.
A must-visit for book enthusiasts, Buffalo Street Books stands out for its customer service and curated collection. Discover exclusive finds and engage in a browsing experience unavailable on major platforms. Don't miss the opportunity to explore this literary sanctuary firsthand—your bookshelves will thank you!
A must-visit for book enthusiasts, Buffalo Street Books stands out for its customer service and curated collection. Discover exclusive finds and engage in a browsing experience unavailable on major platforms. Don't miss the opportunity to explore this literary sanctuary firsthand—your bookshelves will thank you!
6. Found In Ithaca
Accepts EBT/SNAP benefits

Discover a hidden gem in Ithaca, a treasure trove with a deceptively spacious interior housing an eclectic mix of unique finds. While some smaller items may come with a higher price tag, larger pieces are priced more affordably, enticing a return visit. Nestled in an industrial park, this antique mall may not be the largest, but it boasts an array of treasures at great prices, complemented by warm and welcoming staff, adding to its charm.
7. Mama Goose
Emphasis on local and sustainable products

Mama Goose is a must-visit for chic children's clothing. Secure your winter essentials early for top-notch quality at unbeatable prices. The friendly staff complements the diverse selection, including locally crafted pieces. Despite a vast inventory, prices may run high, and occasional interactions with staff may not meet expectations, as observed during a delay in service.
With a vast array of items, Mama Goose is a shopping haven. While some staff attitudes may lack warmth, customers appreciate the diverse inventory. Despite occasional delays and subpar interactions, the store offers a variety of quality clothing options, including locally made items.
With a vast array of items, Mama Goose is a shopping haven. While some staff attitudes may lack warmth, customers appreciate the diverse inventory. Despite occasional delays and subpar interactions, the store offers a variety of quality clothing options, including locally made items.
8. The Cornell Store on the Ithaca Commons

9. One World Market

10. The Sunshines Creative Designs

11. 3-D Light-Loose Threads

12. Home Green Home

13. Bool's Flower Shop

TOPICS
- Personal Celebrations
- Celebrations
- Hidden Gems
14. Ithaca Flower Shop

15. Ithacamade

16. Pastimes

17. Handwork, Ithaca's Artisan Cooperative

18. American Crafts by Robbie Dein

19. Mockingbird Paperie

20. Comics for Collectors

21. 15 STEPS

TOPICS
- Mediterranean Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Affordable Nightlife
- Dinner
22. Marmalade Mercantile

TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- Mediterranean Cuisine
- Mid-Range
23. P&L Supply

24. Sunny Days Of Ithaca

25. Urban Outfitters

26. T-Shirt Express (now Muckles Ink)

27. Sparks and Embers

28. IthacaN Flea Market by Sunny Days of Ithaca
