15 most favorite pizza restaurants in Buffalo
"Pizza restaurants in Buffalo" are a staple of the city's dining scene. From classic thin-crust styles to creative gourmet pies, these establishments cater to all tastes. Whether you're a local or a visitor, exploring "Pizza restaurants in Buffalo" is a must-do activity to experience the city's rich cultural heritage and delicious food offerings.
Toc
- 1. La Nova
- 2. JJs Casa Di Pizza
- 3. Joe's New York Style Pizza
- 4. Imperial Pizza - Abbott Road
- 5. Pizza Plant Italian Pub - Canalside
- 6. Hearth + Press
- 7. Brick Oven Bistro
- 8. Frankie Primo's +39
- 9. La Pizza Club
- 10. Wise Guys Pizza
- 11. Gino & Joes Pizza
- 12. Mister Pizza Elmwood
- 13. Bob & John's La Hacienda
- 14. Zahz Pizza
- 15. Daddio's Pizza
1. La Nova
A Buffalo tradition since 1957, where customers are family.
__NEW TEXT__
La Nova Pizzeria is widely celebrated for its exceptional pizzas, known for their generously-sized portions and superior ingredients. The establishment's commitment to quality is evident in every dish, as they use only the freshest ingredients to create their renowned pizzas. Among the most popular options are the honey sesame crust pizza and the chargrilled wings, which have earned critical acclaim for their delicious flavors.
The pizzeria's excellence extends beyond its food, as the staff is equally impressive. Friendly and knowledgeable, they ensure that each order is delivered promptly and with a high level of courtesy. As a result, La Nova Pizzeria has earned an impressive 4.2-star rating based on over 1,000 reviews. The Todaro family's active involvement in daily operations is a testament to their dedication to providing consistent quality to their customers. Therefore, La Nova Pizzeria is a highly recommended destination for pizza lovers seeking a top-notch dining experience.
La Nova Pizzeria is widely celebrated for its exceptional pizzas, known for their generously-sized portions and superior ingredients. The establishment's commitment to quality is evident in every dish, as they use only the freshest ingredients to create their renowned pizzas. Among the most popular options are the honey sesame crust pizza and the chargrilled wings, which have earned critical acclaim for their delicious flavors.
The pizzeria's excellence extends beyond its food, as the staff is equally impressive. Friendly and knowledgeable, they ensure that each order is delivered promptly and with a high level of courtesy. As a result, La Nova Pizzeria has earned an impressive 4.2-star rating based on over 1,000 reviews. The Todaro family's active involvement in daily operations is a testament to their dedication to providing consistent quality to their customers. Therefore, La Nova Pizzeria is a highly recommended destination for pizza lovers seeking a top-notch dining experience.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Italian Cuisine
- Social Gatherings
- Budget-Friendly Eats
2. JJs Casa Di Pizza
Buffalo's Best Pizza since 1953!
__NEW TEXT__
Service is frequently highlighted as a standout aspect of this establishment, with guests consistently praising its speed, friendliness, and high quality. Many reviews specifically use phrases such as "very good" and "super friendly" to describe the level of service they received.
The food at this location is generally described as decent, with a thin crust that is popular among many guests. However, some reviewers have noted issues with food temperature and an excess of cornstarch on the bottom of certain dishes. On a positive note, other guests have raved about the delicious taste of the food and the generous portion sizes.
Service is frequently highlighted as a standout aspect of this establishment, with guests consistently praising its speed, friendliness, and high quality. Many reviews specifically use phrases such as "very good" and "super friendly" to describe the level of service they received.
The food at this location is generally described as decent, with a thin crust that is popular among many guests. However, some reviewers have noted issues with food temperature and an excess of cornstarch on the bottom of certain dishes. On a positive note, other guests have raved about the delicious taste of the food and the generous portion sizes.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Gluten-Free
3. Joe's New York Style Pizza
Authentic New York-style pizza in Buffalo
__NEW TEXT__
Joe's is a top-notch spot for cheese pizza in Buffalo, offering a delicious and satisfying meal at a reasonable price. Their pizzas are prepared with care and attention, resulting in a solid and tasty experience that is often overlooked in favor of other pizza places.
The staff at Joe's are known for being friendly and courteous, creating a welcoming atmosphere for patrons. The restaurant itself is well-maintained, with clean tables and a neat appearance that adds to the positive dining experience. However, it is worth noting that the cashiers could improve their customer service skills to match the rest of the staff's politeness.
Joe's is a top-notch spot for cheese pizza in Buffalo, offering a delicious and satisfying meal at a reasonable price. Their pizzas are prepared with care and attention, resulting in a solid and tasty experience that is often overlooked in favor of other pizza places.
The staff at Joe's are known for being friendly and courteous, creating a welcoming atmosphere for patrons. The restaurant itself is well-maintained, with clean tables and a neat appearance that adds to the positive dining experience. However, it is worth noting that the cashiers could improve their customer service skills to match the rest of the staff's politeness.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Cheap Eats
- Downtown Spots
4. Imperial Pizza - Abbott Road
Buffalo's Best Pizza & Wings for Over 26 Years!
__NEW TEXT__
Imperial Pizza offers a diverse menu with a focus on Buffalo-style pizza, along with an array of sandwiches, subs, wings, wraps, salads, and side dishes. This establishment is perfect for sports enthusiasts, especially Bills fans, looking for a great place to enjoy a meal while watching the game. The welcoming and courteous staff, along with the lively atmosphere, enhances the dining experience.
Tourists and locals alike are drawn to Imperial Pizza on Abbott Road for its delicious food and welcoming environment. The menu offers an abundance of options, making it the ideal location for families and groups. The quality of the food is impressive, and the staff goes above and beyond to ensure guests feel comfortable and satisfied. Whether you're looking for a casual dining experience, a night out with friends, or a family meal, Imperial Pizza provides a top-notch and enjoyable experience.
Imperial Pizza offers a diverse menu with a focus on Buffalo-style pizza, along with an array of sandwiches, subs, wings, wraps, salads, and side dishes. This establishment is perfect for sports enthusiasts, especially Bills fans, looking for a great place to enjoy a meal while watching the game. The welcoming and courteous staff, along with the lively atmosphere, enhances the dining experience.
Tourists and locals alike are drawn to Imperial Pizza on Abbott Road for its delicious food and welcoming environment. The menu offers an abundance of options, making it the ideal location for families and groups. The quality of the food is impressive, and the staff goes above and beyond to ensure guests feel comfortable and satisfied. Whether you're looking for a casual dining experience, a night out with friends, or a family meal, Imperial Pizza provides a top-notch and enjoyable experience.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Cheap Eats
- Social Gatherings
5. Pizza Plant Italian Pub - Canalside
Home of the famous Pod, a unique stuffed pizza.
__NEW TEXT__
The cuisine at this establishment is truly exceptional. Each dish is carefully prepared and presented, resulting in a satisfying and delicious meal. The service is also commendable - staff are attentive, friendly, and make each diner feel welcome. The portion sizes are generous, ensuring that you leave feeling full and satisfied.
Additionally, this restaurant is an excellent choice for families with children. The menu offers options that will appeal to even the pickiest of eaters, and the staff goes out of their way to make young diners feel comfortable and entertained. Furthermore, the location is convenient for those traveling via Metro Rail, and the beer selection is impressive and varied. Overall, this restaurant is a great choice for anyone seeking a memorable dining experience.
The cuisine at this establishment is truly exceptional. Each dish is carefully prepared and presented, resulting in a satisfying and delicious meal. The service is also commendable - staff are attentive, friendly, and make each diner feel welcome. The portion sizes are generous, ensuring that you leave feeling full and satisfied.
Additionally, this restaurant is an excellent choice for families with children. The menu offers options that will appeal to even the pickiest of eaters, and the staff goes out of their way to make young diners feel comfortable and entertained. Furthermore, the location is convenient for those traveling via Metro Rail, and the beer selection is impressive and varied. Overall, this restaurant is a great choice for anyone seeking a memorable dining experience.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Affordable Nightlife
- Downtown Spots
6. Hearth + Press
Authentic Mediterranean flavors with a local twist.
__NEW TEXT__
Hearth + Press is a restaurant that should not be missed when visiting Buffalo. Their pizza is a standout, bursting with flavor in every bite. The dough is cooked to perfection, providing a delightful crunch, while the toppings are always fresh and generously applied. Their expertise in pizza-making is evident in every pie they serve.
The service at Hearth + Press is another highlight. Staff are friendly and attentive, ensuring that every guest feels welcome. The restaurant also offers a convenient way to pay via QR code. During our visit, we indulged in their Buffalo chicken and Meat pizzas, which were both excellent. The meatballs appetizer was also a hit. To pair with our meal, we enjoyed a delicious bottle of wine. The entrance to the restaurant is located in an alley, so keep an eye out for it. If we return to Buffalo, Hearth + Press is sure to be on our list for another satisfying pizza experience.
Hearth + Press is a restaurant that should not be missed when visiting Buffalo. Their pizza is a standout, bursting with flavor in every bite. The dough is cooked to perfection, providing a delightful crunch, while the toppings are always fresh and generously applied. Their expertise in pizza-making is evident in every pie they serve.
The service at Hearth + Press is another highlight. Staff are friendly and attentive, ensuring that every guest feels welcome. The restaurant also offers a convenient way to pay via QR code. During our visit, we indulged in their Buffalo chicken and Meat pizzas, which were both excellent. The meatballs appetizer was also a hit. To pair with our meal, we enjoyed a delicious bottle of wine. The entrance to the restaurant is located in an alley, so keep an eye out for it. If we return to Buffalo, Hearth + Press is sure to be on our list for another satisfying pizza experience.
TOPICS
- Mediterranean Cuisine
- Italian Cuisine
- Downtown Spots
- Dinner
7. Brick Oven Bistro
Unique mix of flavors with a cozy bistro vibe.
__NEW TEXT__
The sausage pizza at this establishment is truly exceptional, boasting one of the best pizza experiences possible. A delightful blend of sweet sauce and expertly proportioned cheese and sauce combination is featured. The crust is thin and crispy, adding a satisfying crunch to each bite.
Brick Oven Bistro is a establishment that comes highly recommended, known for its delicious pizza and calzones. The service team is attentive and friendly, providing a dining experience that is both comfortable and memorable. Pride is taken in ensuring customers are completely satisfied with their meals, making it an establishment that is well worth a visit.
The sausage pizza at this establishment is truly exceptional, boasting one of the best pizza experiences possible. A delightful blend of sweet sauce and expertly proportioned cheese and sauce combination is featured. The crust is thin and crispy, adding a satisfying crunch to each bite.
Brick Oven Bistro is a establishment that comes highly recommended, known for its delicious pizza and calzones. The service team is attentive and friendly, providing a dining experience that is both comfortable and memorable. Pride is taken in ensuring customers are completely satisfied with their meals, making it an establishment that is well worth a visit.
TOPICS
- Mexican Cuisine
- Gluten-Free
- Downtown Spots
- Lunch
8. Frankie Primo's +39
A taste of Italy in the heart of Buffalo.
__NEW TEXT__
Frankie Primo's +39 is an Italian restaurant that has received positive reviews for its delicious food and friendly service. The restaurant can get busy, which may result in slight delays for orders and beverages, but the appetizers and main dishes are usually served quickly. The menu features standout chicken dishes with flavors that evoke home-cooked meals, as well as delightful cannoli.
Both reviewers enjoyed a version of fettuccine Alfredo, which was impeccably cooked with fresh noodles and tender chicken. A side salad was also ordered and received positive comments. Frankie Primo's +39 offers both an outside patio for dining and an inside cooled area, providing flexibility for customers who are sensitive to traffic noise. Overall, the restaurant is recommended for those seeking a comfortable place to relax, enjoy a meal, and experience a taste of authentic Italian cuisine.
Frankie Primo's +39 is an Italian restaurant that has received positive reviews for its delicious food and friendly service. The restaurant can get busy, which may result in slight delays for orders and beverages, but the appetizers and main dishes are usually served quickly. The menu features standout chicken dishes with flavors that evoke home-cooked meals, as well as delightful cannoli.
Both reviewers enjoyed a version of fettuccine Alfredo, which was impeccably cooked with fresh noodles and tender chicken. A side salad was also ordered and received positive comments. Frankie Primo's +39 offers both an outside patio for dining and an inside cooled area, providing flexibility for customers who are sensitive to traffic noise. Overall, the restaurant is recommended for those seeking a comfortable place to relax, enjoy a meal, and experience a taste of authentic Italian cuisine.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Celebrations
- Downtown Spots
9. La Pizza Club
North Buffalo's best pizzeria since 1976.
__NEW TEXT__
La Pizza Club is a popular choice for those seeking delicious, consistent, and affordably-priced pizza in Buffalo. One of the standout menu items is their prototypical Buffalo pizza, which comes with a variety of toppings to suit any taste preference. Additionally, La Pizza Club offers a Wednesday special of a large 1-topping pizza for just $11.99, making it an even more attractive option for pizza lovers.
The quality of the food at La Pizza Club is consistently high, with favorites such as their hot pepper pizza and fried cauliflower. The restaurant's staff is friendly and attentive, often going the extra mile to ensure that customers are satisfied with their dining experience. Overall, La Pizza Club is an excellent choice for anyone looking for delicious pizza at a reasonable price, with consistent quality and great service to boot.
La Pizza Club is a popular choice for those seeking delicious, consistent, and affordably-priced pizza in Buffalo. One of the standout menu items is their prototypical Buffalo pizza, which comes with a variety of toppings to suit any taste preference. Additionally, La Pizza Club offers a Wednesday special of a large 1-topping pizza for just $11.99, making it an even more attractive option for pizza lovers.
The quality of the food at La Pizza Club is consistently high, with favorites such as their hot pepper pizza and fried cauliflower. The restaurant's staff is friendly and attentive, often going the extra mile to ensure that customers are satisfied with their dining experience. Overall, La Pizza Club is an excellent choice for anyone looking for delicious pizza at a reasonable price, with consistent quality and great service to boot.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Budget-Friendly Eats
10. Wise Guys Pizza
Delicious pizza with a signature sweetened sauce.
__NEW TEXT__
Pizza at this establishment is often described as high-quality and delicious, providing guests with a wide variety of toppings to choose from. The crust of the pizza is a topic of debate among some guests, with some praising its thinness and pliability, while others appreciate its crispy texture. Despite the varying opinions on the crust, there is a general consensus that the pizza is exceptional.
The food at this establishment is highly regarded by guests, who consistently note its quality, freshness, and overall taste. The pizza in particular stands out, often being referred to as the best in South Buffalo. Guests appreciate the attention to detail in the preparation of the food, resulting in a dining experience that leaves a lasting impression. The high praise for the food is a testament to the establishment's commitment to providing a top-notch dining experience.
Pizza at this establishment is often described as high-quality and delicious, providing guests with a wide variety of toppings to choose from. The crust of the pizza is a topic of debate among some guests, with some praising its thinness and pliability, while others appreciate its crispy texture. Despite the varying opinions on the crust, there is a general consensus that the pizza is exceptional.
The food at this establishment is highly regarded by guests, who consistently note its quality, freshness, and overall taste. The pizza in particular stands out, often being referred to as the best in South Buffalo. Guests appreciate the attention to detail in the preparation of the food, resulting in a dining experience that leaves a lasting impression. The high praise for the food is a testament to the establishment's commitment to providing a top-notch dining experience.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Budget-Friendly Eats
- Dinner
- Late Night
11. Gino & Joes Pizza
Home of the unique Chicken Finger Pizza
__NEW TEXT__
Gino & Joe's Pizza is a well-loved establishment, known for its delicious offerings such as the chicken hoagie and delectable pizza slices. Some patrons have commented that the combo pizza was a bit watery, but the service received praise for being attentive and helpful.
Gino & Joe's serves up the perfect New York style pizza, with a large, flat slice that features a crispy bottom, ideal for folding. The cheese-to-sauce ratio is expertly executed, providing pizza lovers with everything they could want in a slice.
Gino & Joe's Pizza is a well-loved establishment, known for its delicious offerings such as the chicken hoagie and delectable pizza slices. Some patrons have commented that the combo pizza was a bit watery, but the service received praise for being attentive and helpful.
Gino & Joe's serves up the perfect New York style pizza, with a large, flat slice that features a crispy bottom, ideal for folding. The cheese-to-sauce ratio is expertly executed, providing pizza lovers with everything they could want in a slice.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Budget-Friendly Eats
- Downtown Spots
12. Mister Pizza Elmwood
Serving Buffalo's best pizza for over 46 years!
__NEW TEXT__
Mister Pizza on Elmwood Ave offers a top-notch pizza experience, featuring a satisfyingly crispy crust and generously portioned cup-and-char pepperoni. The pizza's exquisite sauce is truly noteworthy, delivering a burst of rich and delectable flavor with every bite.
Fresh and abundant toppings are the star of Mister Pizza on Elmwood Ave's pies. Each slice boasts a perfect balance of flavors and textures, leaving customers craving more of their delicious creations.
Mister Pizza on Elmwood Ave offers a top-notch pizza experience, featuring a satisfyingly crispy crust and generously portioned cup-and-char pepperoni. The pizza's exquisite sauce is truly noteworthy, delivering a burst of rich and delectable flavor with every bite.
Fresh and abundant toppings are the star of Mister Pizza on Elmwood Ave's pies. Each slice boasts a perfect balance of flavors and textures, leaving customers craving more of their delicious creations.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Cheap Eats
- Downtown Spots
13. Bob & John's La Hacienda
Serving North Buffalo's best pizza since 1972
__NEW TEXT__
A guest at Bob & John's recently had the opportunity to sample their lunch buffet, which included a variety of offerings such as soup, salad, and numerous pizza options. The reviewer found all of the food to be of excellent quality, making a return visit seemingly inevitable.
Fish sandwich enthusiasts will be pleased to know that the establishment's sandwich was also met with high praise. Opting for the larger size, the reviewer was impressed by the generous portions of deep-fried fish, fresh vegetables, and delicious mayonnaise, resulting in a satisfying meal. This experience suggests that Bob & John's offers a range of delicious lunch options that are sure to please any palate.
A guest at Bob & John's recently had the opportunity to sample their lunch buffet, which included a variety of offerings such as soup, salad, and numerous pizza options. The reviewer found all of the food to be of excellent quality, making a return visit seemingly inevitable.
Fish sandwich enthusiasts will be pleased to know that the establishment's sandwich was also met with high praise. Opting for the larger size, the reviewer was impressed by the generous portions of deep-fried fish, fresh vegetables, and delicious mayonnaise, resulting in a satisfying meal. This experience suggests that Bob & John's offers a range of delicious lunch options that are sure to please any palate.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Mid-Range
- Hidden Gems
14. Zahz Pizza
Tasty homemade pizza, wings, subs, and more made fresh!
__NEW TEXT__
Zahz Pizza is a well-known establishment that offers delectable and high-quality pizzas. The double cheese, pepperoni, and mushroom pizza is a customer favorite, featuring fresh and carefully selected ingredients, as well as a flavorful sauce that enhances the overall taste. The staff members are known for their friendly and welcoming demeanor, contributing to the restaurant's overall casual and family-friendly atmosphere.
The customer service at Zahz Pizza is commendable, consistently exceeding expectations and making visitors feel valued and appreciated. The pizza itself is exceptional, with an excellent crust and dough, perfectly balanced sweet sauce, and an abundance of cheese. The cup and char pepperoni adds a delightful twist to the traditional pizza, creating an unforgettable Buffalo-style pizza experience. Overall, Zahz Pizza successfully combines great taste, quality ingredients, and excellent service to provide a memorable dining experience for all.
Zahz Pizza is a well-known establishment that offers delectable and high-quality pizzas. The double cheese, pepperoni, and mushroom pizza is a customer favorite, featuring fresh and carefully selected ingredients, as well as a flavorful sauce that enhances the overall taste. The staff members are known for their friendly and welcoming demeanor, contributing to the restaurant's overall casual and family-friendly atmosphere.
The customer service at Zahz Pizza is commendable, consistently exceeding expectations and making visitors feel valued and appreciated. The pizza itself is exceptional, with an excellent crust and dough, perfectly balanced sweet sauce, and an abundance of cheese. The cup and char pepperoni adds a delightful twist to the traditional pizza, creating an unforgettable Buffalo-style pizza experience. Overall, Zahz Pizza successfully combines great taste, quality ingredients, and excellent service to provide a memorable dining experience for all.
15. Daddio's Pizza
A late-night favorite for pizza lovers.
__NEW TEXT__
Daddio's Pizza in Buffalo is a must-visit for any pizza lover. The cheesy, flavorful slices and perfectly cooked dough make for an unforgettable experience. The owner is welcoming and kind, creating a friendly and inviting atmosphere for all patrons. Even prominent pizza reviewer Dave Portnoy would be impressed with the quality of Daddio's pizza.
Travelers passing through Buffalo will be pleased to know that Daddio's is open late, offering a convenient and tasty option for weary travelers. The staff is accommodating, even providing bleu cheese dip to enhance the pizza experience. The high-quality slices are just as delicious the next day, providing a satisfying snack for the road. Daddio's Pizza is truly a standout establishment in Buffalo.
Daddio's Pizza in Buffalo is a must-visit for any pizza lover. The cheesy, flavorful slices and perfectly cooked dough make for an unforgettable experience. The owner is welcoming and kind, creating a friendly and inviting atmosphere for all patrons. Even prominent pizza reviewer Dave Portnoy would be impressed with the quality of Daddio's pizza.
Travelers passing through Buffalo will be pleased to know that Daddio's is open late, offering a convenient and tasty option for weary travelers. The staff is accommodating, even providing bleu cheese dip to enhance the pizza experience. The high-quality slices are just as delicious the next day, providing a satisfying snack for the road. Daddio's Pizza is truly a standout establishment in Buffalo.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Cheap Eats
- Downtown Spots