The 7 best Italian restaurants in Bushwick New York City
In the heart of Brooklyn, Italian restaurants in Bushwick NYC offer a taste of Italy in a vibrant and eclectic neighborhood. These restaurants, known for their authentic cuisine, inviting atmospheres, and friendly service, provide a culinary escape for locals and visitors alike. From handmade pasta to traditional pizzas, Italian restaurants in Bushwick NYC showcase the rich and diverse flavors of Italian culinary traditions. Whether you're looking for a cozy trattoria or a trendy enoteca, these restaurants are sure to impress.
1. Santa Panza
Cozy trattoria with gourmet pizzas and fresh pastas.

The culinary experience at this establishment is overall delightful, with a wide range of flavors and ingredients that are sure to please any palate. The menu showcases an impressive array of dishes that are both innovative and familiar, allowing patrons to explore new taste sensations while still enjoying comforting classics. The quality of the food is consistently high, with fresh and well-sourced ingredients that are skillfully prepared and beautifully presented.
The service at this establishment is truly exceptional, with staff going above and beyond to provide a welcoming and attentive dining experience. From the moment guests arrive, they are greeted with warm and friendly smiles that immediately put them at ease. The servers are knowledgeable about the menu and are able to provide thoughtful recommendations based on individual preferences. Perhaps most impressively, they are attentive to even the smallest details, ensuring that every aspect of the dining experience is seamless and enjoyable. Overall, the level of service at this establishment is truly top-notch and is sure to leave a lasting impression on diners.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Celebrations
- Downtown Spots
2. Carmenta’s
Authentic Italian-American classics in the heart of Bushwick.

The chicken parm sandwich at this establishment is a must-try for any food lover. It boasts a unique combination of flavors that leaves a lasting impression. The sesame hoagie bread is exceptional, adding a pleasant texture and taste that complements the tender and juicy chicken parm perfectly. It's no surprise that this sandwich is a popular choice among customers.
The pasta dishes here are equally impressive. The pasta is always cooked to perfection, and the sauces are rich and flavorful. In particular, the meatballs have received high praise for their quality. Each meatball is skillfully crafted, with a perfect blend of spices and seasonings that make for a delicious and satisfying meal. Overall, the pasta dishes offer a fresh and incredible dining experience that keeps customers coming back for more.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Lunch
3. Concrete
Where Sicily meets Brooklyn in every bite

Concrete, a New York City eatery, delights with its Italian dishes, particularly the Neapolitan Ragu and Gambere Pistachio. Value-conscious customers appreciate the affordability of their excellent cocktails during happy hour. In fact, this establishment might just be the best Italian restaurant on this side of Milan, offering an experience that could rival even Milanese establishments.
This family-owned gem goes the extra mile to provide top-notch service, enhancing the dining experience. On Wednesdays, live jazz performances infuse the venue with a lively energy. Diners seeking exceptional food and a warm atmosphere should look no further than Concrete, an Italian restaurant that delivers memorable meals and then some.
4. Roberta's
A culinary destination with a laid-back, hip vibe.

This establishment may not have the appearance of a Michelin star restaurant, but it certainly holds that distinction. While it is widely recognized for its pizza, a variety of salads, Italian meats, and even a well-regarded burger are also on the menu. The atmosphere is relaxed, and the staff, who give off a cool vibe, do not come across as pretentious.
The service here is top-notch, with staff who are both friendly and kind. The prices are quite reasonable considering the quality of the food and the prestigious Michelin star designation. Overall, the restaurant offers a unique and enjoyable dining experience.
5. Testo
Enjoy delicious meals with gluten-free options!

Testo offers an exceptional dining experience with its delicious and fresh food. The butternut squash tortelli and fritto misto are standout dishes that showcase the perfect blend of flavors. Each dish is carefully crafted and presented with great attention to detail. The service at Testo is also impeccable, with staff that are attentive, warm, and welcoming. They create a comfortable and inviting atmosphere that makes for a truly enjoyable meal.
Testo is an excellent choice for any occasion, be it a romantic date or a casual meal with friends. The restaurant's playlist adds to the ambiance, creating a lively and energetic vibe. Overall, Testo is a must-visit destination for food lovers looking for a unique and unforgettable dining experience. With its exceptional food and service, Testo is sure to exceed your expectations and leave you craving more. Highly recommended for anyone seeking a memorable meal in a welcoming atmosphere.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Social Gatherings
- Downtown Spots
- Mid-Range
6. Sapore Di Italia
Authentic Italian dining experience in the heart of Brooklyn.

The pizza at this establishment has received mixed reviews, with some praising its flavor and crispiness, while others find it bland or overcooked. Despite this, the food overall is well-prepared and offers a variety of options to choose from, such as pasta dishes, pizzas, and chicken entrees.
The staff at this restaurant are known for their friendly demeanor and commitment to providing high-quality meals to their customers. The diverse menu ensures that there is something for everyone to enjoy, and both the pizza and other dishes have received positive feedback from many diners.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Mid-Range
- Downtown Spots
7. New International Pasta House
Authentic flavors from around the world in every bite.

The seafood at this establishment is consistently delicious and fresh. Whether it's prepared by frying or grilling, the flavors are sure to impress. The restaurant takes care to source high-quality ingredients, resulting in a satisfying dining experience.
The prices at this restaurant are very reasonable, considering the size of the portions and the quality of the food. The staff members are also known for being patient and helpful, making it a great option for those with dietary restrictions or questions. Overall, it's a great choice for anyone looking for delicious and reasonably-priced seafood.